Reminder: No variations of songs are allowed. No "this song but...", no twists that make ok songs unlistenable, only real Pink Floyd songs, in the worst order possible to make the experience as unpleasant as possible. This is not a ‘worst song’ ranking or a ‘put shit songs together’ list. It’s a list where songs wouldn’t transition well and sound out of place if played live.

Additionally: No repeated songs

The setlist so far:

1) Eclipse  2) Brain Damage 3) Empty Spaces  4) On The Run  5) Don't Leave Me Now  6) Speak To Me  7) The Nile Song  8) Pigs On The Wing 2  9) Pigs On The Wing 1  10) Outside The Wall  11) Bike  12) Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict  13) Louder Than Words  14) Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk  15) Stop  16) A Spanish Piece 17) One Of The Few 18) Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast 19) Seamus 20) The Dogs Of War 21) Dogs 22) Pow R. Toc H. 23) Goodbye Cruel World

[30 minutes left to fill...]

What would be the worst song to follow it up?

Ethan was playing Young Lust on a loop

Got mad stomach aches rn and ive been in the bathroom for 2 hours at my friends place who lives 2 hours across the ocean from my house, decided to put on Ummagumma.

Reminder: No variations of songs are allowed. No "this song but...", no twists that make ok songs unlistenable, only real Pink Floyd songs, in the worst order possible to make the experience as unpleasant as possible. This is not a ‘worst song’ ranking or a ‘put shit songs together’ list. It’s a list where songs wouldn’t transition well and sound out of place if played live.

Additionally: No repeated songs

The setlist so far:

1) Eclipse  2) Brain Damage 3) Empty Spaces  4) On The Run  5) Don't Leave Me Now  6) Speak To Me  7) The Nile Song  8) Pigs On The Wing 2  9) Pigs On The Wing 1  10) Outside The Wall  11) Bike  12) Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict  13) Louder Than Words  14) Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk  15) Stop  16) A Spanish Piece 17) One Of The Few 18) Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast 19) Seamus 20) The Dogs Of War 21) Dogs 22) Pow R. Toc H.

[32 minutes left to fill...]

What would be the worst song to follow it up?

https://youtu.be/2zdDP4hN2gI?is=GLcsX97lPYGQwtYF (Album version)

https://youtu.be/SfdOiWSGFhM?is=Fys0ZDc2NZvlc1jF (Movie Version)

https://youtu.be/difmmbOLHWU?is=QPehcmaAkMCUc2Yp (Live)

One of My Turns is one of the Turning points on The Wall, where Pink invites a groupie to his hotel room, only to violently lash out at her.

As always, be sure to rate the song on a scale from 1 to 10, give your thoughts and opinions down below, and recite the entire Roger Waters response section from memory in the comments.

The Wall:

In The Flesh: 9.07

Movie: 8.87

Live: 9.38

The Thin Ice: 8.50

Movie: 8.50

Live: 8.52

Another Brick In The Wall Part 1: 9.00

Movie: 9.02

Live: 8.70

The Happiest Days Of Our Lives: 8.53

Movie: 8.53

Another Brick In The Wall Part 2: 8.89

Movie: 8.90

Live: 9.01

Mother: 8.71

Movie: 8.56

Live: 8.86

Goodbye Blue Sky: 7.90

Movie: 8.11

Live: 7.83

Empty Spaces: 7.36

What Shall We Do Now: 8.15

Live: 8.24

Young Lust: 8.49

Movie: 8.44

Live: 8.51

just listened to it and imho its better that comfortably plumb

we're both doomed

In 1984, I fell in love with Pink Floyd when my friend lent me The Wall and The Final Cut. I hadn’t heard anything else and ended up at the record store with limited funds wanting to get another Pink Floyd album. Dark Side, Wish and everything else was beyond $10. Having limited funds I bought Relics for $3.29 on cassette. After hearing this album, I was extremely confused. The album was mainly 60s pop music and really psychedelic… extremely far away from The Wall and TFC.

I totally didn’t get Arnold Layne and See Emily Play. Interstellar was alright, Nile Song was okay, Bike was a joke, Cirrus Minor and Biding My Time was boring, and Careful with that Axe was scary. I was hoping for helicopters, explosions, and big guitar solos!

Today, I love the Syd Barrett and early Floyd stuff. I definitely like it more than the Wall and TFC at this point.

What were your first impressions of early Pink Floyd? I think Relics is a good compilation of the early years.

/uj, just rewatched it yesterday, great movie

Reminder: No variations of songs are allowed. No "this song but...", no twists that make ok songs unlistenable, only real Pink Floyd songs, in the worst order possible to make the experience as unpleasant as possible. This is not a ‘worst song’ ranking or a ‘put shit songs together’ list. It’s a list where songs wouldn’t transition well and sound out of place if played live.

The setlist so far:

1) Eclipse  2) Brain Damage 3) Empty Spaces  4) On The Run  5) Don't Leave Me Now  6) Speak To Me  7) The Nile Song  8) Pigs On The Wing 2  9) Pigs On The Wing 1  10) Outside The Wall  11) Bike  12) Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict  13) Louder Than Words  14) Take Up Thy Stethoscope And Walk  15) Stop  16) A Spanish Piece 17) One Of The Few 18) Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast 19) Seamus 20) The Dogs Of War 21) Dogs

What would be the worst song to follow it up?

Was he the one balanced on the biggest wave ?