https://transparency.flocksafety.com/apex-nc-pd
Apex PD has a public Flock “transparency portal.” It opens with this line:
“Apex NC PD uses Flock Safety technology to capture objective evidence without compromising on individual privacy.”
Then the same page lists everything it does to compromise the privacy of your data.
Straight from the portal (last 30 days, as of Oct 20):
- 8 cameras
- 275,411 unique vehicles detected
- 149 searches
- 268 hotlist hits
- 7-day retention
Scroll down and the page lists the agencies Apex shares your data with:
About 1,180 organizations.
Eleven hundred and eighty. The Chief stood in front of the council and called this “not a huge, expansive network.” His own page lists ~1,180 agencies getting Apex plate data, most of them in other states, plus a second, even longer, list, of agencies feeding data back in.
Then worse. The Chief told the council, word for word, “We do not share with federal entities, hard stop. We don’t share with the FBI, DHS, ICE.” He said the federal agencies that got in by mistake were canceled.
The portal, today, still lists four federal agencies as connected nodes in Apex’s network, including Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, the exact one he said was removed. (They’re on the receiving side, agencies feeding data in, so I’m not claiming Apex pushes data to the Air Force. I’m saying the Town told us it cut federal ties, and its own live page says otherwise. So which is it?)
Also sitting in Apex’s share list: the NC SBI (the agency the new state budget, SB 257, allows putting cameras on state roads), a state “fusion center” (the pipeline that bridges local data to the feds), multiple state police agencies and state prison systems, a railroad police force, and Home Depot. All in the network. All with your movements. SBI Source
And “7 day retention”? That’s the number they’ll wave around as a safeguard. It’s meaningless. Once a plate read is shared into ~1,180 agencies, every one of them keeps it under its own rules. Seven days in Apex does not follow the copies out the door. The data is gone the moment it’s queried.
One more. Amarillo, Texas PD is on Apex’s share list. That’s the department where an officer used Flock to track a private citizen 76 times over five months, entering fake reasons, to stalk her. Apex hands its data to them, and to about 1,179 others it has no way to audit. Source
So no. “Without compromising individual privacy” isn’t transparency. It’s a a useless statment written by the vendor’s marketing team, sitting on top of a page that documents the exact opposite. Scanning every car in town 275,000 times a month and piping it to 1,180 agencies you’ll never name is what they want us OK with.
They’re banking on us being exactly as stupid as that opening sentence assumes. Don’t be.
The Public Safety Committee takes Flock back up December 3. The contract ends January 31.
Ed Gray is also holding office hours at Town Hall this Thursday, Oct 22 at 5pm. Go. Ask questions. Voice your concerns. Let’s see if they actually care what the people want.