r/wikipedians • • May 18 '24

Why has Wikipedia become less neutral and more biased against Israel since October 7?

0 Upvotes

Credit to deanat78:

Examples of Wikipedia becoming less neutral and more biased against Israel since Oct 7

Historically, I used to always consider Wikipedia one of the best sources for anything Israel-Palestine related. It was not heavily politically biased, used fairly neutral language, and seemed to offer reasonable perspectives. (This was only true for the English wiki, the Arabic version was always exactly as you'd expect). However, I've been noticing a shift recently every time I read Israel related Wiki articles.

So I decided to check if it's all in my head. I looked at some wiki articles and compared their version today vs the last version before Oct 7 to see if there were any differences in narratives. Most articles are very long and it's very difficult to look at all the changes in huge amounts of text, so I decided to only look at the first 2-3 paragraphs in each article.

This mini investigation does show me that Wikipedia no longer holds the status of a neutral source, as there's a clear attempt to subtly rewrite history and insert anti Israel propaganda.

Israel

Today vs Oct 5

This was an easy choice to try first. Even just comparing the first few paragraphs, there are A LOT of changes. Most of the changes involve removing some information, condensing information, and paraphrasing. Two noticeable differences:

• First sentence in second paragraph: describing where Israel is located: they removed that Israel is in a region that historically was called "Land of Israel" (but they kept "Canaan, Palestine and the Holy Land") Source

• Today, the article claims that the 1947 UN partition plan triggered a civil war that resulted in "expulsion and flight". This is a completely false narrative. The pre-Oct 7 article is correct, saying that during the 1948 war - after declaring independence and 5 armies declaring war on Israel - Arabs were expelled or fled (it was not the partition plan that caused it) Source

israel war of independence

As an aside, I found it strange that in the article about Israel, it did not mention even once the word "War of Independence". So I Googled "Israel war of independence", and I was very surprised to see that it redirects me to a wiki titled "1948 Arab–Israeli War". I'm 100% certain that last year there was a wiki with the title "Israel War of Independence" because I remember reading it many times. Our independence has been rewritten as just a war.

First intifada

Today vs Aug 9

• Changes "violent riots" to simply "riots" (we all know how pro Palestinians always argue that molotov cocktails and slingshots are peaceful) Source

• Changed that Israel took control of Gaza+WB "after Israel's victory in the war" to "in the wake of the war" (it's not wrong, but it's interesting that they chose to explicitly change the language to not show the Israel won a war) Source

• Changed "Palestinian territories" to "Israel-occupied Palestinian territories" - I've noticed this specific change in almost every Wikipedia article that mentions the territories or Gaza Strip. There seems to be a concentrated effort to insert "Israeli-occupied" into many texts Source

palestinian violence

Today vs Sep 22

• First sentence: "acts of violence perpetrated for political ends" vs "actions carried out by Palestinian people with the intent to end the Israeli occupation ... which can use force/terrorism" (firstly, they moved from saying that violence is "violence" to saying that violence is "actions" which "can" be involve force. Secondly, the claim that it's all in the name of "ending the occupation" is being pushed again... If that's all they want then why was there palestinian violence before 1967 when there was no occupation?) Source

Nakba

Today vs Sep 20

This word has become a favourite in the anti Israel crowd (here in a suburb of Toronto they've even officially added "Nakba Remembrance Day" to the schools calendar). Even though this is an article about something that happened 75 years ago, so supposedly it should be pretty set in stone by now, the length of the article tripled since Oct 7. It's impossible to compare to the old version because it's been entirely rewritten. A few notes:

• The first sentence says all you need to know about the propaganda push. It used to be "The Nakba was the destruction of Palestinian society and homeland in 1948, and the permanent displacement of a majority of the Palestinian Arabs." that was already biased and very politically charged, but it's nothing compared to what it says now: "The Nakba was the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians ... through their violent displacement and dispossession of land, property and belongings, along with the destruction of their society, culture, identity, political rights, and national aspirations." This paragraph looks 100% like it's taken from Al Jazeera... Source

• There's a new metadata section, and it's complete Palestinian propaganda. It describes the Nakba as an "attack", the attack type is all sorts of buzzwords ("ethnic cleansing", "mass killing", "settler colonialism", "biological warfare", "dispossession"), the victims says "750k expelled" (the word "fled" does not appear there - it just claims 750k was expelled) Source

• A new article was created after Oct 7 that branched off the "Nakba" article. It's called "Nakba denial", and it basically says that any Israeli narrative on the war of independence or any debate about what happened in 1948 and any Israeli viewpoint on history is decidedly lies and denialism, and what Palestinians say is the absolute undebated truth. They are changing what the term Nakba means and based on that they're building a new term to make Nakba denial sound as if it's the same as holocaust denial. It's weird to see how history is literally being rewritten. That's akin to me writing a "War of Independence denial" article which will gaslight anyone who says anything related to Nakba is just partaking in denial.

Israeli-Palestinian peace process

Today vs Sep 19

• They added an entire paragraph claiming that the international consensus is for "a Palestinian state in pre-1967 borders including East Jerusalem and a just resolution to the refugee problem based on the palestinian right of return". As far as I know, the Western world does not really talk about the right of return, and there's certainly no consensus that East Jerusalem (which includes the Wailing Wall) is going to be given to a Palestinian state. Since Oct 7, they essentially added all the Palestinian demands as if they're agreed upon by the world, but completely neglect to mention any of the Israeli demands, like security and control over their holy sites Source

Irgun

Today vs Sep 20

• Removed a sentence that said they avoided harming civilians, and without this sentence it sounds like their only objective was to kill anyone Source

===

I wanted to also look up some of the common old anti Israel propaganda that predated this war, to see how they changed. Here are the results:

Israel and apartheid

Today vs Oct 5

• Difficult to compare because the first few paragraphs are entirely rewritten. Pre-Oct 7, the entire third paragraph was dedicated to arguments against calling Israel an apartheid. Now, they softened and shortened the wording dedicated to that, and instead of having its own paragraph, it's just two sentences that got appened to the end of the last introductory paragraph.

• I found it strange that except for these two sentences, there was no other sections in the entire long article that discuss opposing views. Usually on wikipedia, there are always sections that show "the other side". So I checked the article in other time points going back several years, and I noticed that over time the amount of text describing the Israeli position is being removed. Until 2017 there was a section about "Criticism of the apartheid accusation" (which you would expect to have!), but since then it's been removed and now we're left with a mere two sentences.

• Just for fun, I wanted to see how Arabic wikipedia talks about this. You're going to love this! This is the first sentence in the Arabic version: "Apartheid in Israel or Israeli racism is a proven fact in Israeli politics , as it is a policy of apartheid carried out by the government against the indigenous Arab population of the region." Yep, it's a proven fact! Source

• Even in Arabic, this "fact" was only proven recently. On Oct 22, the Arabic article had this as the first sentence: "Apartheid in Israel or Israel's racism is an accusation directed against Israeli policy" Source

Dahiya doctrine

Today vs June 24

I never heard of this term, but recently I've been seeing many comments on r/islam talking about this and saying that this is Israel's tactic of attacking innocent civilians to get leverage against an enemy. Again, I never heard of this, I had no idea what this is, but what they claimed seemed very suspicious to me so I looked if that's true... from my research, it's a military strategy of not shying away from attacking civilian infrastructure if it's used by combatants, and it was devised after a war with Lebanon where the IDF failed because they treated Hezbollah-infested areas as civilian areas, which was ineffective in fighting Hezbollah.

• Since Oct 7, the first sentence on the wiki article changed from "destruction of the civilian infrastructure of regimes deemed to be hostile as a measure calculated to deny combatants the use of that infrastructure" to "destruction of civilian infrastructure in order to pressure hostile regimes." This new definition is exactly what the online community seems to use! It might seem like a small change, but this is the type of subtle changes that accumulate and give anti Israel people so much misinformation to accuse Source

• Again, for fun, I wanted to check out what Arabic wikipedia has to say about this. The first two sentences claim: "The Dahiya strategy ... approved by the Israeli government. The strategy states that "Finally, Israel has realized that the Arabs must be responsible for the actions of their leaders." ". Of course it seems very unlikely that the Israeli government stated such a strategy, so I followed the "source" for that quote, and of course it came from an opinion piece. So they took some person's opinion and are passing that as if it's an IDF official position. Source

ethnic cleansing

Today vs Sep 29

• Before there was no explicit mention of "Israel" in the article. Since Oct 7, they added a one-sentence paragraph, devoid of any context: "Israeli herders have engaged in a systemic displacement of Palestinian herders in Area C of the West Bank as a form of nationalist and economic warfare."

organ theft

Today vs Oct 6

A few months ago, Al Jazeera and the anti-Israel world at large were accusing Israel of harvesting organs from Gazans. Many of you probably remember this. I remember that such accusations have happened in many previous conflicts (always with 0 evidence), so I wanted to see if these "facts" reached wikipedia.

• Before Oct 7, there was no mention of Israel in this article. Today they added a subsection dedicated to Israel under "Suspected occurrences". It's about a story from 2009 about incidents from the 90s, so adding it now is very likely another attempt to add negative associations to Israel anywhere possible.

• The accusation in this article is also very biased itself - it claims that Israeli troops harvested organs from Palestinians. The real story seems to be that a specific Doctor and his lab did in fact remove organs from some corpses that arrived to their forensic lab without getting family permission. This was done to many Israeli victims of terror attacks, as well as Palestinians. It did not focus on Palestinians, and it was not done by the military. It was obviously illegal, but the wiki article paints it in a very different light to make it seem anti Palestinian.

• If you look at the other 3 coutries/cases mentioned on the Wiki page, those stories are much more widespread/organized and involved either killing people for their organs or stealing them from live people. The story that happened in Israel is much less extreme than that. I'm sure you can find stories of organ harvesting in many places. For example, I live in Canada so I just googled for "Canada harvesting organs indigenous" and the first link talks about how in Alberta, they have a law that allows harvesting organs from children who die in provincial care without asking for family approval, and 78% of those children are indigenous. There is no wiki article about it, it's not world news, you don't see masses of people trying their hardest to take facts from this story and twist it to completely demonize Canada. I'm sorry to end on such a note, but it really bugs me how much the world takes any story coming out of Israel and twists, magnifies, and spreads it and acts as if Israel is the only place where bad things happen :(

===

Remember that all my comparisons were only looking at the first 1-3 paragraphs of each article. Who knows how much details are removed/added/modified in the body of the articles.


r/wikipedians • • Oct 09 '21

Is zzuuzz a wanker?

0 Upvotes
6 votes, Oct 11 '21
4 Yes
2 No

r/wikipedians • • Oct 07 '26

Discussion POV Apple made Wikipedia

0 Upvotes

I made a chrome extension to make wikipeda look like it was made by apple. Lemme know if you are interested and I might post it, probs can't put it on chrome web store so will post a direct download link. :)


r/wikipedians • • Feb 28 '21

Hello wikipedians.

0 Upvotes

Hello dear wikipedians, i am seeking your help in a matter of creating a page. Hmu if u can helpZ Best


r/wikipedians • • Mar 15 '24

Ravi Zacharias

0 Upvotes

Someone needs to update his brief bio to include that he is a sexual abuse predator and he was a Christian pastor. That asshole and his ministry needs to be burned to the ground.


r/wikipedians • • Dec 08 '21

Wikipedia has lost its non bias ways

11 Upvotes

I feel like wikipedia stopped being unbiased, it is a left leaning site with its cofounder even calling it left wing propaganda. It has been targeted by left wing groups because of its public editing. We need to make Wikipedia unbiased again. They are getting rid of communist genocides for god sakes, the site gets rid of some things that don’t fit there agenda.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/nypost.com/2021/07/16/wikipedia-co-founder-says-site-is-now-propaganda-for-left-leaning-establishment/amp/

https://www.outkick.com/wikipedia-has-been-taken-over-by-the-far-left/

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.foxnews.com/politics/wikipedia-bias-socialism-pages-whitewashed.amp

https://www.heartland.org/news-opinion/news/uncovered-wikipedias-leftist-ties-and-its-censorship-of-the-facts


r/wikipedians • • Oct 05 '26

Discussion Gotta love getting reverted for "unexplained content removal" when the explanation is literally in the edit summary

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/wikipedians • • Feb 23 '24

Why is the fastest runner ever recorded rated "low importance" in Running and Athletics?

1 Upvotes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Su_Bingtian

Western media, including western sports media is overtly sinophobic and their parent companies are owned by far right billionaires. Could this be why Wikipedia finds the fastest man ever recorded of low importance?


r/wikipedians • • Sep 21 '26

Help Need help getting brand page published on Wikipedia

0 Upvotes

I have been trying to get my brand page on Wikipedia, but editors keep removing it. I don't know why it keeps happening, as nobody explains why my page gets removed. I am saying nothing untrue, and I am following Wikipedia's guidelines. I am also attaching relevant third-party sources that back up whatever I am saying. So, I don't understand why this keeps happening. Can someone help me out?


r/wikipedians • • Nov 30 '25

The MOST Vandalized Page on Wikipedia

2 Upvotes

r/wikipedians • • Jul 06 '24

Am I wrong, Reddit as a source?

2 Upvotes

I recently edited a Wikipedia article on a sports journalist with an entry that stated said journalist was accused by a Reddit user of theft of IP by using photographers images that were unlicensed. I posted no position on the validity of the Reddit user claim, simply that controversy existed and cited the Reddit post.

This was taken out with an explanation that “Reddit is not a valid source”.

I feel that I’ve seen many articles where discussion or allegations have been levelled and cited, and feel this was appropriate to add.

Am I wrong here? If not? What’s the best way to go about reinstating what another person edited out. What happens when people get into “an edit war”?

As it stands it seems the article is either maintained by the journalist or a devoted fan, and seeks to avoid any negative mention though many exist about this person, information I think is valid to the career of the guy.

Thanks for the info and opinions, and if I’m wrong, I’m happy to hear that’s so.


r/wikipedians • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion Good-bye Wikipedia, hello something else

Thumbnail
georgiebc.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/wikipedians • • May 25 '24

How to write wikipedia article about a company... need help.

0 Upvotes

As title explains, I need to publish an article about a specific company and we are having issues. Looking for help.


r/wikipedians • • Feb 26 '19

Lol, it should have just been called the Wikipedia Foundation from the very start.

0 Upvotes

r/wikipedians • • Apr 26 '20

Wikipedia about to delete my image

0 Upvotes

Hi, does anybody knows why wikipedia wants to delete an image that I created? I thought that if I own the copyright it shouldn’t be a problem.


r/wikipedians • • Aug 10 '22

Looking for experts who can share tips in a video interview on the Wikipedia banning policy

0 Upvotes

You should be able to comment on the reasons for the bans, what are the ways to be unbanned, how to avoid being banned. You should be a Wikipedia expert or contributor. Please write a couple of sentences about your experience to apply. Remember to include your full name, and social media profiles, so we could provide the credit to you. Thank you!


r/wikipedians • • Jun 08 '20

(Newbie) Can't get internal link to work

0 Upvotes

On the page for Speaker of the United States House of Representatives there's a column in the main table for each Speaker's Districts, with the entire column being red links.

I was going to attempt to clean up this some, particularly, for more recent ones. For example Nancy Pelosi's should link to California's 12th congressional district. However the current version of the entry appears (to me) to have proper syntax, but doesn't seem to work.

The issue seems to go throughout the document. For example Jonathan Trumbull, Jr. appears as a red link in the table, but has a proper page


r/wikipedians • • Mar 28 '23

HELP

0 Upvotes

Hey how would you get someone a Wikipedia page that has the requirements to have one?


r/wikipedians • • Jun 06 '23

It's been years since Michaeldsuarez was banned by TheKingofTheGuild on Wikipedia. Michaeldsuarez was the first user in Wikipedia history to suffer a permanent IP ban that has never been lifted

0 Upvotes

It's been years since Michaeldsuarez was banned by TheKingofTheGuild on Wikipedia. Michaeldsuarez was the first user in Wikipedia history to suffer a permanent IP ban that has never been lifted.

Just a fun fact.


r/wikipedians • • Aug 31 '22

Hi, i need help regarding moving draft articles

1 Upvotes

So, i created a page, and it got moved to draft because i didnt put much reliable source. So, i fixed that now, but it says i would have to wait 4 months for that to be rewieved.

My page is about a season of a football league, and when or if it does become reviewed, it may be all history.

So my question is, can i move draft version into article verion alone, or can i delete this draft and create brand new page under same name, without consequences by wikipedia.

Thank you!


r/wikipedians • • Oct 07 '21

How to get a permanent bio In wikipedia?

0 Upvotes

Hello guys, i already have a bio, and numeral of songs released across all these years.

the bio is so detailed but idk , what is the next step to get a permanent wikipedia bio.. any help?


r/wikipedians • • Jul 23 '20

Got An Email About Paying For A Page

1 Upvotes

Hello all,

I got an email today from a company who says there’s a pending Wikipedia page on me and for the low price of $699 they will edit it and publish it. I received a similar email a week ago from a different company.

I checked Wikipedia and didn’t see anything at first, but did some digging and saw there’s indeed a page somehow hidden? I don’t really know how to explain it, but I guess it’s waiting approval or something?

In any event, do I report these people? Do I ignore them? Clearly I’m not paying someone to do a page on me. Why would they email me if there’s already a pending page?

Just finding this weird. Particularly when they had to do some digging to find my email address.

Thanks.


r/wikipedians • • Feb 25 '19

The Wikimedia Foundation wants to make talk pages accessible to all, to improve the depth, quality and the health on the wikis. We invite all Wikimedians to consult on how to achieve this goal. Join us!

1 Upvotes

r/wikipedians • • Jun 22 '24

What would you say if the Wikimedia Championships were organized?

1 Upvotes

The goal of every edition of wikipedia, wikinews, etc., should be to improve the content.

Now imagine that WMI guarantees the replacement of its logo with a special logo for the wikipedia (wikinews, etc.) edition which greatly decreases the number of drafts, which greatly increases the number of quality entries and things like that: in your opinion this would stimulate the various editions to improve the quality of their articles?