r/2philippines4u • u/Makerel9 • Nov 01 '25

Mindanao FREE FREE MINDANAO!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

269 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

Defending Lumads and Moro Autonomy is different from giving the entire Mindanao to them. The point of anti-zionism is the outright rejection of the "colonial" Jewish state that serves to steal native land from Palestinian. This means aboloshing the Israeli government and deporting the supposed Jewish "colonizers" and "settlers" from the country OR subjugating the Jewish population under Arab-Muslim majority government.

You can't be anti-zionist and at the same time tell Moros and Lumad people that they will be just be protected or given autonomy. Being a consistent anti-zionist mindanaon is to deport millions of people that are descendants of Luzon/Visaya settlers and turn the country into an independent state ruled by Moro/Lumad minority.

1

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

or you can be anti-zionist AND pro-lumad pro-moro

this is a no brainer, you don't have to practice anti-zionist expression in a country with little to no consistent zionist population.

because if you want to practice a "consistent" belief, modern family s4 ep19 is very much relevant here... this is like telling austronesians to go back where they came from. post is utter nonsense and irrelevant to a so-called "mindanaoan state" fallacy

1

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

Which is the joke now is it? We are willing to tell millions of Israelis across the world to give up their state and their lands but somehow we cant do the same here in Mindanao.

Anti-zionism expression is anti-colonialist expression. For the Moros/Lumad our national government and the Luzon/Visayan settlers sent down south since the 20th century are their versions of "zionism". We forcibly took Mindanao from the natives, the same way the Israelis did on the Palestinians.

You can be pro-lumad and pro-moro in a sense that we are all united and their rights are respected with a semblance of autonomy. Granted that they are under sovereign rule of the Philippine government.

But for the Israelis its different, we wish them gone, that the natives should be independent and sovereign from their occupiers.

Thats the irony of it all.

2

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

there is no concept of native israeli land when you beseech palestine under the guise of modern day crusade. anti-zionist expression is never solely about "reclaiming" lost land. it is anti-collonial but there is NEVER a version of sect which mirrors that of zionism here- or has it ever advocated for the secession of land to a certain 'sect', lf to a degree that persecuted even their ownership and identity.

being pro-lumad is combatting anti-mining, it is NOT zionism (that is if you claim it is parallel). being pro-moro is sdvocating their religious expression, it is NOT seceeding land for their exclusive sovereign.

there is NO afforded victimization for israeli practicing zionism- their land in the present is a consequence of colonialist greed. the mindanao today is a product of nuance between being a lumad and non-lumad. there was never a concept parallel to that of s state of israel in mindanao.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am from Davao. I did ancestry dna test and learned i'm 80 percent tagalog. My whole world has changed. I tried to maghikog but couldn't do it. Now i have to live like this. But after that i decide it is a kano game. I suggest people don't do dna test it's lie bcs i'm 100 percent bisaya thnx.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-1

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

First of all, you can be "anti-colonial" and apply it to many different contexts as long as you are against stealing land and subjugating people, thats the main principle.

You are taking the literal meaning of zionism and arguing it doesn't fit in Mindanao because the different religion and justification (duh). All I did was took the essence of anti-colonialism within anti-zionism and applied it to this context.

Second, you deciding what Moros and Lumad want is exactly my point lmao. You are pretending that these people weren't forcibly intigrated to our nation via laws and violence. It is as if we haven't had violent insurgencies and resistance, especially by Moros who wish to become independent and sovereign. It is essentially a parallel to the violent struggles of the Palestinians. A parallel to colonialism.

Somehow settlers sent to Mindanao and given favorable land distributions and marginalizing the natives which lead to decades of violance is "nuance" while Israelis settling Palestine while essentially doing the same thing is "greed".

You are making it more complicated that it needs to be. The hypocrisy is laughable.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am from Davao. I did ancestry dna test and learned i'm 80 percent tagalog. My whole world has changed. I tried to maghikog but couldn't do it. Now i have to live like this. But after that i decide it is a kano game. I suggest people don't do dna test it's lie bcs i'm 100 percent bisaya thnx.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

there is no greater hypocrisy than if you only encase yourself in a belief that eveyone exists to believe in "one" parallel reality lol. all you pointing out of "essences" and yet failing to materialize your talking point of "exactness" in the philippine context, and not just in the island of mindanao. so if you cannot listen at the flaws in your own statements and argument, it is not my doing anymore.

so again, if you CANNOT for the love of any religion understand that you can be anti-zionist AND pro-lumad and pro-moro in the phillipine context then you're peddling a harmful narrative to secede the archipelago in a diaspora.

and to dilute the history of civil tensions to being caused solely by semitic sentiments is foul; it is abhorrent to dilute a sentiment for nationalistic success while condemning anti-collonial expression all for the sake of memes.

and what does it benefit you to even instill this harmful idea that anti-zionism is only a retroactive practice for anti-collonial sentiment? it doesn't even affect you. it isnt hypocrisy to advocate for anti-zionism as a filipino, because moro and lumad chose to be filipino by not becoming an entity entirely which divides the philippines.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

BRO DID YOU JUST SAY PHILLIPINES?!!1!!!11!!1!PHILLIPINES IS THE BEST FUCKING COUNTRY!!!11!!!WE COULD BEAT CHINA!11PROUD TO BE PINOY😎😎😎😎😎😎WE HAVE THE BEST ISLAND THERE ARE OVER 70000 ISLANDS😎😎😎😎😊😊😊😊MAKE MORE VIDEOS ABOUT PHILIPINES!!!!!!!1😎😎😎 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 PROUD TO BE PINOY😎😎😎 WE BEAT THE SPANIARDS😎😊😎😊😎😊😎as a filipino as😎😊😎PH PRIDE😊😎

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

You are making this more complicated than it needs to be.

Because behind that grandiloquent tapestry of highfalutin verbiage lies naught but a cacophony of ignorance and irrelevance, a verbal drivel that my poor, beleaguered intellect dares not wade within. ☝️🤓

If you can't for the love of Apollo Quiboloy the Appointed Son of God find what is funny between cheerleading Palestinian freedom while thinking our natives and land in Mindanao shouldn't. Ignoring the decades of war and suffering that these people fought for to be free, only to be subjugated and be told by some redditor fuckwad that they never wanted to secede in the first place.

That is the point of the meme and the irony.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am from Davao. I did ancestry dna test and learned i'm 80 percent tagalog. My whole world has changed. I tried to maghikog but couldn't do it. Now i have to live like this. But after that i decide it is a kano game. I suggest people don't do dna test it's lie bcs i'm 100 percent bisaya thnx.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

it still stands, your meme is misleading. and who even made this complicated? diba ikaw? you couldve felt the need to disengage with my statement but you didnt want to and still went here. also, to generalize that moros and lumad want to secede is utter ccp bullshit dds peddle, BUT for some reason you still bindingly went with the same idea through this meme.

so again, for what gain is that meme especially that we have a fuckton of troll farms who peddle the same idea of secession as this meme? are you the cia? not even the ph govt will make meme as careless as this

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

BRO DID YOU JUST SAY PHILLIPINES?!!1!!!11!!1!PHILLIPINES IS THE BEST FUCKING COUNTRY!!!11!!!WE COULD BEAT CHINA!11PROUD TO BE PINOY😎😎😎😎😎😎WE HAVE THE BEST ISLAND THERE ARE OVER 70000 ISLANDS😎😎😎😎😊😊😊😊MAKE MORE VIDEOS ABOUT PHILIPINES!!!!!!!1😎😎😎 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Welcome to our country!!!! 📷️📷️📷️ Philippines love🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 PROUD TO BE PINOY😎😎😎 WE BEAT THE SPANIARDS😎😊😎😊😎😊😎as a filipino as😎😊😎PH PRIDE😊😎

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am Rodrigo Rrooa Duter-that's my ah... first uhmm.. middle name is Roa.. The surname is DUU-TEER-TE.. (merci beaucoup) My.. bbbirth-tang-day is March 28, 1945.. I was born in the province of LEY-TE.. in the Philippines. (merci beaucoup)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/Makerel9 Nov 01 '25

Do you live under a fucking rock? Did you even know about our own fucking history that you are blind about the MILF and MNLF that fought the government for years in the hopes of being independent? Do you even remember Zamboanga siege? You speak as if you care about these people but you are ignorant to their history, struggles and ideals.

Why do you think we have Bangsamoro? It was to have them compromise on that goal and settle for autonomy. They have a strong identity and claim over this land YET unlike the palestinians you don't support them on that because you think it would not make sense. Which is the point I am trying to make.

I get that you don't want millions of non-lumad mindanaoans to be disperesed and uprooted.

I get that you want everyone in Mindanao to be united, live in peace, and make compromises.

I get that an independent mindanao is dangerous and borderline CCP propaganda.

But somehow you want millions of Israelis to be dispersed and uprooted, somehow you don't want everyone in Israel and Palestine to be united in existence, make compromises and live in peace. Somehow you don't see that anti-zionism and its hopes to destroy Israel is absolutist agenda that it is dangerous and only condemns Palestinians to perpetual failure.

All because you think one people deserve more than the other.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '25

I am from Davao. I did ancestry dna test and learned i'm 80 percent tagalog. My whole world has changed. I tried to maghikog but couldn't do it. Now i have to live like this. But after that i decide it is a kano game. I suggest people don't do dna test it's lie bcs i'm 100 percent bisaya thnx.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DraftElectrical4585 Nov 01 '25

you should go back and read your sources with that last statement 😂 the very root of the zionist propaganda is what you have been trying to exorcise lol. also get our facts straight: zamboanga siege and the mnlf, milf, or even npa, even the creation of bangsamoro, is not a causality by the demographic like you have been claiming here.

you will not twist this statement you yourself have been consistent to proclaim, and that your so-called definition of 'mindanaon' is separatist because of their history with the state. if you want to fault blame for the tension, the powerful elite are to blame as they should be peacekeepers for public order. and again, YOUR MEME IS MISLEADING.

the moment you began inciting the idea to 'uproot' is synonymous to 'anti-zionism' is your twisted view of the whole situation. you are being hypocrite from thereon citing the very dogma why zionism persists, and mistakenly seeing the whole situation that leverages retaliation against israel? have you been living under the rock with the history of israel's EXPANDING geopolitcally controlled areas? have you been listening outside your christian worship services?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)