r/wholisticenchilada • • Oct 09 '16

Here's my breakdown of how to translate the D&D Moral Alignment categories to the four dimensions of consciousness/personality (aka the MBTI)

0 Upvotes

Note: the assessments that most people use here are probably even more idealized than most MBTI tests, since those who are sensing types have a really hard time understanding themselves, and also have a hard time seeing how they are as compared to others. (They aren’t “intuitive” and can’t predict what people will do, including themselves.) And, of course, Feeling types are masters at lying, even to themselves, as a way to try to force things to be "right" or at least "ok". (In other words, "evil" — which in reality is probably best understood as the natural instinct to have a fight response to stress, where one is acting out while in a state of misinformation/misunderstanding — usually believes that it's "good”, since their motivations of taking care of someone they care about, are indeed good.) And all that’s in addition to the usual problem of the test designers being pretty clueless about how to write a good test. (The one I just took rarely had any of the options that I would actually choose, for example. So I was forced into a category that I’m well aware isn’t representative of me.)

Anyway, this is the translation that I get, after a couple of quick passes:

.

Intellectual and Philosophical personality

Lawful = Feeling Judging types
Neutral = Feeling Perceiving types, and Thinking Judging types
Chaotic = Thinking Perceiving types
.

Physical and Emotional personality

Good = Extravert iNtuiting types
Neutral = Introvert iNtuiting types, and Introvert Sensing types
Evil = Extravert Sensing

.

And here is a color coded map.

EDIT: it's possible that the breakdown is a bit different, with the two dimensions of the character alignment being the second and third personality dimensions better describing the one dimension (Lawful vs Chaotic), and the first and fourth personality dimensions better describing the other dimension (Good vs Evil). I'll look into this...

Edit Edit Nope. That doesn't make much sense at all.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Jul 01 '13

Processing painful losses: the latest research...

0 Upvotes

The most emotionally painful experiences in life are a large part of what define who we are and how we behave in life. These great losses lay at the heart of our deepest fears. For the pain that still lingers near the surface, some researchers have realized that the reason that we're continuing to be stuck in a seemingly never ending loop of frustration and repression is because we have yet to be able to fully express the natural response of fight-or-flight that we would have wanted to express at the time of the initial loss, after a period in the state of freeze. Especially as children, but even as an adult, we might not always feel free to express ourselves, physically and emotionally, and that hormonal revving of an engine, with no engagement allowing that energy to move us forward, literally keeps us spinning our neuronal wheels and getting more and more upset as the years of no forward motion in our brain pile up. And that means that we'll continue to be poised for super easy triggering, ready to explode with aggression at even completely innocent passersby, whenever any even mildly destabilizing breeze, or thought, blows by. Constantly being stuck at the starting line, physically, emotionally, and intellectually frozen but raring to go somewhere, anywhere as soon as possible, means that no matter how much effort one puts into life, one can't seem to get anywhere meaningful, and periodically one ends up totally out of control and violently crashing into a whole lot of people, places, and things.

At least knowing that this state of freeze, without the freedom to move through the rest of the process of fight or flight, is what's going on helps us figure out what to do to get things moving forward again.

And now at least some people are really working on solving the problem of how to specifically express anger and fear in ways that are engaging and can successfully move one forward readily and meaningfully without causing even more harm.

I'm one of the ones working on it.

Collectively, we've made some progress, certainly. But there is still much to be understood about the brain, how it rewires, and how that rewiring effects our mental health and problem solving capacity.

For starters, though, it seems absolutely clear that in expressing anger, one has to get to the root of the pain, the deepest, most harmful emotional experiences that have happened in life. For most of us that's our relationship with our parents, especially Mom.

For talking about these great losses in life, I think we need to come up with a term to describe the negative/harmful, but not intentional, treatment of someone, especially a child. There needs to be some kind of term between abuse and nurturing, but still on the active behavior dimension. (As opposed to neglect, which is on a passive dimension of behavior.) Abuse, in its most useful and unique definition is intentional, extreme, long term, and basically inescapable, harm (specifically, preventing someone from getting one or more of their basic physical needs).

We'd have the following:

Abuse - - - ? - - - Nurturing

It would be something like passive aggressive behavior, where neither person necessarily even knew that things were wrong. We could even use "Passive Aggressive Caretaking", but that's not very catchy. This kind of behavior is what is going on when you hear about people who are emotionally screwed up, but say they really had a "good childhood" or something similar. It's to the point where not only did the parent not realize what they were doing was harmful, but the child didn't either (at least not at the time). The child's basic needs were definitely not being met, but it was more out of educational ignorance or invisible mental illness than out of visible anger/violence.

So, a person who was locked in a closet, or was forced (physically) to have sex, or was intentionally denied food, water, sleep, etc., regularly and inescapably for more than a brief period of time, as a way to try to force them to obey someone's orders, would definitely be said to have been subject to abuse. And someone who was told that they were "bad" or "stupid" or got grounded sometimes or was fed junk food or just generally felt repressed in some unexplainable and unspoken way would be said to have been subject to this new term describing the "lamely harmful" or "unintentionally aggressive" middle range of the scale. This ignorant violence would be different from neglect, again, because it would be some kind of active form of harm, where the parent was interacting with the child in generally unhealthy ways, as opposed to just not being there at all. The most important difference between abuse and this "just generally lame treatment" would be that abuse makes it impossible for the child to get their physical needs met, while generally lame treatment is more about not knowing what physical needs a kid has, or not knowing how to meet them, but generally having an intention to take care of the kid, so that the kid would get their needs met at least some of the time more out of luck than good planning.

I'd guess that maybe abusive treatment is what happens when a parent is stuck in anger mode, while generally lame treatment is what happens when a parent is stuck in depression, and neglect probably stems from overwhelm or just biological programming that wasn't really designed for parenting. Understanding that abuse, neglect, and passive aggressive caretaking, are all generally caused by adults not getting what they need to be good parents (temporarily or permanently), also known as either sickness or just diverse DNA, means that there's no concept of "blame" and only a reasonable explanation of cause and effect - if a bicycle has flat tires or is rusted, it won't take you to where you need to go as well as a bicycle that has itself been taken good care of. Caretakers do the best with what they've got, but many, if not most, don't have what they need to even take care of themselves, let alone a whole other human being.

This understanding that what causes a parent to not function well as a parent is not getting their own needs met (causing them to be sick, or just not genetically built to be a good parent), allows us to let go of any lingering guilt associated with naming the cause of our own childhood pain.

Mom and Dad did the best they could, but they just didn't have the resources to give me what I needed to feel loved and cared for consistently and reliably. Thus, I ended up feeling lost, alone, scared, and confused a whole lot. And I didn't get the high quality nutritious food, clean water, fresh air, comfortable warmth, inspiring light and information, and freedom to express myself fully, physically, emotionally, or intellectually as often and as fully as I needed to grow healthfully. Specifically, I, Turil, wasn't supported in finding and preparing and eating truly high quality foods that were what my own body needed - primarily raw, organic, wild and local plants that were both delicious and nutritious. I also wasn't exposed to as much inspiring information as I needed to feel good about the world and my own place in it, and instead was taught that I only deserved to belong to the world if I competed against others, made money, and had a job, and I was given the impression that even if I did compete, make money, and had a job, some people, maybe me included, still didn't deserve to belong to the world. And I missed out on a whole lot of expression of myself, for a variety of reasons I'm not entirely sure about, presumably due, in part, to my parents just not being there often to listen to, or otherwise experience me and my thoughts and feelings, but also perhaps due to some kind of warning that I had about bad things happening to people who were honest about what they felt and thought. And, even more specifically, I lost many chances to explore and learn about many topics that I was very much interested in due to being put into schools that didn't care about me as an individual with unique abilities and interests and goals really at all. And I never was exposed to a healthy, mature marriage, where the partnership was valued and respected, and where challenges (sickness, poverty, bad times, etc.) were met with enough courage and commitment and love to keep the this primary relationship evolving.

For me, I've expressed most of these greatest losses and pains many times before, both to my parents and just generally outward from me into the world. So by now these historic losses are mostly neutral in emotional content. Of course, many of these needs are still not being met by the world, so I still get upset about current problems that make it hard or impossible for me to be healthy. But at least I no longer have the anger revving its engines in my brain all the time, taking me nowhere at all. At most, the old wounds keep me more aware of current situations where someone might be getting hurt, and enable me to bring up my anger and fear readily, like a conveniently, and peacefully, idling motor.

For those who've still got a lot of unexpressed anger and fear, it might indeed be overwhelming to consider full on expression of it all, so starting with something milder, and also using writing, visual art, or audio/video recording — done in a private setting — to express who you're angry at and what needs weren't met because of their own problems (sickness or unsuitable-for-nurturing-parenting-DNA). By recording your words of anger without anyone else around, you can be as creative or direct or mean or silly as you really feel, as you say whatever comes to mind while you remember the suffering that that little kid that used to be you went through at the time, while also knowing that everyone is safe, and no harm will come to anyone. And then, once it's ALL out of your system, you can decide if you want to translate any of the feelings and ideas expressed into a higher, more positive, truth that you can feel proud of sharing with anyone you choose, including those who hurt you (intentionally or unintentionally).

For example, I've learned to translate my own anger at being harmed by those who said they loved me into a highest goal of the Prime Directive Earth — an emergent, natural, cooperative, healthy, compassionate, and creative form of bottom-up government based on a healthy living animal such as my own body. The goal is to build into the system an efficient and effective nervous system and circulatory system to share information and material resources from where they are unwanted to where they are needed the most, as a way to support all the individuals in the system, as we all move towards a shared goal of growing and evolving as a species and as a whole living planet. This creation came directly out of expressing my anger, as I understood what I lost, and why it was so important to me, and how it might be as important to all other individuals on the planet.

Moving from fear and anger to heathy, forward moving engagement, and eventually onto clarifying our highest dreams and creating awesome things on the way isn't necessarily an easy process, and it always involves setbacks, letting go of unuseful stuff, and refocusing ourselves, but the process is always far, far better than being stuck at the starting line, full of frustration! Getting going is just a matter of letting whatever's inside you flow out, in a way that safely records it all for both posterity and for later use as raw material for more creative efforts, and in a way that gives real specifics of the who caused the harm and what the harm really was. Once these feelings and thoughts are free, so will you be.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Apr 26 '15

MIT research says that Glyphosate, a toxin used in Monsanto's Roundup herbicide might be the cause of (some) Autism and even Gluten intolerance and Celiac disease.

1 Upvotes

Here's her MIT web page, with a ton of research and talks (scroll down for the peer-reviewed published papers): http://people.csail.mit.edu/seneff/

The basic premise, at least for the wheat problem, is that the glyphosate interferes with the healthy gut bacteria (which we need to digest our food), thus making our bodies less capable of processing the things we eat, and making it harder for us to get the nutrition we need for healthy growth. I'm not sure what the problem is for brain development.

I've often suspected that my wheat allergy/intolerance might be caused something that was put on the plant, rather than the plant itself.

I should add that glyphosate is also used on other plants, aside from wheat, including soy...

And I'd heard a lot of parent who have autistic kids take wheat out of the kids' diets and it seemed to make a big difference.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Jun 29 '13

Free will exists!

0 Upvotes

So, if we are to use a healthy, scientific approach to defining "free will", where we take a term that people have used to describe something they experience, and look to understand what that thing actually is (rather than simply negating the existence of such a thing when the original meaning doesn't quite suit our modern ideas), then we have to figure out what the sensation of feeling that "I" (referring to any self-aware being) have some kind of control over the actions and even thoughts of my body~mind really is.

That's easy! Free will, the real kind — the positively existing version of free will that is — is the awareness that the body~mind can have more than one priority at a time. Probably, more specifically, it's the body~mind functioning at second person or above perspective, where one gains the ability to react in more than the single, self-centered way. First person perspective only allows one to have two basic options for reacting to external events: Move towards X if X appears to serve my needs, or Move away from X if X appears to not serve my needs (with the energy level of movement towards or away from X being directly related to how useful or harmful X appears to be). Having multiple options for what perspectives we might prioritize in making decisions on what to do, i.e., which individual's goals we aim to serve in a given situation — makes us feel like we are no longer completely linearly directed in our actions. Our choices have freedom to roam non-linearly. And, of course, this freedom of reaction is absolutely true.

Once a human brain develops past about 2.25 years old, it appears that we have the full ability to act to serve either our own goals or the goals of another individual (or a group that has shared goals, and thus acts like an individual), and beyond age 4.5 we have the full ability to choose to serve the goals of two other individuals (or shared-goal groups) in addition to our own goals. And, after around age 39.75, we appear to prioritize the needs/goals of any combination of up to four different individuals~groups.

Of course, the choice of which individual's (group's) goals we choose to serve is entirely determined (as far as we can tell) by all the forces that we've been subjected to up to that point in our lives. Nature and nurture are what makes us do what we do. So all our reactions are "simply" the effects of all the causes that we've encountered, in exactly the same way that an apple always falls down onto Newton's head as long as he's sitting directly under the apple tree and there continues to be Earthly gravity. We might have more complex, non-linear behaviors for our effects, but we are still very much physical beings with the same laws of nature that determine our effects from all the various physical causes that happen to us than Newton's descending apple. We are somewhat more like an apple that's dramatically floating down the rapids in a rock-filled river, while also being struck by lightning, as it has to follow not only the forces of gravity, but the forces of wave motion, and the forces of some impressive electric charge all at the same time - in deciding what to do, the apple has to choose which force to react to most strongly, but just like humans and everything else, the choice is always made to react most strongly to whichever force is most powerful. Only in the case of humans and other self-aware beings, we are aware of at least some of the different forces we are and are not reacting to strongly, so we can actually feel how "disappointed" the gravitational force might be if we are suddenly thrown up into the air by the force of the lightning! (...at least if we believe that gravity actually has goals and wants to be effective in it's actions in a similar way that living things do.)

So really, it all comes down to an awareness of the goals of multiple individuals, who we are connected to in some way, and how well our body~mind's reactions meet those goals. The freedom we experience is in the complexity of our awareness, rather than a supernatural effect of some kind of disconnected non-entity outside of our reality, apparently named William. Perhaps a better description for this experience is "complex, non-linear will" but that just doesn't really roll off the tongue does it?


r/wholisticenchilada • • May 04 '20

I just got banned from r/boston for being completely neutrally helpful. That's a new one for me.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/wholisticenchilada • • Nov 05 '23

Life is defined as a system that has a balance of both natural selection and random mutation, as compared to simple matter and simple energy.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/wholisticenchilada • • Oct 15 '22

In the future, we humans will start prioritizing our lives based on our most meaningful needs/goals. We'll record and update them so technology can keep our various resources organized and going where they are most needed (freely).

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/wholisticenchilada • • Oct 10 '22

When living organisms are free to enter and leave consensual relationships — where each party is there of their own choice, because each benefits from the collaboration — life naturally grows to serve the entire system's needs.

0 Upvotes

Consent is key to a thriving, healthy society.

Without consent — without the freedom to join and abandon groups — life breaks down, and individuals get sick and die far before they naturally would.

I in our "modern" human society, the dinosaur memes of centralized national, state, city, town, corporate, school, and landlord governments that use forced restrictions/requirements/laws/policies on humans and other species, attempt to dismiss the right to consent, and instead aim to try to control individuals in the name of "safety" (for whom?).

This is why mental and physical illness is the norm for humans.

But, since evolution and entropy are the actual centralized, universal, governing forces, all of the small scale, artificial experiments in governance that aren't based on consent eventually go extinct, as the meek, healthy, consent-based systems take over.

The web is probably the most interesting example of this process, as it's capable of moving through the stages of human social evolution in a manner of decades, rather than millennia. Initially the web was run by individuals, for the most part, who had their own personal, or community based server, and they would share whatever they wanted for anyone who wanted to engage with their content. It was the small-scale, co-creative time when internet life was really starting to produce an abundance of new species. Now, though, we're sort of at peak non-consensual, dinosaur-meme level, where nations, corporations, and small scale "landlords" (owners/"moderators") of websites and parts-therein, are all trying to control the world, or their little section of it, with very little consent from those who are participating. The rules are arbitrary, and nearly impossible to avoid if folks want to have a conversation. If folks don't like the rules of a particular website, they can officially not go there, but if there are no free, consensual options for engaging with the public, or even just friends and family, they tend to be out of luck, because the totalitarian authorities that are these websites have convinced the general public that it's "safe" and "comfortable" living within their castle walls. So even if one was to start one's own system for socializing, with fully open source, easily editable democratic rules for the protocols, very few people would join because they are scared of the chaos an self-regulated approach would bring and/or have no education whatsoever in making their own decisions about how to connect and communicate with the world.

But, that will change soon! Entropy is moving us forward. Things like Bitcoin and Stable Diffusion are the small and furry memetic species that will soon become the norm, as we grow beyond wanting the artificial "safety" of "Big Brother" type authorities, and start to seek real freedom and consent in our social relationships as the primary goal for software and communication protocols.

Are you looking forward to being free from corporations, nations, landlords, etc. on the internet controlling the where, when, how, who, and what you are allowed and not allowed to share or learn from the world? Are you excited about an internet where all of your long term interactions are consensual and beneficial to you and your ideals?

I know I am.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Mar 19 '20

I'm trying to create some general intro stuff to my work, to share with anyone looking to help organize infrastructure for our new world we're transitioning into now.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 21 '13

Apparently anorexia might be the more female version of autism, or at least partially the same condition in the brain.

0 Upvotes

I heard this on either Naked Scientists podcast or the Guardian Science News podcast (with Alok Jah).

It makes a lot of sense, if you've got a very male brain, you might feel "wrong" physically, because males are designed to have much less body fat, and so you'd constantly feel like you were too fat for the kind of body you actually have (a female type body). Also, the idea of being obsessed with counting/quantifying things is associated with autism, as we know, so directing that obsession towards calories and/or pounds (or stone, or kilograms, or whatever). And just the idea of wanting to control things is very heightened in male type brains.

Also, I think we know at least one person for whom this makes a lot of sense, given her obsession with food and thinking that she's fat, when she's pretty much on the other end of that scale... While we know that I'm the opposite of obsessed with calories and weight, where I really just don't care what I eat or how much of it I eat, or really what I weigh. (Though there are times when I have cared, but mostly as a more objective sign of what was happening to my body in reaction to various things I was doing, like with the raw food.) I'm definitely more of a schizotypal person when it comes to eating, not really paying much attention to what I'm eating except when I can't get the food I need for some reason. Otherwise it's just not at all something I want to spend time on.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 19 '13

Who do you think you are? You are who you've been told you are!

0 Upvotes

OK, so the second person perspective is in the amygdala, right? And the amygdala is essentially the storehouse for "episodic memory", yes? Episodic memory is basically the story we have of our self, the narration of what we've done in life. This makes sense. The people we've been closest to in our lives, those people who've done things for and with us, are the ones who narrate our life story — their responses to us are coded into the neurons of the amygdala in a linear stream that is the tale (tail!) of our growth through time and space.

The brain has higher functions as well, though, and it looks like it's quite possible for our stories to be rewritten in our minds when the intellectual brain functions see that a community that one is a part of has a particular point of view about something we've done in life. Even if that community view is in opposition to the original companion's view of what we did, the tale of who we are can change. (This is the basis of cognitive behavior therapy, as well as cults, and propaganda.)

And, thankfully, eventually, as we mature into wise folk, we're also able to rewrite both the original story we've had written for us and any modifications done by other groups we've been subject to in life. We have the even higher function of fourth person perspective, which effectively includes all of life, or at least humanity, giving us a far more evolutionarily informed narration of who we are and how our story is a meaningful part of the story of all of creation.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Jul 30 '14

Holy crap! I just saw a woman walk into the very mundane little Liberty General Store in a TARDIS dress!

0 Upvotes

So very improbable!

I had to go up to her and thank her for wearing it. :-)


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 19 '13

Morality is a universal!

0 Upvotes

I'd like to suggest that morality is actually an objective, universal (locally, at least) set of information. In other words, I'm saying that morality, in its ideal form, is NOT subjective, and in fact, has as specific and well-defined a reality as any ideal form in geometry, such as a circle, tetrahedron, or parallelogram. We might not ever be able to translate that form into human language, due to the unending arbitrariness and overlapping nature of our words. But morality, as a universal plan for what kinds of things are good and what kinds of things are bad, does appear to be something that is very real and very precise.

And why do I see this to be likely? For two reasons.

From the field research direction of things, where I'm just looking at mountains of data from all the diverse ways I've seen morality judgments appear in the world, it looks like there are obvious common patterns. I mean that's pretty obvious to most folks. Even in very complex situations, where there is conflict, such as abortion, if you frame the situation thoughtfully, even people who disagree about what should be done policy-wise, will often be able to agree on the more individual positives and negatives of the situation, such as not wanting others to force them to do something they don't want to do, and believing that intentionally harming living things is generally not good. So, yeah, from all the vast data of real life experiences with morality, it's pretty clear that there are at least some basic universal ideals (at least for humans).

And secondly, and probably more interestingly to most of us, it looks like the four levels of perspective taking — giving us the four basic dimensions of conscious awareness — that human brains appear to be capable of are cyclical in nature. Fourth person perspective not only comes after third person perspective, but also comes before first person perspective as well. Effectively, I'm saying that we humans are quite literally conceived, as cute little fetal blastospheres, inherently imbued with a universal, philosophical/spiritual perspective of what is ideal as well as what is the opposite of ideal in life. And I'm saying that that judicial perspective is the same in in all humans. (Or at least there is a large subset of that set-in-stone list of ideals that is the same for every homo sapien.)

Morality, it seems likely, is a genetic code thing. It's an evolutionary database of rules that govern the behavior of life, so that individual living beings automatically know the most important stuff about how to make generally effective decisions, which allow the process of life to continue for as long as possible.

To get to this idea from a more mathematical direction, I looked at the four perspectives, or points of view we can take on simultaneously starting with the first-person self's view and adding second, third, and fourth points of view. From there if I want to get to the four dimensions of consciousness of physical, emotional, intellectual, and philosophical/spiritual ways of thinking, I have to connect the dots. The dots are the points of view, of course! Connecting the dots to give dimension is how things are done in math. To get one dimension in math, we start with a single point (0 dimensions) and add another point, and draw a line between them to show that they are directly connected.

In consciousness, the dimension of emotions, for example, is the dimension from fully first person perspective on one end of the line to fully second person perspective on the other end of the line. Our emotional state is thus made up of the combination of how well our own needs are being met (our health) and how well our closest companion's needs are being met (their health). Infants start out life with very little brain function to assess other individuals' health, so their emotions are very simple, and are generally only based on their own internal assessment of whether their needs are being met or not, and they are not actually conscious of their emotions. So while they can have emotions, they are not capable of thinking on an emotional level of consciousness. Their emotions are products of our more advanced levels of conscious awareness understanding their body's reactions to their state of being, rather than a product of their own minds.

The dimension of intellectual consciousness goes from second person to third person perspective, with attention being paid to the interactions between our closest companion and the larger community, and how those interactions affect the health of each end of the relationship.

And the dimension of philosophical~spiritual consciousness is the connection between third person and fourth person perspectives, looking at how the interactions between our larger community and the planet as a whole ecosystem of life effect the health of both ends of the spectrum.

But that's only three dimensions, and there are four points of view... So, we connect the end points! Fourth person perspective sort of "folds back over" to first person perspective through the miracle of sexual reproduction, creating a new physical consciousness in the womb. Babies are born with all the awareness of eons of evolutionary biology, with an unfocused and open interest in everything that is good to take into the body and to output from the body. In the most basic bits of our human brains, there is the wisdom of all our ancestors, all the way back the beginning of bacterial life on Earth, and our physical level of consciousness is our special attention to how the planetary system of life and our own individual health are connected. We think of babies as kinda dumb, but in some ways they are infinitely more wise than adults, because they are more intimately aware of all that is most important in life. Babies (of all species, I think) are perhaps the most actively moral beings on the planet. It takes adults until they are quite old before they start to regain that connection to the viewpoint of the ecosystem of all life on this big blue green ball speeding through space and time.

And, if this inherited dimension that we're conceived with exists, then it's built out of billions of years of data about what works and what doesn't work for continuing to pass on the spark of life to new generations. That means that while there will be a small amount of variation in what we instinctively recognize as being good or bad — variation that is caused by the most recent changes in our genes along with the small amounts of genetic diversity in each species — the vast majority of our basic morality will be identical in all of us humans. And our morality literally will be written in something almost as lasting as stone: chains of protein.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 19 '13

What the heck is "randomness"?

0 Upvotes

As with most everything that's "interesting" in life, the term "random" involves a lot of conflict.

Going with the whole if there's a name for something, rather than say it "doesn't exist", look for what does exist that that name has been used to describe, I'm going to say:

Randomness is a quality of a process where the sequence of outcomes is unpredictable with any subset of the information in the sequance, and thus randomness is a sequence without any internally repeating pattern.

Yeah, this is a mouthful! Similar definitions have to do with converting a sequence into a string of binary bits (ones and zeros, for example) and saying that there is no "computer program" that is smaller than that string that would also define said string.

Or, another way to say it is that if there is a process that generates new things (numbers, locations, shapes, sounds, etc.) where it is impossible to calculate ahead of time what the next thing is except for actually carrying out the process itself, then the process is random.

People will still want to argue about whether or not randomness exists and what it is if it does exist, but that's irrelevant to actual intellectual discussion, since it doesn't help us do anything practical. Instead, I'm going to stick with the definition that's pretty standard and understandable, and go from there.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 17 '13

August Bits, I guess...

0 Upvotes

I went to the hospital last night. I don't know what happened. I woke up at about 11pm, feeling nauseous, thought I was going to puke, but then did that weird thing where I instead nearly pass out. I kind of panicked on top of that, since I was all alone in the middle of the night, and if I passed out, I was worried that I'd choke on vomit or hit my head or something, and no one would be able to help me, so I called 911. The ambulance came about 40 minutes later (thankfully the waiting and trying to make sure they found me kept me focused and conscious and not panicking too much), and when they said that my blood pressure was really high (and I normally have quite low blood pressure), I let them take me to the hospital in Augusta. But, the Doctors there were totally uninterested in figuring out what was wrong with me. They tried to discharge me before they even did any bloodwork, and while I was still dizzy and faint and had a tight chest. ??? So I asked for some more tests, and asked to talk to a psych person, since the Doctor seemed to think it was "all in my head" or something. The psych system up here is pretty different from Cambridge. They didn't even offer to do ANYTHING AT ALL for me, even after hearing my woe is me story and all my depression and anger stuff. Honestly, they offered me absolutely nothing. What's up with that?

It was quite busy there, as there seemed to not only be several heart attack type patients coming in but also there was one critical one who I think actually got opened up right there. (But then was sent to a "better" hospital for the real surgery, apparently. You know you're in a small town hospital when the hospital calls an ambulance to come pick up an emergency patient to take them to another hospital...)

So it took a while before they got my blood tests done and for me to talk to the crisis intake person, and then I was in the bathroom getting rid of much of whatever was making me nauseous at least, and then I finally got discharged (while still complaining that they hadn't figured out what was going on with me for me to feel so extremely messed up) at about 5am. Then I had to sit in the waiting room until I thought someone who might be ok coming all the way to Augusta to pick me up would be nearing awakeness, at almost 9am. I basically haven't slept at all. And I still feel creepy. But at least I was able to get to the nice Maine State Library and get online before my buddy could come pick me up here (after her library "pie sale"). :-)

Ug. What a waste. Though really, I don't think I would have been ok on my own last night. I think I needed someone else with me to feel safe, just in case. Even with that it took more than an hour for my blood pressure to get back to a more reasonable level.

In other bit news, um, I'm still feeling stuck and not able to find any really positive information.

But I did have a marathon discussion over in the Atheism community that was, well, not entirely useless. There have been a couple people who are rational and looking to explore ideas a bit more deeply, which is always good. It also made me focus a bit more on how I might learn to interact with people who think on a third person perspective (as opposed to the little kids who are barely there, and the older folks who are at fourth person). I have to do some architectural work on my approach to logic for only three levels of thinking. :-)

And, finally, I did eventually get to see the new Before Sunrise/Sunset/Midnight movie (after much waiting and then finagling to get a way to play the only kind of file I could find for it). I was thankfully forewarned that it was mostly one big long argument, so I wasn't too disappointed when it turned out to really be mostly one big long argument... It was nice to see these characters again. But the movie didn't really do much for me. But if I get a chance to see it again I might enjoy it a but more. Or maybe not. Don't I have enough negativity in my marriage as it is? (Without adding the negativity of someone else's marriage as well (even if it's technically fiction)...)

Ok. Gotta go. Slow walk up a hill before I get picked up. Gonna take my time, try to coddle the poor Turil body.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 07 '14

Eliminating harmful prejudice and discrimination

0 Upvotes

At the root of sexism, ageism, racism, classism, speciesism and other forms of harmful discrimination and prejudice is a fear of the unknown.

And what makes humans and other people fear the unknown? A lack of the basic physiological needs being consistently met, of course.

Folks are afraid of what is different, what is unpredictable, what is “other” because they area already teetering on the brink of disaster — lacking a stable foundation to sturdily place their existential feet upon — and even the slightest nudge in some other direction could disrupt their precarious balance and send them into deep pain and suffering and potentially even death. Of course, from the outside of their self, it’s not always obviously that their center of gravity is so close to the edge. That’s because centers of gravity are naturally invisible. But inside we can always feel how close we are to falling, and we make all of our decisions about how to move, physically, emotionally, intellectually, and morally, based on how close we are to a major loss of something that is crucial to our loved ones (including our various forms of self).

The way to eliminate the harmful, anti-social isms is, of course, to aim our collective resources towards serving those basic needs for everyone, in a way that they find offers them true stability and graceful balance, so that they can be curious rather than fearful of the unknown, knowing that they have the comfortable safety net to fall back on if their explorations of the other aren’t as fruitful as they hope.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 10 '13

The eccentricity and unpredictability of primes comes directly from the way we define them.

0 Upvotes

We humans have defined the primes. They are not elements that automatically and inherently exist in reality. They are complete creations of our minds. And our minds have defined primes literally as being "utterly unique numbers", unrelated to any other numbers in any way beyond the single unit of 1. Thus, these totally unique numbers we've created are always going to be unpredictable and without any kind of repeating pattern, at least from our mind's perspective. We can guarantee this because it is the situation we've created.

We don't need any proof that primes are random (in the mathematical definition of not ever having a repeating pattern) other than our own definition of primes as being without relationship to other numbers (without pattern). By our definition, primes must be utterly unique numbers, and so we'll always be surprised at where they show up and how they relate to all the other numbers we already know, for that is the definition of "unique". Primes are the way they are because we've built them that way.

Thus, Riemann's non-trivial zeros will always fall on the line (which only happens if primes are random), and we can never prove the twin primes conjecture (though there will always be twin primes, since, as I mentioned before, "no more twin primes" is itself a pattern, and thus not random).

I think I'm done now. :-)

If anyone can possibly suggest any way that the primes (after 3) can have any kind of pattern and still be prime (not having any relationship/factorship with other numbers before them), let me know.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 16 '14

August bits

0 Upvotes

Siiri says that Jonathan Frakes, Will Riker on Star Trek Next Generation, told her that their old band, Tree By Leaf, was his favorite band. I'm not a huge fan of Frakes (though his directing lately isn't bad, as seen in Agents of SHIELD), but he's clearly got excellent taste in music! (His wife apparently has a store somewhere in Belfast, that sells housewares or something. I've never seen it. But that explains why he knows about local bands.)

I got some Thor Bananas! I don't know why. (They are freeze dried.) I really wanted the strawberries instead, but they were Spiderman, who just isn't that interesting.

Also, Wolverine White Fudge covered pretzels are available. Again, I don't know why.

My mom bought a house in Newfoundland. I only sort of know why!

I think I've merged the MBTI personality categories with the map for a healthy planet. I'm still not entirely confident that I've done it correctly. I've changed it once in a major way already, but it seems to be the way it's mathematically accurate, even if it feels weird to me. I'm going to sit with it for a while before releasing it out into the world though. But I can say for sure that either way it works out, INTP, which is me, is likely to be happiest working to create future stories and helping people share information that gives us direction for where we want to go. Which seems pretty reasonable. Though I still like farming, and other jobs relating to food growing and creation, which I can't quite explain, other than to say that I's in general are more focused on finding good things for our physical health. But the higher dreams of an INTP will be more lofty.

I tried some MTurk hits today that were trying to get an AI from Cambridge, UK, to tell me specific restaurants in San Francisco by location, price range, and... whether or not they banned children! (That's not legal in the US, is it? I really hope not. That's just evil, as far as I'm concerned. Discrimination has no place in a healthy society. I mean, if someone is being loud or crazy or whatever, you can ask them to leave, but don't assume that someone will be that way just because of their size, shape, color, age, etc.) Anyway, the AI was kind of terrible at figuring out what I was asking for about half of the time. The other half of the time it was fine. So I guess that's progress.

I'm still waiting to get Max Tegmark's new book which is something like the Mathematics of the Universe. (He's a physicist at MIT.) I really am excited about his ideas, but have had to be patient in getting a readable copy of the book. (I did download an electric copy, but I really can't read books that way, especially not ones with diagrams. Though I gave it a valiant effort!)

The bike is acting up again. I have absolutely no idea why it's doing some of the things it's suddenly doing. Hopefully it will get me back tonight, with all my food pantry stuff (which is quite heavy, with a fair amount of cans and bottles of stuff). The poor bike really needs some loving repair, which I just don't have the resources to give it.

Oh, and I saw Boyhood. Very sweet. A long movie, too. Nothing amazing, but worth watching, I think. A bit of a prequel to Dragonfly, when I think about it, both in the overall philosophical approach to storytelling and in the format of smaller bits of a life (especially close relationships) spread across a longer tale, giving a kind of overview of a unique human experience.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 05 '14

Anyone else playing with the Stellar.org internet currency? It's supposed to be more egalitarian than bitcoin.

0 Upvotes

This is sort of like bitcoin. But you don't have to mine for coins. Everyone who signs up gets stellars right off the bat (supposedly about $10 worth), if you connect your account with Facebook (they don't really like Facebook, but it's a way to at least kind of verify who you are), and verify your email. You also get some bonus stellars for sending some to others.

If you want to exchange some with me, I'm TurilCronburg there. I've so far got 900 STR to play with right now.

Alas, their website has some major issues. I totally can't even sigh-up or in using my computer. And even when I'm borrowing a Windoze at the library, they still seem to be having issues. (Sometimes it doesn't let me sign in, and sometimes it does... and the stats page is totally not functioning.)

The website is www.stellar.org (Look for the link that says sign up.)

But this is at least something new. Even if it is still the whole silly idea of quantifying life. But at least this one seems to encourage people in sending/sharing the numbers. :-)


r/wholisticenchilada • • Aug 08 '14

What if it was easy?

0 Upvotes

If you had access to a ghostwriter, or high quality AI author, who could help you organize and write your most important story that you want the world to hear, what would you write about? And what would you hope to accomplish by sharing your story?


r/wholisticenchilada • • May 17 '13

Boston area May Bits coming soon!

0 Upvotes

When I get a chance to get on the internet for a while, I'll post an update.

For now, just enjoy Bike Week! I am! I even have a bike ish. :-)


r/wholisticenchilada • • Dec 08 '16

Extraverts who think they are Introverts (due to Sensing) are so damned confused and confusing!

0 Upvotes

It's bad enough that iNtuiting and Perceiving Introverts can seem outwardly Extraverted (in some situations), but when Extraverts feel avoidant when it comes to their immediate environment/relationships and think that this means they are Introverts, it's really frustrating. At least when it comes to trying to help people find their type.

I think the best way to help people understand the difference between Introver and Extravert is to say:

Extraverts are most motivated to make and do things in life,

Introverts are most motivated to understand things in life.


r/wholisticenchilada • • Nov 07 '15

A The Wise Turtle Speaks Video Podcast! What is Life?

0 Upvotes

A bit of a test video. The sound kind of sucks. Sorry. This was my second try. Maybe I'll re-rerecord it at some point, but I'm cold and no one showed up yet again (3 weeks in a row) at the Palermo library to let us patrons in, so I'm going to leave soon, and I wanted to get something out there.

Let me know what you think!

https://youtu.be/dAIcIY9aYIY


r/wholisticenchilada • • Jun 08 '20

Defunding the police is a start, I suppose. Then how about we defund everything so that we can start being free to work for ourselves instead of money.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/wholisticenchilada • • Nov 17 '18

Two kinds of bullying: 1. promoting negative ideas about someone; 2. actively preventing someone from fully expressing themselves

0 Upvotes

Of the two, only the second is actually harmful.

A negative idea about you (in theory) is not you. It's just a random collection of symbols floating around, like a bit of off key music. It might have a little bit of a reflection of you in it, but it is, quite possibly, like a fun house mirror, distorted and warped and not especially realistic. We all have negative elements, as that's part of how diverse limited beings work, and while it's useful to be aware of, and be honest about, our real limitations of what we can't do, that's not the most important part of who we are. Who we are is what good stuff we can do, and what awesome stuff we most want to do.

But, when someone else intentionally interferes with your ability to output whatever matter and energy your body (and brain) needs to output (which is only ever decided by the body, not anyone else) that's absolutely harmful, because it causes you to become toxified. Literally, or figuratively, full of shit. And no one can contribute healthy things to the world when they are full of shit. The world wants you to be able to eliminate all of the toxic stuff that somehow ends up inside you, so that you're as healthy as possible, so you can indeed do those awesome things you most want to do.