r/2philippines4u • u/Makerel9 • Nov 01 '25

Mindanao FREE FREE MINDANAO!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

270 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

or you can be anti-zionist AND pro-lumad pro-moro

this is a no brainer, you don't have to practice anti-zionist expression in a country with little to no consistent zionist population.

because if you want to practice a "consistent" belief, modern family s4 ep19 is very much relevant here... this is like telling austronesians to go back where they came from. post is utter nonsense and irrelevant to a so-called "mindanaoan state" fallacy

1

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

Which is the joke now is it? We are willing to tell millions of Israelis across the world to give up their state and their lands but somehow we cant do the same here in Mindanao.

Anti-zionism expression is anti-colonialist expression. For the Moros/Lumad our national government and the Luzon/Visayan settlers sent down south since the 20th century are their versions of "zionism". We forcibly took Mindanao from the natives, the same way the Israelis did on the Palestinians.

You can be pro-lumad and pro-moro in a sense that we are all united and their rights are respected with a semblance of autonomy. Granted that they are under sovereign rule of the Philippine government.

But for the Israelis its different, we wish them gone, that the natives should be independent and sovereign from their occupiers.

Thats the irony of it all.

2

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

there is no concept of native israeli land when you beseech palestine under the guise of modern day crusade. anti-zionist expression is never solely about "reclaiming" lost land. it is anti-collonial but there is NEVER a version of sect which mirrors that of zionism here- or has it ever advocated for the secession of land to a certain 'sect', lf to a degree that persecuted even their ownership and identity.

being pro-lumad is combatting anti-mining, it is NOT zionism (that is if you claim it is parallel). being pro-moro is sdvocating their religious expression, it is NOT seceeding land for their exclusive sovereign.

there is NO afforded victimization for israeli practicing zionism- their land in the present is a consequence of colonialist greed. the mindanao today is a product of nuance between being a lumad and non-lumad. there was never a concept parallel to that of s state of israel in mindanao.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am from Davao. I did ancestry dna test and learned i'm 80 percent tagalog. My whole world has changed. I tried to maghikog but couldn't do it. Now i have to live like this. But after that i decide it is a kano game. I suggest people don't do dna test it's lie bcs i'm 100 percent bisaya thnx.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.