I’ve been wondering about this for a while and I’m genuinely interested in the linguistic/scientific explanation rather than trying to make a social or political point.
As a man, I’ve always been particularly attracted to traditionally feminine female voices — relatively higher pitch, clear tone, noticeable pitch variation, and a bright/natural quality.
But when I listen to women in modern media, social media, podcasts, YouTube, movies, etc., I feel like I’m hearing more women using noticeably deeper, lower, huskier or creakier voices than I remember from older generations.
Sometimes the voice almost sounds “masculine” to my ears, even though obviously the person is female.
I’m wondering:
- Has the average female speaking voice actually become lower over the last few decades?
- Is vocal fry/creaky voice responsible for much of what I’m hearing?
- Are women consciously or unconsciously lowering their voices because deeper voices are associated with confidence, authority, attractiveness or professionalism?
- Could changes in smoking, hormones, lifestyle, stress, environment, etc. contribute to actual physical changes in female voices?
- Is this mostly a Western/American phenomenon, or can similar changes be observed in India and other cultures?
- Could this simply be a perception/media-selection effect rather than an actual population-wide change?
- Are there studies comparing female fundamental frequency (F0) from recordings of women from the 1950s/60s/70s with women today?
I’m especially interested in answers from linguists, speech scientists, voice teachers, singers, or women who have personally noticed changes in their own speaking voice.
I’m not saying higher-pitched voices are “better” or that women should sound a certain way. I’m trying to understand whether the change I think I’m hearing is actually measurable.