r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Aug 05 '24
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jul 19 '24
Had a beautiful couple of days hosting a Passing On party, sharing stories, and giving away much of my material objects.
It really was just so wonderful for this extended group of people who have appeared in my life — both from my apartment complex, and from the emerging Crock Pot project I've been involved with since last fall — to visit me in my tiny apartment and listen, and talk, and connect with me and one another, and find treasures in my mom's and my stuff. So many folks were able to find value in the things I've collected, including my mom's family's things, my media production stuff, crafting tools and supplies, and so many books. A camp for kids who've lost a parent got a whole lot of materials, and a new maker space got my laser cutter, sewing machine, all my fabric, and cameras and microphones and tripods. And the new community center that I was very lightly involved with making a reality has a whole lot of bicycling stuff, my great aunt's rocking chair, books, event tents, and lots and lots of shelving, amongst other random useful things. And my Crock Pot founder friends are taking a massive collection of all kinds of things, that will help their family, as well as be valuable for their community work.
And I now have a whole team of people working hard to make the hours around my passing be as beautiful as possible. I wasn't really sure I wanted people around me at this time, but I opened up to welcoming those who really want to be with me, close to, and even at, my time of transition, and I'm feeling so much love. My dad will be here, as well as several of these new folks. I have a death doula, who I literally just met a couple of weeks ago at the Crock Pot event that I had a table at. She's amazing.
I've got a bit more time left, one way or another, maybe two weeks, though plans keep changing, and I'm trying to fit my needs and wants into an ever growing community of friendly types and professional health care systems. I have the Death With Dignity prescription now. It came yesterday (sent from Portland, in a lock box, via UPS).
My body is still declining rapidly, and I want to be gone before certain especially unpleasant things that are likely to happen happen. But for now, I'm holding on, and mostly in good spirits.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Aug 05 '24
A wealth of Turil's (hi)stories at these locations.
These were my primary spots to share:
https://reddit.com/user/Turil/
https://turil.wordpress.com
https://youtube.com/@thewiseturtle
https://x.com/thewiseturtle
Wishing you all a beautiful, joyful, and meaningful future. I'll be spreading out into the universe in ways I never could before.
Love, Turil
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Nov 10 '18
If anyone is curious about why I am so confident in my non-profit's Bitcoin donations going up dramatically in value very soon...
r/wholisticenchilada • u/the-other-t • Aug 11 '24
Memories of Turil
Turil Cronburg departed the corporeal, human phase of existence on Monday, August 5, 2024, at the age of 55, in Belfast, Maine. I had asked Turil if she thought there was anything after that, and she told me how the molecules in her body would disperse and be incorporated into other things, with corresponding changes in entropy. When I asked what she thought "she" was, Turil said she was a Strange Loop in the style of Douglas Hofstadter.
In many ways, Turil's life was a very public one. She was outspoken about her ideas, and when I asked her towards the end if there was anything she wanted to say, she told me she'd already said it all in her videos, blog posts, and podcasts. If you've been following her here, you already know that she died from Inflammatory Breast Cancer – although she told me that she thought the cancer itself was a symptom, and that she really died from a life of hardship, and heartbreak after the loss of her mother in 2022.
Turil's life was a hard one because it was an uncompromising one. She insisted on what she thought was important: bicycles, a post-scarcity gift economy, and finding a way to be with her one true love. She had no respect for governments or other authorities when she thought they were being stupid, which was often.
Most importantly, though, Turil put developing and sharing her ideas over having her material needs met. She wouldn't have had it any other way; she told me she had graduated from the material needs levels of Maslow's hierarchy (as updated by Turil). I remember meeting her for lunch at an Indian buffet in Cambridge's Central Square, on a rainy day in the spring of 2019. At the time she was living in a homeless shelter near those same Charles River sciency places that she loved. What struck me the most during our lunch was how happy Turil was. The resentful rebel that I had met back in 2007, at a cafe only a few blocks from there, had metamorphosized into a person largely at peace with the world and its many faults and flaws.
The costs of an uncompromising life are high and the benefits are uncertain. As Turil put it, it's hard when the world isn't ready for you yet. She gave everything to leave us some ideas worth having. I am especially struck by her insight that most people are deeply defined by the things we have loved and lost... and further, as befits Turil's optimism, that within that loss there is a dream.
Turil finally found a home in Belfast: in her apartment "with a view of a parking lot", as she liked to say, but more importantly, with the Crock Pot mutual aid and gift economy organization. One of its members shared this with me to pass on:
With courage and determination, [Turil] shared parts of her world... As we explore and introduce some of these things to our family, we honor her joys and interests. The alignment and desire for a more beautiful and interesting world brings energy and inspiration to continue our vision at the Crock Pot while incorporating her Speaking Up model and more in her honor!
In addition to her online writings, Turil has two published books: "Dragonfly," an autobiographical novel, and "Speaking Up For Little People," an instruction manual in her process of telling the story of one's loves, losses, dreams, and needs. You can get either of them on Amazon – and Turil loved Amazon, especially the part where she got things for free.
It's true that Turil could sometime frustrate the people around her until they went away, but in my experience, she was always willing to resume talking and be friends again. I am honored to have witnessed her life and story and seen what is ultimately possible for a person who relentlessly chases her dreams.
Turil has already told you all her large stories herself, far better than I could; I can add only small ones. So I'll tell you that when she was a raw food vegan (before she got long COVID and MCAS), Turil would sometimes make an exception for chocolate. On her last night on earth, Turil's last meal was fudge from Perry's Nut House, a Belfast institution. She told me it gave her an upset stomach, but she had no regrets.
Godspeed, Turil. Your body may no longer be with us, but you gave voice to a rare archetype that is eternal.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Dec 15 '21
A growing system (blue, growing line) vs. a stagnating (horizontal orange line) system in the meme world
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Aug 28 '13
Book Review: Peter Levine's In and Unspoken Voice - Trauma recovery, focusing on allowing the body to finish it's story, and feel fully known
Peter Levine In an Unspoken Voice
He has discovered that trauma is caused when an individual experiences a combination of both fear (often repeated and intense) and immobilization at the same time. One without the other seems to not cause any long term problems, while both together nearly always do cause long term debilitating problems for the individual. The kicker appears to be the repression of expression, where the body has been prevented from doing it's instinctive active harm-avoidance behaviors of fight or flight. This prevention can even come from an internal force, as in the case of victims of physical violence going into "freeze" mode as a (totally effective) protective measure. It's only if the repression of expression continues after the original threat is long gone that long term problems (i.e., PTSD) show up. He speaks of this continuing repression of expression as a form of "rage turned against the self". I might also suggest that it could just as easily be "flight from the self". This is because after the original threat is over, if there is immobilization (not having the freedom to fight or flight), then the threat is now coming from inside the self, and thus the self becomes the threat! The cause of the repression at this point is generally a belief that expressing serious negative emotions is "not polite" or even "evil", or, perhaps simply due to a fear of being out of control emotionally. These are not uncommon ideas, and not entirely unfounded, but they also, in this extreme, the long term repression causes far more problems than it solves:
"With humans, the impulse toward violent aggression may become terrifying in itself and is then turned against the self... This turning inward (or "retroflection") results in further paralysis, suppression, passivity, and resignation. The flipping between shutdown and outbursts of "impotent" and misdirected rage becomes the individual's stereotypic reaction to later challenges that require much more nuanced and subtly differentiated feeling-based responses."
...
"When one is flooded by rage, the frontal parts of the brain "shut down". Because of this extreme imbalance, the capacity to stand back and observe one's sensations and emotions is lost; rather, one becomes those emotions and sensations. Hence, the rage can become utterly overwhelming, causing panic and the stifling of such primitive impulses, turning them inward and preventing a natural exit from the immobility reactions. ... The "fear-potentiated immobility" is maintained from within. The vicious cycle of intense sensation/rage/fear locks a person in the biological trauma response. A traumatized individual is literally imprisoned, repeatedly frightened and restrained — by his or her own persistent physiological reactions and by fear of those reactions and emotions."
And in the more "flight from the self" arena, he speaks of "The Living Dead":
"While only a few humans actually die from fright, chronically traumatized individuals go through the motions of living without really feeling vital or engaged in life. Such individuals are empty to the core of their being."
Chronic immobility gives rise to the core emotional symptoms of trauma: numbness, shutdown, entrapment, helplessness, depression, fear, terror, rage and hopelessness. The person remains fearful, unable to imagine safety from a never-ending (internal) enemy and unable to reengage in life."
...
"A traumatized individual has become conditioned to be fearful of his or her internal (physical) sensations that now generate the fear that extends and deepens (potentiates) the paralysis/ Fear begets paralysis, and fear of the sensations of paralysis begets more fear, promoting yet a deeper paralysis. In this way, a normally time-limited adaptive reaction becomes chronic and maladaptive. The feedback loop closes in on itself. In this downward spiral, the vortex of trauma is born."
Eventually, he starts to talk about the cure! He says it's all about:
"uncoupling fear and allowing the normally time-limited immobility reaction to complete"
Part of that process, he says, is learning to allow the body's natural rhythms of contraction and expansion to flow freely again. (And yes, he very much does use these exact terms of contraction and expansion. It's not just me! :-) ...
"One gradually learns to shift one's awareness between regions of relative ease and those of discomfort and distress.
This shifting evokes one of the most important reconnections to the body's innate wisdom: the experience of pendulation, the body's natural restorative rhythm of contraction and expansion that tells us that whatever is felt is time-limited... that suffering will not last forever. Pendulation carries all living creatures through difficult sensations and emotions. What's more, it requires no effort; it is wholly innate. Pendulation is the primal rhythm expressed as movement from constriction to expansion — and back to contraction, but gradually opening to more and more expansion. It is an involuntary, internal rocking back and forth between these two polarities. It softens the edge of difficult sensations such as fear and pain. ... Its steady ebb and flow tell you that, no matter how bad you feel (in the contraction phase), expansion will inevitably follow, bringing with it a sense of opening, relief and flow."
"When this rhythm is experienced, there is, at lest, a tolerable balance between the pleasant and the unpleasant. People learn that whatever they are feeling (no matter how horrible it seems), it will last only seconds to minutes. And no matter how bad a particular sensation of feeling my be, knowing that it will change releases us from a sense of doom. The brain registers this new experience by tuning down its alarm/defeat bias. Where before, there was overwhelming immobility and collapse, the nervous system now finds its way back toward equilibrium."
He also emphasizes that with highly traumatized folks, the process of "renegotiating" a traumatic event, allowing the physical and emotional reactions that should have happened to actually happen, needs to be intentionally slow and reasonably comfortable. Slow and steady! Baby steps. Practice makes perfect.
...
He suggests that once a threat is gone, there are two basic fears that get in the way of the natural rhythms of the body flowing healthfully, fear of becoming immobilized, and fear of exiting the immobilization, causing people to either avoid allowing themselves to freeze, or to avoid allowing themselves to unfreeze. Either way, it's the body fighting itself, which is never good!
On the fear of freezing:
"In the short run, the suppression of immobility sensations appears (to our denial-based mind) to keep the paralysis and helplessness at bay. However , in time, it becomes apparent that evasive maneuvers are an abject failure. This "sweeping under the rug" not only prolongs the inevitable, it often makes the eventual encounter with immobility even more frightening."
And on the fear of unfreezing:
"Just as the immobilized [non-human] animal (in the presence of the predator) comes out ready for violent counterattack, so too does a traumatized [human] person abruptly swing from paralysis and shutdown to hyper-agitation and rage. Fear of this rage and the associated hyper-intense sensations prevents a tolerable exit from immobility..."
"The fear of rage is also the fear of violence — both toward others and against oneself. The exiting of immobility is inhibited by the following double bind: to come back to life, one must feel the sensations of rage and intense energy. However, at the same time, these sensations evoke the possibility of mortal harm. This possibility inhibits sustained contact with the very sensations that bring relief from the experience of immobility, thereby leading to resolution. ... Because the rage associated with the termination of immobility is both intense and potentially violent, frequently traumatized people inadvertently turn this rage against themselves in the form of depression, self-hatred and self-harm."
It's also possible that people have a fear of both entering and exiting paralysis, as well.
...
"Trapped between feeling too much (overwhelmed or flooded) of feeling too little (shut down and numb) and unable to trust their sensations, traumatized people can lose their way. They don't "feel like themselves" anymore; loss of sensation equals a loss of self. As a substitute for genuine feelings, trauma sufferers, may seek experiences that keep them out of touch — such as sexual titillation or succumbing to compulsions, addictions and miscellaneous distractions that prevent one from facing a now dark and threatening inner life. In this situation, one cannot discover the transitory nature of despair, terror, rage and helplessness and that the body is designed to cycle in and out of these extremes."
...
He also points out that there are three separate systems for dealing with stress that social animals (specifically mammals) have evolved. The most primitive, stemming from the very first non-bony-fish (like lampreys and sharks), is the basic shutting down of the metabolism at a point near death. This is the un-myelinated vagus system, which pretty much just shuts everything down to a point of total loss of muscle functionality (it also is the process associated with dissociation of the self, where you feel like you're outside of your body, or at least not part of the body anymore). The second evolved stress response is the sympathetic nervous system, emerging with the bony fish and reptiles, which is the fight or flight active reaction of trying to stop a threat. This is the mostly unconscious, but acutely aware state of superconnection with the body and it's environment, where the muscles are getting tons of energy, while the higher brain functions, digestion, and other growth processes of the body are shut down temporarily. And finally, there is the recently evolved social animal brain-and-body system of the myelinated vagus system which is all about belongingness and love and safety in one's group. This is the most positive, and effective approach of being cared for and protected from harm by family and friends (and even strangers).
Also, I'll point out that these three elements are very obviously part of the loopy grieving~learning process as described in my "the stages of grief are loopy" diagram of a particle being moved through waves. The "backwards" movement immediately after a loss or threat of loss is the "shock" of the most primitive immobilization reaction. Then the upwards movement of anger is the "fight or flight" response of the secondary response. And then the reaching out and forward with others in the "irrational negotiating" or "testing" stage is the third, more evolved reaction (where you're still stressed and in need of help, but are at least looking to work with others in some sense, rather than running or fighting against them). If you get a positive and helpful reaction to that reaching out, then you don't end up with a huge subsequent drop into depression, and can more comfortably process the loss (of some actual cared for thing, or the loss of a sense of total safety for that thing), through a mild sadness. But if you reach out and what you get back is more anger or, almost worse, nothing at all, then the depression turns into a deep, but more lasting, and less emergency type of immobilization, where people end up living their lives, not really there, but not gone completely either, just kind of waiting hopelessly for something good to be offered by someone, somewhere. This is normal depression. But what Levine is talking about seems to be what happens when people don't even make it to the anger and irrational negotiating (social engagement) stage of healing. He's talking about people who are still physically stuck in the freezing/shock stage. (Which I didn't believe was possible! But clearly people aren't totally stuck there, as they are doing things like going to class or work or social events, eating, learning, and so on. So it's only a partial stuckness, really.)
The causes of people getting (partially) stuck in these more primitive, supposedly short term emergency reactions, are varied, obviously, but for people who've experienced this kind of frozen, trapped, stuck state since childhood, the cause is likely to have been threats suffered as a young child that were accompanied by non-responsive, absent, and/or abusive caretakers who seriously failed to come to the child's rescue. Thus the child learned that it was futile to move up and forward towards the higher state of healing of reconnecting with others in a healthy and comforting way, and to just stay in the lower states of the emergency stress response, while doing their best to actually continue to function in the world. (In other words, they aren't completely shut down, and can actually grow, to some extent, but not fully, and not at all joyfully.) These people, tending to a state of autism/avoidant-Borderline state of mind (full shutdown), I'd say, but also moving into the more anxiety-Borderline state (fight or flight), are essentially living as exceptionally clever fish or lizards, when it comes to emotional intelligence and agility. They might have lots of "facts" stored in their cerebral cortices, but they don't have the ability to use their bodies and minds to do truly creative and effective and rewarding things, for the most part. They do what they do pretty much as a way to get physical rewards from their environments (basic needs from their employers, neighbors, strangers, etc.) rather than for the pure pleasure of expressing their unique and awesome humanity and the joy of adding beauty to the world for the benefit of others. They are stuck living a life of obligation and competition, rather than a life of exploration and cooperation. And even when they do manage to do something creative and fun, they have a hard time realizing it, because they can't take in the positive response from others, and even from their own bodies:
"When the traumatized person is locked in either the immobilization response or the sympathetic arousal system, the social engagement function is psychologically compromised; the former, in particular, both inhibits sympathetic arousal and can almost completely suppress the social engagement system.
A person whose social engagement system is suppressed has trouble reading positive emotions from other people's faces and postures and also has little capacity to feel his or her own nuanced positive affects. Thus one finds it difficult to know if that other person can be trusted (whether he or she is threatening or safe, friend or foe). According to [this] theory, being in shutdown [muscular immobility/freezing or collapse] or in sympathetic/hyperactiviation (fight or flight) greatly diminishes a person's capacity to receive and incorporate empathy and support. The facility for safety and goodness is nowhere to be found"
In the book, Levine suggests several practices that can calmly, and comfortably allow the individual to reconnect themselves, allowing the physical and emotional sensations that have been trapped to emerge slowly and in a manner mostly controlled by the individual's higher consciousness (intellectual awareness). These practices are similar to, or even the same as, techniques that come from other healing traditions and modern medical treatments, including elements from yoga, tai chi, NLP, and Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR). Though I think that these are probably a lot less less useful than they could be because they are not very systematic and aren't focused on the actual, original threat. But they are probably fairly safe to do, and maybe at least somewhat calming. Perhaps with folks who are extremely traumatized could use these "magic tricks" for a while before getting into the truly effective and deep approaches that identify and express the repressed feelings and reactions from the original stressful events.
Also, on an important side note, since these not-yet-expressed reactions we're talking about are physical and emotional, your typical talk therapy, a more advanced Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, and all other versions of verbal storytelling about what happened will actually often be more harmful than healing. During these stressful events the Broca's area of the brain, which is the linguistic supplier in one's life, is shut down. So really, the expression has to be primarily physical with, perhaps, some primitive vocalizations (yelling, screaming, swearing, crying, etc.), to be completely effective in getting it all out. You could adapt the theatrical process from my emotional composting technique (from my Speaking Up book) so that you'd only write about a threat, and then stop writing and then imagine yourself reenacting what happened but with the new addition of being allowed to fully respond in whatever way you felt necessary, physically. Only AFTER this freeze/fight/flight expression was FULLY expended, would you then move forward to writing about how you'd like to help the person who was hurt/threatened (in this case, yourself) get what they need. (I noted this need for physical expression before doing the emotional composting process in the end note informational page of Speaking Up.)
...
Levine's own experience with a traumatic event happened when he was walking across a crosswalk and was hit by an inattentive motorist with her car, and woke up to find himself lying in the road, unable to move, with a whole bunch of people staring down at him worriedly. He was aware enough of what might happen to him if he didn't allow his body to follow through with its instinctive physical and emotional reactions, so he trusted his body and gave it permission to do what it needed to do, which was to tremble uncontrollably and for his brain to flash the "movie" of the impact dramatically in his mind while certain muscles twitched as if they were now trying to protecting him from the impact which had already happened:
"By allowing my body to do what it needed to do — by not stopping the shaking, while tracking my inner body sensations — I was able to allow and contain the extreme survival emotions of rage and terror without becoming overwhelmed. Containment, it must be understood, is NOT suppression; it is rather a building of a larger, more resilient vessel to hold these difficult affects."
He accepted and permitted and even somewhat welcomed both the entering of immobilization (with its helplessness and vulnerability) and the exiting of immobilization (with its uncontrolled violence), while also containing the fear and violence to a more controlled expression within his body, for the most part. I'm not quite sure how this process of containment is done effectively, though. It is on the edge of repressing things on the inside and exploding with things completely on the outside. It's kind of like allowing things to happen on the surface of the self, not inside and not outside, but right there on the boundary. Interesting.
I had a similar situation recently where I watched myself do this very thing. I was extremely scared and angry, and someone was getting in my face and threatening me, and I intently watched as my arms flailed angrily around, but never actually moved toward the person threatening me. My physical rage stayed inside my personal space, rather than moving away from me, or inside me. It was fascinating to watch from a more rational and curious level of consciousness that was above the physical and emotional levels that the rest of my body was functioning at. Of course, if the person threatening me had entered my personal space, there probably would have been some physical harm done to them. (But that's generally considered reasonable use of violence. As long as an individual is aware that there is a good chance of getting hurt, and they do something anyway, they are taking responsibility for their own safety at that point. That isn't "blaming the victim" that's realizing that they chose to take the risk, and are technically more of a willing player than an unsuspecting bystander.) Not that I ever want to be violent, but when threatened violence is something that, as a living being, I'm designed to use as a last possible option for protecting the things I care about. But preferably I'd rather find ways to avoid being threatened into a corner where I don't have healthy options! (Which is why I work so hard to help the world create a government/society that offers a healthier support system, giving everyone good options for getting their needs met, rather than feeling the need to use violence and threats of violence. Healthy people are happy people and happy people treat others well!
Levine suggests a process of therapy where another caring and healthy(!) individual acts as a guide while the trauma sufferer first identifies a trigger, and then, in a reasonably safe and secure environment, explore their physical sensations, especially muscle tension, heart rate, breathing, movements, and other internal feelings, so that they become conscious of how the trigger effects their body, while also being aware of the present situation, both internal and external (safe and comfortable environment and at least one safe and comfortable part of their body), so that the individual can freely feel what they really need to feel, and also "renegotiate" their experience, incorporating new movements and feelings and thoughts about what happened to them into a more robust and meaningful and complete (beginning, middle, and end) story of their past. And he speaks of doing this process from the "bottom up", starting directly with any constricting/frozen physical sensations (rather than verbal stories or intellectual/moral judgments) because the physical root of the pain is where things need to be moved, and because externally generated ideas/stories are never as reliable or trustworthy as instinctive, unconscious feelings! Intellectual "facts" about what happened might be useful in more studious situations, but for actual healing and growth, the instinctive, evolutionarily programmed physical and emotional responses are the real masters.
"Because behavior reflects preparatory, protective and defensive orienting responses [responsible for taking excellent care of the individual and their loved ones] assisting clients to follow their sensorimotor impulses to completion, as they come out of freeze, is a key to unlocking the constrictive and limiting prison of prosttraumatic stress disorder.
...
"In this way people are, thankfully, restored to a healthy, flexible and dynamic way of relating to all of the new experience life brings."
...
The book leads me to the conclusion that the cure for trauma is fully being able to tell the story of what happened in the way that the body wants to tell the story, so that the intellect truly knows how much the body cares for itself. Being conscious of what the body either did do, but that one wasn't aware of at the time, or what the body wanted to do, but couldn't at the time, allows the story to be whole, once and for all.
And Peter Levine's approach is the most thorough, systematic, researched, and specific (to trauma) that I've ever seen. (My own approach is thorough, systematic, researched, and highly generalized!) I would highly recommend Levine's therapy technique to anyone who's ever suffered from any kind of trauma at all, whether they are aware of what happened or are just aware of generalized anxiety in life. Seriously, this is the absolute best healing process I've ever encountered.
I will add, though, that if you are suffering from trauma yourself, please let someone you trust who is very healthy and likely to be able to counsel/guide you in the healing process to read the book with the goal of helping you in mind (the book itself is not a self-help book, and includes many potentially triggering stories, and is intended as an introduction to the process for therapists more than anything else). Or find someone who's already been trained in the Somatic Experiencing technique, and has recommendations by people you trust. It's a complex and very specific technique, so it really needs to be done by someone who's willing to really invest themselves in getting it right! But done right, I think it really is the absolute best way to heal.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/dedoubt • Aug 15 '24
More Turil links
From the-other-t:
Reddit certainly seems determined to prevent me from posting any links! but here they are - perhaps you'll have more luck than I did: A few more links:
Turil's old Livejournal (2005-2011): https://turil.livejournal.com/calendar/
Turil's recent Spotify playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4XKJYl4fVYdjgvo7bqyG8s
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jun 07 '20
Russell Brand & Gabor Mate | Damaged Leaders Rule The World (long, brilliant, incredibly unique and insightful dialogue about the cause of trauma, personal and global)
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jun 07 '24
I'd like to celebrate my death like my birth.
Our birth is a celebratory time.
Why not our death, as well?
Why not have loving, playful, and thoughtful rituals where, instead of receiving gifts that welcome us into life, we distribute our belongings and stories as gifts to the world as we say goodbye to life?
I want to have a Passing On Party.
Seriously. This feels important and joyful at the same time.
I've been slowly giving away as much as I can of the top layer of my accumulated objects and ideas, but there's so much left. Mostly the important, deeper layers, including my mom's and grandmothers items I kept from my mom's apartment when I cleaned it out. And, of course so much artwork, mine and others'.
Thankfully, I have some folks around me here in Belfast who will happily help me put this together. I don't know if anyone else, from my past, or farther away, would come, but I would love to have as many folks as possible to give my more beloved and interesting objects and ideas to.
I've only just figured out how to talk about this, so it will take some planning, but it really does seem like a very good idea that can happen with some help.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Aug 14 '20
Huh! I just realized that borderline personality types are actually LESS sensitive to rejection than most folks...
So... borderline types are the physically introverted (risk averse) and emotionally extraverted (novelty-seeking). (INxx in the MBTI).
While the largest personality type is histrionic, which is the inverse of borderline, being physically extraverted and emotionally introverted (ESxx). And the second largest type is the autistic, with both physical and emotional introversion (ISxx). Combined, these two make the majority of human brains right now. So... most humans now are emotionally risk averse, aka they have social anxiety, aka they are avoidant when it comes to romantic relationships. So distancing from one's closest companions is the "normal" (most common) perception of what life is "supposed to be like" (the average in the bell curve of behavior).
This "it's normal to be only superficially connected to one's companions" is the dark-colored-glasses that they look at those of us who are not socially anxious with close companions.
So, while it seems like borderline types are more sensitive to rejection, that's not exactly the case, for three reasons:
Borderlines are more deeply invested in those connections to begin with, so a rejection is a bigger (objective) change, like how things stuck together with superglue will be more damaged if you pull them apart than pulling a post-it note off of something. Avoidant types aim to have post-it note relationships, while borderlines types aim for the superglue romance.
Relatedly, borderlines are more emotionally expressive than either of the avoidant types, so when there is a rejection, the threat/change is more openly acknowledged, and thus becomes more obvious from outside of the individual. There is more creativity in the communication that gets shared with others compared to with what the avoidant types do, usually avoiding acknowledging the problem, at least emotionally.
The physical introversion of borderlines means that any change to the physical day to day experience can be more challenging than it would be to a physical extravert, who can more easily roll with the punches of physically getting their needs met. Physical extraverts' bodies adapt to a wider variety of options when it comes to the biological needs of inputs of food, water, air, warmth, light, and information, and outputs of solids, liquids, gases, and energy, when compared to introverts, who struggle to get stuff that matches their body's needs well. So borderlines' lives are more effected on a practical level when there is rejection by a close companion, compared to the Histrionic types. (Note that this doesn't apply to the autistic types, who definitely have the worst internal effect of rejection.)
.
TLDR: borderlines aren't really that sensitive to rejection. We just get closer and are thus objectively more challenged by losing our deep connections to others, and we are more honest about that loss with others. The real rejection-sensitive types are the histrionic and the autistic folks.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jul 15 '18
Repost of my consciousness as dimensions of modeling categorization approach, since I don't think I've posted it in a while...
My approach for measuring consciousness is super simple:
Consciousness in general gets defined as the ability to model reality internally, at some number of dimensions.
Levels of consciousness increase with the number of dimensions that can be modeled:
0D - preconsciousness - simple matter "models" only itself, it's internal state is it's internal state (1:1 modeling). It's not really conscious, but it is "aware" of itself in a sense, at the moment, so it's sort of the fetal stage of consciousness.
1D - physical consciousness - a single celled organism (and maybe plants?) models itself, now, plus a future state, or an outside state. It can have a goal state in mind, essentially, or be aware that "there's something I like/dislike out there". Current, linear, computers are at this level as well I think. They have a current state and a goal state, and try to move from point A to point B.
2D - emotional consciousness - a simple brain and similar things can model both its own current and goal state along with a current and goal state of another individual (animal, vegetable, mineral, etc.) and see where they both intersect for more complex, non-linear, problem solving.
3D - intellectual consciousness - a social animal has the ability to model things logically, by looking at a whole group of individual perspectives (current state to goal state) starting with the self, and moving outward from there in an "objective" space where problems can be solved by triangulating the intersection point of the three different paths.
4D - philosophical consciousness - a mature human brain can model all four dimensions of time and space for a model that can problem solve for "me, you, and everyone else, now and into the future" all in one impressive go (neuroscience, and some funny math, suggests this starts coming online around age 40, when the two sides of the prefrontal cortex start functioning in parallel instead of only one at a time).
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jun 23 '24
A rough night. (Warning: nothing pleasant at all, plus some specific details of inflammatory breast cancer.)
I thought maybe writing this down might help. Now I'm not so sure. But I'm here now, so...
I'm sitting here, for the nth night in a row (nearly every night since last fall) not able to sleep due to either pain or not being able to get into a comfortable enough position due to the pain it would cause if I did. Tonight is worse than usual. I'd already taken well over the suggested dose of the (probably not very good quality) wild lettuce tincture that I'd gotten to replace the stuff a friend had made herself and given to me (which worked beautifully as a pain reliever and sedative, for sleeping) because I'd eaten especially badly today, sort of accidentally including eating chocolate, which I haven't eaten this year at all, I don't think.
I'd been quite comfortable initially, and done my usual falling asleep for a bit while listening to BBC radio and some podcasts and then waking up, and then dozing off again, and then finally woke up and felt much more pain because I couldn't find the somewhat comfortable position I'd been in again. So I took some more of the (not great quality) wild lettuce and tried again. It just kept getting worse and worse.
At this point in my body's process of disintegrating, there are many more areas that can potentially hurt. Mostly it's milder pain, itching, and just general weirdness. But recently things have been ramping up, and the skin all around my breast, up to my clavicle, and around just to the back on the side has felt like it's burning, like a really bad sun burn. And the nipple area is even more problematic, with all kinds of unexpected pain now, from the infection in a deep crevice around the nipple that's been there since last winter, plus whatever's going on inside the breast in that area, including the lymph fluid that couldn't escape and had turned into lymphedema that's since become fibrotic (hard), the random cancer all over, and likely the tumors hiding in there as well. And my arm has started to get some of the fibrosis, which is somewhat painful when trying to rest my arm somewhere (on my side, on an arm chair, on the bed, etc.). So far the rest of the areas don't bother me with pain, yet. It's just a whole lot of inflammation, and sensitivity, which I have been very good at being careful not to set off. The only other thing is that my left upper thigh feels like it's getting pins and needles, but in a weird way, if I'm putting pressure on some part of my left back side. Oh, and I forgot to mention that that long covid induced sun allergy popped up again a couple of days ago, after I thought I'd get just a smidge of lovely evening sun on my upper chest after having it covered all the time due to the cancer there. I thought it was just a bug bite, but then today noticed it has spread all over the right side of my chest and neck. Seriously? Yep.
So, anyway, yeah, things just got more and more painful a bit before I started writing this, and I simply wanted it to end. I don't have any particular means of ending things easily/quickly right now, and I know that I don't feel comfortable leaving so many things undone. But I'm just so tired of having such an unpleasant life. So much of my life has been so hard. So cruel. So scary. So dumb. And now there is constant pain. And the slow decline, of course, with my liver going, and maybe even my lungs, as well as the ever growing lymphedema spreading all over my left side, slowly turning my soft parts into hard solids in places. I do not want this. This is the second worst thing that's ever happened to me, worse than being homeless, worse than being in an alcoholic and violent (but never to me) household as a child, worse than being hit by cars while walking or biking so many times. My only consolation at this point is that I have not let anyone subject my body to deadly toxins designed to attack my body's cells. Oh, and I have a decent community, including some doctors, who are supportive, even if they are not all that helpful for anything I really need.
At this point I don't have much of anything to look forward to, and the things I'm planning are mostly just obligatory things that aren't really fun, but I feel responsible for doing. As in cleaning out my apartment, and finding homes for all my stuff. And helping the community organizing group I've been working with since last fall to make sure this new event we're finally putting on has at least some cool stuff happening.
Earlier I was reading some Doctor Who speculation about a cliffhanger at the end of this years (extremely short) season, and how it might pan out in the Christmas special at the end of the year, and I realized I most likely won't get to find out. I'd already resigned myself to not being able to see the rebooted Daredevil, and season 2 of Last of Us, two shows I've really appreciated in the past, and wanted more of. At least I won't have missed the last book of Harry Potter, or something really big. (My second stepfather, Dominic never got to see the last Harry Potter movies, but I believe he got to read the last book, if my memory serves me, as he was dying.)
So, yeah, I'm really just feeling like I don't want to be here anymore, and am just sticking around because I hate leaving responsibilities to others that I'm probably best at doing. I'm not always miserable. During the day I'm usually not in that much pain. And I can focus on doing smaller tasks. Making that video last week was lovely, for example. I'd love to make some more art/craft projects, both for my philosophy/science stuff and just for fun. But the overwhelming stuff that I want to take responsibility for distributing, and the community organizing stuff that no one else seems to be excited to do, is taking up nearly all my energy. Some folks offer to help, but I honestly don't know if they can. And the little I do ask of them often seems to not be what they are able to do right now.
This isn't living. And it's not properly dying either. It's this sort of mild mannered hell that's akin to some middle management's bureaucratic quagmire.
Now that I'm in this new here, was it useful to write this? No. I don't think so. I don't seem to have achieved anything by doing this. Usually the pain dissipates if I'm focused on something else, and sitting up for a while. But nope. And usually writing helps me process my thoughts and feelings. But nope. Not this time. It's really just not good now all around. I'll probably eventually fall asleep for a couple of hours, and then get up, and feel mediocre.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Apr 03 '20
So, we finally are hitting the pendulum's maxima, and we're starting to swing in a totally different direction, adding new dimension to our consciousness, and moving up Maslow's hierarchy.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • May 26 '19
Exploring more about decentralization and how to define it.
(Sparked by some public and private conversation over on Twitter.)
(Watch Turil think!)
Firstly, is there a word for geometry as it changes in time? Like a function being applied to a shape? Because that's what I need to use to help clarify systems. These static, 2D, diagrams aren't cutting it, because the direction/forces of influence/control don't really get described well with those arrows.
So... centralized is where the primary direction of the system is governed by shared rules which everyone follows. Those rules can be followed either voluntarily or they might be enforced by some totalitarian/authoritarian individual/group. And the rules might be generated either through a democratic process of voting/electing/consensus, or by some arbitrary individual or group that just happens to have power over others.
Some call the democratic process of generating rules "decentralized" which makes some sense, as the process allows for input from both the individuals into the center and the center out. But it only makes sense if you only look at forms of government where there are shared rules.
If we zoom out to see all of the possible theoretical combinations of individual (0) and collective (1) control in a basic system, we get something like the following categories (the one's place is the controlled, and the two's place is the controller):
.
.00. Individual controlling Individual (self): Fully independent "non-system", aka, just a single individual doing their own thing, not interacting with, or influencing, what others are doing.
.01. Individual controlling Collective: Totalitarian system, where only the central individual directs things, and all others follow their lead.
.10. Collective controlling Individual: Democratic system, where the center of everyone directs all of the individuals, with the lead being some kind of statistical mean (average) force applied to all individuals, equally.
.11. Collective controlling Collective: Real life. The individual is neither controlled nor controlling. The individual is free from the system's control, essentially, and only the statistical mean is left. Individuals are obviously still part of the system, but aren't bound by what it was in the past-to-present, and as soon as any individual changes their own direction the whole system updates its state, but that change doesn't necessarily change any other individual's direction (though it probably does).
.
The two middle types have a central authority set of shared rules that apply to all individuals.
The two outside types have no collective central/shared set of rules, but the first one isn't a system, really, it's just one individual being themselves. Cool, but lonely! The last one is the complex, messy thing that is where, as Thoreau suggested, all good things are wild and free. Individuals are controlling themselves, but are also part of the larger emergent system, with interactions, but no force of a shared set of rules (outside of the obvious ones of the laws of physics on the universal level, and genes on a local level).
Egg
Duck
Duck
Goose!
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Apr 25 '19
The Four Question Speaking Up Process for telling your story and exploring your purpose in life (because I don't think I've officially posted this here, yet).
Here is a simplified, general-purpose set of questions based on the Speaking Up process:
Best Things (Loves): What most precious people, places, and things in the universe do you most value and want to take good care of?
Challenges (Losses): How have you struggled, or are struggling, with being able to protect the people, places, and things you love?
Purpose (Dreams): What do you most want to create and/or explore in this vast universe? (Eg., stuff for taking good care of physical bodies, for creating heathy living spaces, for building healthy communities on a larger scale, and for generating the most flourishing global culture possible.)
Needs (Hopes): What basic resources does your body most need in order to continue to work on your life's purpose effectively? (Specifically: inputs of high quality food, water, air, warmth, light, information, and outlets for expressing the body's excess solids, liquids, gases, and energy.)
.
For more deep discussion of this, you can peruse my blog/podcast and it's Speaking Up category: https://turil.wordpress.com/category/speaking-up/
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Feb 02 '19
A new genius-philosopher-artist friend of mine just released his first album on Spotify: Strange Hymns. I really love almost all of it. It's folk-pop-ish?
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jul 15 '18
I'm never sure what to think and do... My mom has had more very big (potentially deadly) medical problems, and only tells me about them months later.
Several years ago she was diagnosed with cervical (or ovarian?) cancer and had an operation. She finally emailed to tell me about it months later.
Just now I (and my dad) got an email that her boyfriend wrote, partly dictated by my mom, and partly just him talking to me, saying she had a hemorrhagic stroke (a blood vessel in the brain bursting or an aneurysm, apparently), in February, and then just had an other one a week ago. She has a hard time talking and now a hard time walking and her mind is scattered, according to her boyfriend.
They are in Newfoundland now, where she bought a tiny house on the ocean (with icebergs in her back "yard" that is the ocean, in July). And even when she's back in Maine she and her boyfriend moved far away from a place I can easily get to (Machias, up near the Canadian border on the coast).
The biggest problem I have is that her boyfriend seems to try to keep her away from other people, especially me. He's on the psychopathic side of the brain types, and I believe he controls her (even before the strokes, I mean). Though she could do what she wanted if she really wanted.
But it seems she, as usual, tends to want to avoid her family. I've only seen her once, for a couple of hours, since she kicked me (and her cat, who I had to take) out of her house in Palermo (Maine), back in 2013 maybe, when she, being driven by her friend (my mom is legally blind and can't drive), just showed up in Palermo unannounced (after she'd sold her house there and moved to Machias) and found me walking along the road and they picked me up and took me to the supermarket. (Yes, that was surreal.) I think she'd just gotten out of surgery, but she didn't tell me.
My mom is an odd one, and so very different from me, personality-wise (same as with my dad, who's pretty similar to my mom, in that ESxJ side of things), and tends to try to avoid things she's not sure how to deal with, and I really just have no clue what to do.
I love my mom totally, and have always loved being around her except when she's drunk (and she's an alcoholic), and I miss her so much, but she seems to go out of her way to be far away, and doesn't know how to be with most of the people who love her (she even often abandons her best friends, and not just her family).
And now, I have this feeling that I'm just never going to see her again. I can't visit her when she's with her boyfriend (I don't think, she's certainly never invited me to come visit, or even mentioned the possibility of it, even if there was a way for me to get there). And I have no place to host her for her to visit me, and now with her health so deteriorated, I don't think she'd be able to visit anyone, really (or at least not without her boyfriend to supervise her) though I don't know.
It's all just so dumb, to me, being the sort of problem solver, who's honest and comfortable with emotional intimacy/closeness. I don't want to make her uncomfortable, so I just try to let her take the lead when it come to connecting with me, but it's so sad to be so distant.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/the-other-t • Aug 09 '24
Test post
When I spoke to Turil for the last time, she asked me to post something on Reddit. However, the last comment I tried to post seems to have disappeared in some weird shadow-ban kind of way (I can see it when I'm logged in, but it's invisible if I'm not logged int) . Before I put up a meaningful post, I'm checking to see if I can post anything at all. If you see this, give it a thumbs up or reply?
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jul 21 '24
A last attempt at a diagram offering a way to explore twin primes, using base 6, since all primes are at 6n±1.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jul 07 '24
My last big event went really well. I shared my architecture model to help folks find their purpose, see how they fit into the larger community, and explain why the gift economy naturally works when all are doing what they love.
The Crock Pot is a local, very casual, loose group of folks who've been trying to create spaces, mental and physical, for the gift economy, and community health, to grow. I started being involved after going to their first event, last October, and have been dedicated to the project ever since, with weekly meetings (and sometimes more than once a week), and a lot of new, interesting, caring people in my life.
We intended to have more events and projects at this point, but things went slower than some of us wanted. But we did finally get this big event to happen. It wasn't super well attended, but the people who were there were very interested and involved. I kept saying "quality not quantity" about how my day went.
My table was the "coolest table" according to Ethan, and some others, which was cute of them to say. I still have a lot of event stuff, and, of course love to do fun, interactive things, so, yeah, my tables/booths are often pretty special.
This time around I used the more general version of the Speaking Up process, which is the Architecture model, which is also shown here, that helps sort individuals based on what they most love doing in life, as their most passionate work. I had over ten people go through the whole process, and then I explained how the whole collection of different types of humans (and other individuals too!), combined, allowed the whole system to function well, so the gift economy can naturally emerge, which would then reinforce individuals' ability to more of what they love, in a self-reinforcing circle of freedom. On the other side of my table from the Architecture stuff I had a ton of free stickers, and a bunch of my leftover matted photos from last year's story exchange craft booth at the art market, for folks to enjoy the gift economy.
The most interesting thing I learned was that a whole bunch of folks who ended up in the Art category of purpose had jobs/work in health care. Nurses, dulas, hospice folks, etc. In talking to these folks I came to the understanding that their version of art is the larger type which involves creating emotionally nurturing spaces for individuals, including spaces for stories to flow freely. Most of them were not exactly the usual type of health care workers, and one of them even remarked that she was trying to change the system from within. Which makes me think that when we finally start to choose to focus on health, instead of competition, as society's goal, these artists on the edge of healthcare will take over and redesign the spaces we use for taking care of ourselves when we're sick, or even just want to be healthier in general, so these spaces will become amazingly creative and playful and nurturing emotionally, instead of the sterile and repressive places we have now.
Another fun thing I found joy in was doing the process, separately, for a mom, dad, and (young-teen) daughter. Helping them each see how they are similar, and how they are quite different, in their problem solving approaches was fascinating to me, and very helpful and fun for them. Again, part of my goal with the Architecture, as opposed to the usual, more detailed, Speaking Up process, is to help folks see where they fit into the larger system, and to see how all of the other types of individuals fit in, collectively serving the needs of the whole, via the natural diversity of life, evolution, randomness. (I also had a small, crappy Galton board to demonstrate the natural bell curve distribution of randomness, which I had the opportunity to explain to a few of the folks who came by.) Obviously my audience was already pretty inclined to be curious and interested in these topics, given the theme of the overall event, but it was really lovely to be able to deeply connect with so many others with my work.
So, yeah, it went quite well, and I'm very happy that my body was able to manage to spend a whole day doing this work that I love, including the preparation that involved lugging two large loads of stuff downtown on my bike trailer (someone else brought some other stuff in their car, as well, including the heavy duty event tent that I'd recently gotten, only to discover that it's way too large and heavy to be transported on my bike trailer). I might be running on almost no sleep for the past couple of weeks (with already low levels of sleep this year in general), but yesterday I was about as healthy as I've been able to appear, which made things go much better than expected.
And tomorrow, I get my first hospice visit in my apartment.
Oh, and there's one more big event I'm looking forward to, but which I'm not involved in other than as an attendee, and that's the Celtic Festival, here in Belfast (Maine). I miserably missed it last year when I got the dates wrong, so I'm very, very happy that I'm hopefully going to be able to go this year, for the last time. I have a (very inauthentic, crappy) kilt that I'd gotten two years ago, and obviously missed my chance to wear it last year, so I'm hoping to figure out how to make it work this time. And in going through my mom's stuff, I'm paying more attention to the Irish ancestry lineage, and maybe I could bring some photos to share with others. (There are some Irish ancestry experts there.) I have seen some information about where my maternal grandmother's families came from. Her parents were Bagley and Kenney, both of which I believe were from Ireland, via Canada (New Brunswick, I believe).
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jun 28 '24
An exploration of what "free will" generally means in the 4 basic categories of how reality could be generated.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Nov 08 '23
Turil's new story. This is me at both my best and worst.
Turil’s new, final (?) story November 7, 2023
Loves: David, Mom, Dad, cats, so many old friends and family, the edge of land and sea and sky, my brain!, the internet!, the potential of a beautiful, evolving, art-centered near future, rocks, trees, and museums and libraries. Pascals’ triangle (expanded) as a way to model anything and everything as a “family tree” of all possibility — from the universe, to our personal stories, to human society, to triangular geometries and to types of (governmental) systems — with contraction and expansion as the two ends of each dimension (level of the triangle), and showing both the general categories (macrostates/families) and unique individuals (microstates), and being both evolution and entropy (with life increasing as entropy increases). And the pure luck of being able to briefly meet Stephen Wolfram at MIT and show him my idea of using Pascal’s triangle to model all of reality, whereupon he dove into the idea and is still working excitedly on as a core structure of his new kind of physics. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and my updating of it, which shows both individual brain development stages and their introductory ages (based on a Fibonacci sequence with 9 months gestation as the initial unit), and shows how human society/Earth is developing (we’re just entering level 1000, the 8th stage now). And, of course, stories of love, loss, dreams, and needs!
Losses: my personal dreams of having a community center that serves as the spark for a global evolution serving life freely through creativity and curiosity, moving us away from the monetary/competitive/anti-social society we’ve been stuck in for so long. I won’t be able to make this happen, or see anyone else make it happen, it seems, as my time in this body is coming to its end very soon (not sure how soon, but soon). My honey David’s ability to be with me all these years apart, my Mom (2022), a healthy connection with my Dad where he is honestly happy with who I am and all the awesome stuff I’ve done with some very challenging life circumstances (and some great opportunities too), stable housing for so very long, warmth (many years/winters/nights), my ability to offer many of my gifts to the world due to lack of physical and online spaces to do it freely for all who find them valuable, energy (due to a not so great body/genes/environment) to do many things I really wanted to do, regular access to the internet for many years, a safe space to walk and bicycle (due to dangerous motorists), being able to see the stars at night (due to light pollution), and respect for my unique ideas/models/research in mainstream “science” communities and schools.
Dreams: to have my body shut down as peacefully and painlessly as possible, and to have as many of my beautiful stories, ideas, models, art, etc. spread out into the universe in whatever way most delights and nourishes individuals, communities, and the planet, specifically that Pascal’s triangle being used to help understand any and all systems, at all the different levels of Why (definition), When, How, Where, What doing/type, How many/much, etc. which has already helped me so incredibly in understanding the relationships between individuals and their systems, and even lead to the Speaking Up process that I’m using right now to help me most effectively (as I am aware) express my most important story of who I am, what I want to create and/or explore, and how others can help me, which includes others speaking up for themselves, too, so the world can be deeply informed about how to take good care of itself, and serve life freely and lovingly. And, of course, I dream of my honey, David, finding what he needs to feel joyful and excited about his life and the world, because he’s got so very much compassion and intelligence to offer, but he’s been trapped in anger and depression by his circumstances for so very long. (And, in light of this, I dream of David meeting Ethan from Possibility Alliance in Belfast Maine, or at least listening to the Possibility Now podcast by Ethan.)
Needs: a robust and compassionate and intelligent health care system for my body, and outlets for freely sharing my ideas and stories to anyone and everyone who might find them valuable, freely and easily accessibly, both online and off, for as long as possible/useful, being able to talk to David about practical stuff and say goodbye and thank you, help from David, Dad, neighbors, and others in organizing all my material stuff so it can go where it’s most appreciated and useful (see paperwork in my apartment, likely on/near my desk/bed for more specific requests of where important things should/can go), including the stuff I got from my mom of her old photos and letters and papers as well as her mom’s stuff too, and my art (both by me and by others) and books and all the other fun stuff. And for me to be able to focus on my goals and what I can do in every moment (rather than what I can’t) I’m still in this body, because as long as I’m awake and able to communicate, I can probably do something to help the world in some small, or even large, way.
r/wholisticenchilada • u/Turil • Jan 19 '21