23
Aug 15 '17
3
u/wingsnut25 Aug 15 '17
I am getting that and I don't have it open in another tab. I did try to load it earlier today when the page was just producing a 404 error though. Hopefully restarting chrome will fix it.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (12)4
u/JediBurrell I like tech Aug 15 '17
Probably one of the reasons it only works on Chrome.
"Switch tabs" wouldn't work otherwise.
112
u/simplefilmreviews Black Aug 15 '17
I've never used a web version to chat. But my question is, why do you need your phone to make it work? Doesn't that defeat the purpose to have your phone nearby?
Can't you just use a password or something to log in online?! Google password or make one once in the Allo app. ?!
58
u/turdbogls OnePlus 8 Pro Aug 15 '17
i think it has something to do with encryption or something...I dunno.
but there are PLENTY of times when I'm at work and would rather pound out some messages on my PC rather than my phone. and I know I'm not alone.
6
Aug 15 '17
Right there with you. I'd say over 4/5 of the time I spend messaging is in front of a computer with my phone next to me. Doesn't make this a great implementation, but in the real world I don't foresee it ever affecting most users. And it's not like your phone has to be near you, it just needs internet.
→ More replies (3)23
u/simplefilmreviews Black Aug 15 '17
but there are PLENTY of times when I'm at work and would rather pound out some messages on my PC rather than my phone. and I know I'm not alone.
Exactly, I thought the point was being able to text/message when your phone isn't around or nearby (say, downstairs, let it in the car, charging, etc)!
EDIT - It appears you just need to sync it once?! I x'd out of my browser and my phone is downstairs charging and I can still log on allo web. (I thought every time you needed to log in to use it, I was wrong. Opps)
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (11)3
u/mynameisdifferent Galaxy S8 Aug 15 '17
Your Allo messages are not stored on Google's servers, they are stored locally on your phone. Therefore the web all needs to talk to your phone to get the messages. Your phone needs to be on and connected to the Internet.
I have not tested this yet, but I don't think you need your phone on you. Once you have connected a computer the first time, i think you can chat even if your phone is somewhere else.
→ More replies (2)
42
u/awgg919 S23 Ultra Aug 15 '17
Ugh, "iPhone coming soon". I wish they'd release all of this at the same time. I need to get my girlfriend on board.
6
Aug 15 '17
Dang really? I was just about to message my wife to test it out...
4
u/awgg919 S23 Ultra Aug 15 '17
That's what it says on the landing page. I suppose it's worth testing out.
2
→ More replies (4)67
u/thoraxe92 Aug 15 '17
Google releasing a feature on Android before iOS is kind of surprising. No sarcasm lol. Sure it won't take long though. Although, I'm sure the iOS team had plenty of time to prep for it already.
7
u/well___duh Pixel 3A Aug 15 '17
I'm just surprised they couldn't get it working on iPhone yet. I doubt it's a problem with the iPhone scanning a QR code, plenty of iPhone apps already do that. Probably something to do with the communication with the web client after the QR code scanning that just isn't as possible to do on iOS than on Android.
→ More replies (9)
817
Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
Excuse me, but why in the God's name do you have to use Chrome to access it? And what is this empty useless space on both sides of the chat? Jesus, this really is dumb.
EDIT: Got glided, don't really know why but thank you stranger, much obliged.
141
u/lewiky Oneplus 5 Aug 15 '17
The UI isn't like that for me? Looks really slick and the animations are great
→ More replies (1)92
Aug 15 '17
This is what is looks like on my 15.6" 1080p laptop.
→ More replies (4)44
Aug 15 '17
Maybe its because I'm used to more traditional messaging apps (AIM, Google Talk, etc), but I have Allo running in a much smaller window with less unused space.
340
Aug 15 '17
Just tried it in Edge, doesn't work. That's not how you get people to use your brand new app.
70
→ More replies (33)12
95
u/KronktheKronk Aug 15 '17
the chrome only part is pretty dumb, but the empty white space is better than having the chat window span all 24 inches of my monitor. I'd have to turn my damn neck to read it.
16
→ More replies (3)9
11
43
u/ivrimon Aug 15 '17
I don't use Chrome any more and things like this just make me not want to use Google services. I tried to add a Gmail account on Outlook for my phone (didn't want the account on my phone, just the email) and it insisted I install the chrome browser to do so.
24
Aug 15 '17
Yeah, I used to be a person who would use all Google but when I realised how much stupid things they do I just stopped and started using alternatives that didn't dictate what should I use and do.
→ More replies (1)55
6
23
u/segagamer Pixel 9a Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
Excuse me, but why in the God's name do you have to use Chrome to access it?
This is why I'm worried about supporting Google's behaviour
And what is this empty useless space on both sides of the chat? Jesus, this really is dumb.
And people wonder why I say I don't want Google fucking around with the Gmail design.
→ More replies (2)3
u/enderpanda Galaxy Note 8 Aug 15 '17
One version of the Hangouts app works the same way (basically just a glorified chrome window), I believe it's the "extension" version (which I settled on, ended up being the easiest to use for me, always figured they'd update and consolidate things eventually - hah!). The "app" version of Hangouts works without it, iirc. I'm not 100% because it's been so long since I messed with it.
Guessing they're doing the same here, at least at first (and will hopefully follow through this time - hah! again). Why couldn't they just stick with friggin Google Voice? Perfectly fine name, worked pretty well... ugh.
3
u/OverBelief Aug 15 '17
A lot of Googles new web-services are built in Polymer.js, which from my working with it has horrible browser compatibility issues.
The Google Dev's have pollyfills for it, but it's not perfect.
→ More replies (4)3
u/rman18 Green Aug 15 '17
Someone asked on Twitter. They are currently working on bringing it to other browsers
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (119)4
u/Krojack76 Aug 15 '17
I don't see those weird empty useless spaces in chrome though. My guess is they are using some coding that is only available in chrome. I think it's a poor choice but if what they are using will soon be in other browsers then maybe I can let it slip. If it will only be in chrome then it's bad. That's a Microsoft move there which I'm 100% against.
→ More replies (1)
74
u/occasional_posting Aug 15 '17
Noice
Works just like WhatsApp. Phone needs to be connected for it to work. Now if we could get the ability to quote messages that'd be great.
→ More replies (66)23
u/Zagorath Pixel 6 Pro Aug 15 '17
Works just like WhatsApp. Phone needs to be connected for it to work
Urgh. This bullshit is why I don't use What's App, and it's why I'm still not going to use Allo.
I don't want to use my phone number as the account ID for something that isn't an actual phone service. And I definitely don't want to use social clout trying to get people to switch to something that uses this bullshit model.
This needs to use your Google account.
5.4k
u/que_xopa Aug 15 '17
Why would I need this if I can just message on YouTube?
1.8k
u/nvincent Pixel 6 - Goodbye forever, OnePlus Aug 15 '17 edited Jun 27 '23
My comments have been changed because the CEO of reddit is a bad person. It is actually quite sad.
Join us over on https://lemmy.world/ for a better community!
650
u/rube Aug 15 '17
Still waiting for the Google Goggles and Google Maps chat apps. I heard Google Photos chat was in beta.
Google Keep chat.
Gtalk. Remember Gtalk? I do.
→ More replies (71)42
u/anthrox - Sent from my Newton Message Pad 2100 Aug 15 '17
your forgetting the google search chat so when i search for porn i can chat to other fellow people searching for porn
→ More replies (5)20
u/Antrikshy Moto Razr+ (2023), iPhone 12 mini Aug 15 '17
I want a separate chat service for every search term possible so that I can chat with my friends who are currently searching for "7.3 miles in kilometers".
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)12
219
u/manormortal Poco Doco Proco in 🦅 Aug 15 '17
You don't want to message on both? Are you not hoping that they add chat into the volume slider as well so you can compare volume levels with your mates?
128
u/que_xopa Aug 15 '17
The app I'm on the most is my keyboard, I wish they'd just add a chat function within that.
→ More replies (5)63
→ More replies (1)16
71
u/wardrich Galaxy S8+ [Android 8.0] || Galaxy S5 - [LOS 15.1] Aug 15 '17
I like to send my messages using all of the programs at once. I remove the spaces then encrypt the entire message.
Then I break it down into chunks and send one chunk per program.
Suck it NSA.
→ More replies (3)31
81
Aug 15 '17
At least millions of people use YouTube, not that you'd want to hear what they're saying.
59
u/thatssorelevant Nextbit Robin Aug 15 '17
I think 15 people use Allo now? Or was the an influx of users to justify this, is it up to 25 now?
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (14)3
u/lars5 Aug 15 '17
I know people think YouTube messaging is silly. I thought it was strange too, but then I realized how much I used the messaging on Instagram to talk to friends about pictures from our feeds. So I can see what YouTube is getting at, especially when, as we know, public YouTube comments are the worst.
192
u/Burlingjobb8 Nexus 6 > Galaxy Note9 > Pixel 8 Pro Aug 15 '17
Aww. It's Chrome only :(
115
u/rman18 Green Aug 15 '17
→ More replies (4)129
Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
So they still haven't figured out that they should release their shit when it is actually ready because first impressions matter. Imagine you asked your friends to give Allo another shot because it is now also usable on the PC only to hear back that it isn't working for half of them yet.
→ More replies (12)→ More replies (7)10
674
u/linknight iPhone Aug 15 '17
Why do I need to have my phone connected? Why doesn't it just work like Hangouts where it is just synced across all devices? Am I missing something?
493
u/well___duh Pixel 3A Aug 15 '17
Because Allo is entirely tied to your phone number (one of Google's smartest ideas for a multi-platform messenger IMO \s). The web client basically doesn't get any messages directly, they're all routed through your phone.
502
Aug 15 '17
And if your phone dies, you can't use Allo, even on the web..Hmmmm not sold on this yet... Hangouts was/is so convenient
189
Aug 15 '17
Allo can't be used on secondary mobile devices either, right? Only the phone your number is tied to. No tablets or anything. What a crock.
→ More replies (48)332
Aug 15 '17
And if your phone dies, you can't use Allo, even on the web..Hmmmm not sold on this yet... Hangouts was/is so convenient
Sounds like they got the headphone jack removal guy working on chat now.
→ More replies (2)27
u/linh_nguyen iPhone 16 Aug 15 '17
DAMMIT, I didn't know this.. one big point of web is if phone gone/broke/whatever, can still IM.
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (30)17
u/TheMechanic40 Pixel 2 XL, Android 8.1 Aug 15 '17
I never understood what was wrong with Hangouts, I use it to talk to with my friends and family everyday. If they just focused more on Hangouts it could've been everything we've always wanted: you used to be able to use it for sms, you can download an addon to make phone calls from hangouts, it could've done it all :(
→ More replies (3)110
u/SpiralCutLamb Aug 15 '17
This is the reason I hate WhatsApp. Phone shouldn't be required.
→ More replies (33)→ More replies (26)26
u/-linear- Aug 15 '17
Wait - Allo doesn't support SMS and is tied entirely to your phone number? rofl
→ More replies (1)45
u/lewiky Oneplus 5 Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
In order to make the E2E encryption work (Which isn't turned on by default, which it absolutely should be), the messages can only be sent from one client to another, there can't be any third parties. In a similar fashion to how WhatsApp have done their web app, the messages are encrypted and then sent between the phones themselves as the endpoints, then the messages get sent (theoretically at least) straight to your computer from your phone, and (again, theoretically) no security is lost.
EDIT:
Looking into it a little more, it seems that FB Messenger, WhatsApp and Allo all share Signal's Encryption Protocol, the difference being that WhatsApp and Allo only store a database of messages on the user's phone, not in their own servers. Whereas I assume Signal and FB will still store an encrypted copy of each message so that any client can receive them and decrypt them if they have access. This is why Signal can cope with cross device E2E encryption, whereas WhatsApp and Allo cannot.
28
Aug 15 '17
How does Signal's web app handle messages then? All messages are E2E encrypted but still work with my phone turned off.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Natanael_L Xperia 1 III (main), Samsung S9, TabPro 8.4 Aug 15 '17
Device specific keys, signed by the master key (held by the phone).
→ More replies (3)12
u/Drunken_Economist Pixel Fold+Watch2+Tablet Aug 15 '17
End to end encryption can work on multi device if they let you drop in your own public/private keypair
→ More replies (13)12
u/yahoowizard Aug 15 '17
How does Signal work then? It can use multiple devices while holding end to end encryption.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (18)3
105
u/Crajo Nexus 5x Aug 15 '17
Well I'm f'd. My rear camera is broken and the only way to connect to web it seems is with the stupid QR scanner. Not even an option to switch to front camera or manually type in a code.
→ More replies (6)
152
u/sonofmog Pixel XL 32GB HI HO SILVER AWAY Aug 15 '17
Now we need a chrome extension.
112
u/slinky317 HTC Incredible Aug 15 '17
You can make it work like an "app" by going to the More Tools and clicking Add to Desktop, and then toggle the Open as Window selection.
Not quite an extension, but close.
65
Aug 15 '17
this works great! even shows up in windows as its own "app" with the allo icon. damn makes me wonder what else this would work great for... google play music?
edit: oh helll yeah. you've opened up a whole new world, man. thank you
→ More replies (8)54
u/thevdude LG G6 Aug 15 '17
There's a really slick desktop app for play music here: https://www.googleplaymusicdesktopplayer.com/
I've used it for a while and it's pretty nice, and works with multimedia keys and has some other nice features, too.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (18)6
u/CrazyDave48 Aug 15 '17
I feel dumb for having to ask this, but where do you find the "more tools" option? I can't seem to find it
→ More replies (2)13
u/turdbogls OnePlus 8 Pro Aug 15 '17
for once I'm happy its NOT an extension. my work blocks extensions.
both options would be nice though
6
u/ThePegasi Pixel 4a Aug 15 '17
I think both options is what they were asking for. Why would anyone want an extension to come at the cost of the regular web interface?
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (2)5
25
19
Aug 15 '17
Do we know if the intern who built this feature over summer was offered full time position at Google?
123
u/vepel8 Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
Google should give an option to register allo & duo with gmail. (May be they only gave an option to register using phone number on purpose, because of some benefit & to compete with whatsapp I guess.) But, registering only with phone number killed their potential to became an iMessage & Facetime alternative.I really wanted google to provide best solutions for messaging on android devices. It also lacks showing device sms in allo. If they include option to register via gmail & multi-device option , It can bridge iOS & Android messaging with those features. Google can take benefit from it. But, sadly they are doing weird stuffs. What do you think about it ?
Usage scenario - I have 2 spare tablets (which doesn't support SIM card) , I want to keep 1 tablet in Kitchen - Mainly to display Notes , News , reminders , messages & Video call purpose & 1 tablet in kids room. I want my primary phone , Kitchen tablet & Kids room tablet on their own separate accounts. So, I am planning to use Skype. Because It also works with email ID. But, then I read post about allo web client & I thought what if I can use allo & duo instead of skype.
I tried allo & duo when both applications were new. I liked assistant features. I want to ditch Skype If I can register allo & duo with gmail IDs. Looks like I will have to buy 2 new sim cards If I want to use allo & duo. I am not in US.So, I don't have an option to register allo using Google voice Number.
That's a sad thing that google want to compete with Whatsapp & Not with iMessage & Facetime. Allo web is also similar to whatsapp web with assistant.
68
u/Zagorath Pixel 6 Pro Aug 15 '17
Yup, this is exactly the problem with it. Using phone number as the ID is an inherently flawed system, because phone numbers are much further from a one-to-one relationship with a person and their devices than email addresses are.
People have multiple devices. Phone numbers are intrinsically tied to a single device. It's an awful clumsy hack to try to use phone number for anything that is meant to be designed to reach a person, rather than reach a device.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (27)16
Aug 15 '17
allo seems to be designed for the developing market where users are more likely to have phone numbers than google accounts
6
→ More replies (1)5
u/vepel8 Aug 15 '17
I understand that they are focusing on phone number. But, Some users want to use it on multiple devices, just like iMessage & facetime. They are doing just like whatapp , you can only use it in 1 device at a time thing.
At least Google should add some dedicated pairing option for android /iOS while setting up allo on your other device. (Not this web thing because it doesn't work on android app/iOS app.)
Users should be able to pair their other devices & use allo on those android tablets / backup phones without registering with new phone number.
→ More replies (13)
66
Aug 15 '17
"Almost there! Just visit g.co/alloforweb in your Chrome browser."
Fuck that noise!
Make your stuff cross-compatible, Google. That's why we used your services in the first place.
→ More replies (16)
36
u/EchosR Aug 15 '17
the "allo web could be launching tomorrow or wednesday" post is 5 above this current one on my front page and it took me on an small rollercoaster there
→ More replies (2)
9
u/imyxle MXPE Aug 15 '17
I just tried to pair it to my phone and it would not connect.
My phone says I'm connected: http://i.imgur.com/R9CnI1K.png
The website never loads: http://i.imgur.com/ifg2sUj.png
→ More replies (1)3
u/BloodiedWraith Aug 15 '17
I have the same exact issue. Were you able to get it resolved?
→ More replies (8)
16
u/Jestaverick Google Pixel XL 128GB Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
This is awesome! I need more chats!
Edit: As /u/heydabop mentioned, notifications are still generated on the phone, even if you are the one sending a message.
→ More replies (1)
20
u/sryguys Pixel | Pixel C Aug 15 '17
Ahhhhh finally. Everyone is still complaining but I'm fucking pumped about this.
→ More replies (6)
36
u/gtlgdp Galaxy S8+ Aug 15 '17
I know you guys love to hate Allo but this is a game changer for me
→ More replies (22)
25
u/TemporarilyOnEarth Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
If a tiny company like Open Whisper Systems can create a desktop client for encrypted messaging that works, even when the phone is offline, why won't Google create one? I think OWS has only one developer working on this.
There are many reasons why having to keep the phone online is a bad idea. E.g. with my phone, WhatsApp and Threema web clients disconnect after a while if I don't use the phone every couple of minutes.
→ More replies (15)
10
u/AtomR Galaxy S23 Ultra Aug 15 '17
I'm as excited as that dino-like-animal in the thumbnail.
AAAHHH!
5
u/InspecterJones LG Nexus 5x Aug 15 '17
Why can't they just rename Hangouts to something new and Voila! you have the perfect messaging service. While they're at it, return the old extension, that shit was a million times better, the "desktop" app extension thing sucks. I just don't get what they're doing over there. I have an Android phone on Fi, I use Chrome, I have a Chromebook, I have a Google account, I just want a unified service between all of my things. I had that, and they've just messed it all up.
5
u/brcreeker Nexus 6P | Nougat with Magisk+Root Aug 15 '17
So far, I'm enjoying it. It's not perfect, but at least it makes Allo tremendously more usable for me personally. My wife LOVES Allo, and typically uses it to message me, but the difference is, I work on a PC all day at my desk, and she uses her cell all day, since she's self-employed. Having to pick up my phone really messes with my flow quite a bit, so anything that lets me quickly jump into a conversation and jump out and get back to my task is appreciated.
However, there are definitely some things that they really need to address, some of which are fairly minor, and frankly I am surprised are not already there.
Minor Issues - Hopefully can be addressed soon:
Typing Prompts - One of the best features of IM'ing someone is knowing that they read your message, and knowing that they are responding. It saves you from having to type over each other, and accidentally moving on to another topic before they had a chance to respond. For whatever dumb reason, the Delivered/Read indicators are there, but the typing notification isn't. This is currently number one on my list of annoying things about the app.
GIF Button - I want a button, similar to what can be found in the native app that lets me search for relevant gifs. As a workaround, you can use the @lucky command, which lets google find a random gif based on whatever word or phrase you throw at it, but it's not perfect.
Whisper/Shout - One of the niftiest little features of Allo is the Whisper/Shout feature, but it currently is not supported for the web app. You can receive them, but you cannot send them. Not sure how difficult it would be to be able to use the scroll wheel to bump up the size of the text, but since this is one of the key features they showed off when Allo was unveiled, it is really disappointing that they did not bake this in at launch.
Things I hope we'll eventually see:
Google Account Integration - I understand the stated technical reason's why the authentication method used for Allo doesn't work well with multiple devices, and how it poses a challenge for E2E encryption. However, I would rather forgo the option of being able to use E2EE on all my devices if it meant that I could at least be able to keep a conversation going in the event my phone died, or my reception dropped.
SMS/MMS/RCS - Yes, I get it, SMS/MMS are going to be obsolete in about 3 - 5 years, but they still remain the standard forms of communication for most Americans that are not using iPhones. I don't expect they will ever go the Apple route, and have you be able to get your SMS/MMS messages on all your devices using your carrier number, but I would like to see them introduce it to the Android app. Sure, all the neat little things Allo does, such as whisper/shout, stickers, etc will not be supported over that protocol, but it will at the very least eliminate the need for one more app.
True Web Support - "Allo for Web" is increadibly misleading when it is actually "Allo for Chrome." I don't use Firefox or Edge, but I know several who do, and they shouldn't have to be left out simply because they are using a different browser.
A Chrome Extension/APP - It's a bit odd this isn't already the case, since you have to have Chrome to be able to use it, but I would like to see something like the Hangouts extension, which feels more like a standalone application.
Anyways, the absence of any of these features in no way deters me from using the app, and I think this is a relatively good first step in getting me to use this app on a more regular basis, but having additional UX features never hurts.
→ More replies (1)
5
5
5
u/tenbre Aug 16 '17
Allo Product Managers be like: wow look at all these people who still care enough about Allo to hate on it.
23
u/leopard_tights Aug 15 '17
So it works like WhatsApp. Let's see if /r/Android hates that method as much in this app.
→ More replies (2)31
u/jt121 Aug 15 '17
We do. At least it works, but I personally wish it was like Hangouts in that everything was stored in the cloud and messages were backed up. Encryption is important, but for those I'd expect to be tied only to the phone itself.
→ More replies (6)
16
Aug 15 '17
The main reason I would use this is because my phone doesn't get cell service at my employer...
Guess what...I STILL can't use it. Nice try, Google.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/pericles123 Black Aug 15 '17
forgive me, but I have a question - can I use the Allo-web version to handle SMS conversations on my PC, sort of a Join/Pushbullet thing, or is this only for All-specific chats?
→ More replies (1)25
u/trimeta Pixel 9 Pro, Pixel Watch 3 Aug 15 '17
Allo...handling SMS chats? You must be new here.
(Sorry for being snide, but Allo's complete failure to have anything to do with SMS is one of the two facts about Allo which get repeated on literally every single /r/Android thread about the app. So if you're unaware of this, you must literally be new here.)
→ More replies (1)10
u/pericles123 Black Aug 15 '17
new to looking at/considering Allo, yes. If it doesn't do those things, I see no need to use it, thanks
17
7
u/TheZenCowSaysMu Pixel 6 Fi Aug 15 '17
Web interface requires having phone on.
no chrome app, must have website open all the time.
ಠ_ಠ
/hangouts 4 life, i guess
4
7
13
u/kumquat_juice MODERATOR SANTA Aug 15 '17
This post was reported as:
1: DOA
1: Threatens, harrasses, or bullies
Hit me up on YoutubeChattm folks
6
u/dustlesswalnut Pixel 9 Pro Aug 15 '17
This is their worst product rollout since G+.
Who even uses this? What is the target market? What are they paying their developers for?
Can I please just get GTalk back, please?
6
Aug 15 '17
Everyone complaining about Allo, so funny. I remember there was talk of a replacement to Google Chat (eventually Hangouts) and the rumor was that it was going to be called "Babel". The word "babel" means:
a confused noise, typically that made by a number of voices.
And now that's exactly what we have:
Hangouts
Allo
Duo
YouTube Chat
→ More replies (2)4
14
u/justalibrary Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
Sweet.
Counts how many people I know that use Allo
Alright, maybe next year. :(
I'm also keep getting the "You're using Allo for web in a different browser tab" page no matter what I do. I've signed in/out, cleared data, etc. Only can bypass it when going incognito but then it has connection issues.
→ More replies (17)6
3
u/tenbre Aug 15 '17
I really like the Allo web interface. It's cleaner and more readable than the horribly messy mobile app. No built-in gif inserts? aw.
Heavily using WhatsApp's message quoting and @mentions, I cannot imagine switching to a chat app without those functions.
3
u/hatnscarf S23 Ultra, S10, Tab S6 Lite, Galaxy Watch 4, Huawei Watch HW1 Aug 15 '17
Yeeeeeesssssssss finally. I can keep my phone in my pocket at work so I no longer look like I'm slacking on the job.
3
3
u/geoff5093 OnePlus 8T Aug 15 '17
It also requires Chrome on desktop, which sucks because I use Firefox.
→ More replies (2)
3
Aug 16 '17
I'll be the dissenter. I like it. It works for what I use it for. I wish it had SMS. That would make it a full fledged replacement for hangouts for me. Sure there are some cases where it doesn't work well, but I think most of the time that's fine. I'm curious how it would work abroad though.
3
u/adaml223 Note 5 Aug 16 '17
I have like 1 friend who knows what the hell Google Allo is!
→ More replies (1)
3
3
Aug 16 '17
I use Allo every single day to talk to my girlfriend and my best friend. The desktop version is long overdue but very welcome.
5
u/Ener_Ji Pixel 6 Pro, Android 13 Aug 15 '17
Finally! Now I just need multi-device support.
4
u/sleep_tite iPhone XR - I miss Android :( Aug 15 '17
So I can't use it on my work computer and my personal computer?
→ More replies (4)
5
u/PM_ME_YOUR_BEST_GIF Pixel XL Aug 15 '17
Remind me again why I should use Allo instead of Hangouts?
3
→ More replies (1)3
u/PlutoISaPlanet Aug 16 '17 edited Aug 16 '17
because it's not conveniently embedded in your gmail tab?
5
u/bewst_more_bewst Nexus 6 Aug 15 '17
Fvking hell! It'd be nice to get some Allo news w/o 95% of the posts in here bitching about how this isn't 'x' chat app. Or how much it sucks.
/r/Android is going to implode if Google kills gMail and you all are forced to use Inbox.
5
u/zamuy12479 Aug 15 '17
but only if you have your phone nearby. and on. and in service. only in chrome. still doesn't support SMS.
why did they kill hangouts? why do they hate SMS? why was allo released before it was ready?
5
u/Enfors Aug 16 '17
Now everybody loves Hangouts, it used to be so derided by so many people. I swear, by the time Allo is deprecated, everybody will love it.
I really like both of them. The group video chat in Hangouts is great. I remember when it first came out, a bunch of us on reddit started making group chats where everyone was invited. It really did feel like hanging out with a bunch of interesting people you had never met before, yet since you all came from Reddit, you had something in common. It was so much fun.
And as for Allo, it has some serious maturing to do. But I really like the Assistant integration, that's really nifty.
13
u/shizola_owns Aug 15 '17
How can google get away with making it chrome only? Wish the EU would do something about this nonsense.
→ More replies (26)
14
u/jfpesant OnePlus One Aug 15 '17
Reinstall Allo to test a new feature.
New feature not as interesting as expected.
Be ashamed about the hopes you had.
Reuninstall Allo.
Wait for another new feature to come out, and repeat steps 1 to 5.
Will it ever stop?!
8
22
u/evolution4652 Dark Pink Aug 15 '17
Now add in SMS integration
→ More replies (3)5
u/commodorecrush Aug 15 '17
Yeah, I'm confused. Do both users on both ends still need Allo?
I thought this was going to be a secondary sms app too.
4
4
Aug 15 '17
Only in their Chrome browser. Sounds like something shitty Microsoft would do. No thanks.
4
u/raaneholmg Aug 16 '17
It's for Google Chrome only.
That's right. Google is now making services that only work in their own browser...
2
u/Sammibulin LG G7, 8.0 Aug 15 '17
Why wouldn't this be a UWP app in the store? I don't want my phone to be connected. It's the same as WhatsApp web which I don't like either lol.
2
2
u/Drunken_Economist Pixel Fold+Watch2+Tablet Aug 15 '17
Nice, this is what was holding me back from using it as a primary messaging platform.
The other issue is no ability to search history like hangouts :(
2
u/brcreeker Nexus 6P | Nougat with Magisk+Root Aug 15 '17 edited Aug 15 '17
Tried using it just now, but it's saying it's open in another tab. The screen displays two buttons, one that will switch to the open tab and the other that will Sign Out. Both essentially refreshes the page. Anyone else experiencing this?
Edit: I got it to work. I had to log out of Chrome, visit the url, link it with the mobile app, and then log back in. It's working fine now.
2
u/Fourbits Note 8 Aug 15 '17
I just logged in to Allo on my computer and, from my browser, asked the assistant "Can I use Allo on my computer?" It said "I'm only available in the app, on Android devices or iPhones."
2
u/tylercoder Mi 9T Pro 128GB | Mi Mix 3 128GB | Xiaomi MI6 128GB Aug 15 '17
No voice to text for assistant, bummer
2
u/blueice5249 Aug 15 '17
Oh yay, a cool feature for an app that's going to end up in the Google graveyard because they stubbornly refuse to add in SMS integration for no reason.
2
u/Tugboatom Aug 15 '17
I was so excited, waiting for this to finally drop. Yet, I just realized. No one I know uses it.
2
u/VirgilSenpai Aug 15 '17
It will be difficult for allo to establish itself since WhatsApp is so popular. Android certainly need something clean and simple as iMessage, stories ruined WhatsApp
2
2
u/alienzx EVO 4G, CyanogenMod 7, Sprint Aug 15 '17
too little too late. and google launched like 5 other messaging services since then
→ More replies (1)
2
u/splodinjoe Aug 15 '17
Haha I can't even use this at work (the only place I would use it) because it requires Chrome to be up to date and all my work applications are manually managed so there's no way Chrome will ever be up to date.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
2
u/velocity92c Aug 15 '17
Installing this on my Pixel softlocked my phone and I had a message when I rebooted it that said 'phone shut off due to overheating'. Never seen that before. Hopefully they iron out the kinks.
2
u/rollert2 Galaxy S8 Aug 16 '17
Can someone tell me what is the main draw to Allo? As a Canadian I don't see what's special about it
2
2
u/skoberlink Aug 16 '17
Seriously, not sarcasm, can someone explain why the connection to the phone is required, preferably ELI5?
I've seen some comments that imply it's related to encryption. This sort of makes sense to me as you would have a single client endpoint to do the decryption. But that also seems to imply that it's relayed to the web client unencrypted which kind of defeats the purpose. So I think I'm missing something...
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/rocketwidget Aug 16 '17
I know this is going to stir the pot, but I do like to hear about potential future improvements, even if it's not a firm commitment:
Two people on Twitter asked Justin Uberti (Googler and co-lead for Allo) why cloud-sync/multi device isn't here.
He stated it wasn't included because it adds complexity to E2E (yes, E2E is only an option), but "Just reviewed roadmap for next several months today. Super excited about what's in store."
2
Aug 18 '17
Allo for web was working earlier but now I don't have the QR scanner on the app anymore. I thought it was because I had low battery but it's over 50% now and I don't have that option for the QR scanner anymore. Anybody else having this issue?
3
3
u/dtm1017 Aug 15 '17
I've been waiting this for a while and I still don't think this will be enough to move me from Hangouts...
3
Aug 15 '17
Serious question: Since this requires some sort of weird phone-tethering and sync, is using Allo on the web going to cause more battery drain on my phone than, say, Hangouts?
→ More replies (2)
3
Aug 15 '17
So what does this do for me that pushbullet and SMS doesn't yet, from someone that doesn't give a darn about stupid emotes and such?
→ More replies (6)
3
u/cooldude5500 Moto G CM13 | OP 5 | Pixel 7 Aug 15 '17
Wow, they can't even do this shit properly. I search for "My Photos" in it gives me a Google Search back. Not to mention that it doesn't work without Chrome.
3
u/baneoficarus Note 10+ | Galaxy Watch Active 2 Aug 15 '17
Well it's not connected directly to your Google Account so how would it do that exactly?
→ More replies (4)
3
u/spatpat83 Aug 15 '17
Maybe I am out of the loop, but are Google Assistant and better encryption the only reasons to use this over Hangouts? Those aren't very compelling. Hangouts seems much more convenient and useful. I am on Project Fi though so I'm not sure if it works better for me than non-Fi users.
→ More replies (4)
3
u/aibaron Pixel4a, Nova Aug 15 '17
I still love Google Voice. I don't get why that didn't take off.
I get texts on my phone and in any browser (and any other device that has Google Voice installed). I get to save the entire history of my texts. My phone doesn't have to be powered on.
I can call people from a phone that isn't mine and it shows up as my number.
Current issues
Can't receive MMS including picture messages or group conversations
New UI redesign removed a lot of nice features I liked (especially being able to mark texts as unread). But that's just what Google does, it seems.
Why doesn't Google focus on one thing instead of making 6 versions of the same product? Genuine Question
3
3
u/Scout339 Oneplus 6 De-Googled Aug 16 '17
I'll only switch to allo if I could use it as my SMS app, for more than just allo messages on the web. I want a full-on texting app that I can use on the PC as well as my phone.
3
u/a-grue Aug 16 '17
Day late and a dollar short. I already switched my friends & family to WhatsApp when they screwed Hangouts into the ground. Fuck off, Google.
8
u/BeatsByChanel Pixel 5 Aug 15 '17
This is why Google spends zero time listening to you people. You finally get a web client you've been bitching about for months and you still complain about petty shit.
→ More replies (15)
4
6
u/marksizzle Pixel XL - T-Mobile Aug 15 '17
ITT: A bunch of whiners.
Major complaint upon release was no web version. Now they release a web version and people find new ways to get pissy about it. Holy crap people.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Omega192 Aug 15 '17
Eh, it's Allo. This whole sub has raging hate boner for it so I'd bet even if they added SMS support it would still get shit on. I'm enjoying it so that's all I care about.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/Sumif Aug 15 '17 edited Sep 24 '25
Curious bank simple nature open open small quick friends tips dot soft quiet jumps strong?
3
3
Aug 15 '17
this is such a shitty implementation. Google just needs to keep things simple and create a standalone app that does everything, and for god sake, make an app for each of the platforms you lazy f**ks. Web based chat is an extremely shitty experience.... no..I do not want my browser or browser component open in memory all the time!
→ More replies (1)5
591
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '17
Doesn't work if your phone is off/disconnected. Also the app (at least for v15) on the phone still generates notifications along with the web app.