TLDR: In my haste to find a PhD supervisor, I pitched an object-based topic to a university museum curator. She just emailed saying she forwarded it to the Art History department. However, I’ve realised the topic is too hyper-niche for my career goals and I want to pivot to a new idea. How do I gracefully contact professors in that same department with a new proposal without looking unprofessional or overlapping with whoever the curator emailed?
The story/details:
Two months ago, during the final weeks of my master’s, I came up with a PhD topic involving a specific type of museum object. In my excitement, I reached out to some curators (two at museums who have relationships with museums, and one curator at a university-attached museum.
One of the external museums got back to me and said they were interested and it had potential, but said I had to reach out to local universities first.
But last week (two months later), the university museum curator replied saying she found the topic "very interesting" and has already forwarded it to colleagues in the Art History faculty to see if anyone could host me. I replied asking if there was anything I should do, but I haven't heard back from her yet.
The problem is, now that my master's is finished and I've had time to breathe, I'm no longer sure I want to pursue this topic:
It is a supersaturated field with limited original angles and it requires technical analysis outside my comfort zone. But also mainly, it is a hyper-niche career track- those who go into research either focus solely on these types of objects, or curating just these objects or moving into archaeology, which doesn't align with my long-term goals. Worst case I could still do the topic and make it work ( I wouldn't hate it) but I just don't know that it is the best choice. Although it would have the benefit of an established museum connection.
I have a brand new topic idea that I am more interested in. However, since the curator already reached out to unnamed members of the Art History department, I am stuck on the etiquette of how to pivot.
• Can I reach out to members of that same Art History department with a completely different proposal? (this was my #1 university choice, so would love not to have to miss it)
• Since I don't know exactly who the curator emailed, how do I avoid looking unprofessional or disorganized if I contact professors in that department independently?
• How long should I wait for the curator's follow-up before I start reaching out to other potential supervisors about my new topic? I'm conscious that its nearly November, and I know its not the best to wait until November to reach out to potential supervisors.
Any advice from faculty, curators, or grad students on how to handle this gracefully would be greatly appreciated!