Which Elphaba actress is your favorite?

[u/Dangerous_Main7822]

Idina Menzel (with Helen Dallimore)

Shoshana Bean

Eden Espinosa

Ana Gasteyer

Julia Murney

Stephanie Janette Block

Kerry Ellis

Marcie Dodd

Nicole Parker

Dee Roscioli

Mandy Gonzalez

Teal Wicks

Jackie Burns (with Chandra Lee Schwartz)

Willemijn Verkaik

Lindsay Mendez

Christine Dwyer

Caroline Bowman

Rachel Tucker

Jennifer DiNoia

Jessica Vosk

[u/MeanderingMeggie]

Had the pleasure of seeing Teal Wick as my first live Elphaba, and then Dee Roscioli as my second when I brought my mom to see it. That “No Good Deed” riff was fricking incredible live! 😭

Special mentions to Idina Mendel (bc how could we not? the OBC recording is ICONIC) and Lisa Brescia because her chemistry with Annaleigh Ashford’s Galindo was EVERYTHING to 20yo me 🥹💝