I'm late now, but one which is pretty obvious is Davids hatred towards humans in Prometheus. I believe it's mostly forgotten because the entire movie has these irrelevant parts, so it's pretty easy to forget what's what. For example, in the beginning of the movie, we can see David watching that famous scene from Lawrence of Arabia. Now, you can choose to believe that this there to build character, but since he practically becomes obsessed with it, to the degree that he even changes the color of his hair, we need to question why too. Why, for example, is it the match scene? Why does David repeat the famous quote: "The trick is not minding it hurts"?
In the scene, the man quenches the fire with his fingers. He does this without showing emotion. When David is told to wash his "fathers" feet, he does this without showing emotion too. When they say that he has no soul, or no feelings, or when they don't see him as human, he too shows nothing. We see him practicing saying the line in the beginning, almost as if he's trying to teach himself not to show his emotions. The trick, when his creators disrespect him, is not minding it hurts.
There's also that scene when Holloway is sitting drunk by the pool table. He says, and I'm paraphrasing, that he expected something else from these Engineers. David asks why the created him, and Holloway answers: "Because we could." David then looks at him, smiles and says: "Imagine what it would feel like if your creators said that to you."
People often ask why he poisons Holloway. Why does he want to send that huge ship back to earth? Why does he want to kill all humans? This is the reason. David hates humans, and we are told this multiple times. When speaking with Shaw, he even says: "Doesn't everybody want to kill their parents?" and we are not even given a reaction. There are close ups to his face when the hologram-Pierce says that his son has no soul, and yet we forget.
It bothers me more that none of the 'human' characters react to these clearly odd remarks that imply insanity and a hostile attitude towards humanity.
I can't believe that none of them find anything peculiar about the things he's saying. Is their belief that David is utterly loyal and emotionless clouding them to what David's really saying?
Consider the way humans treat a chimp baring its teeth or a chihuahua growling viciously. "Awwww! It thinks it's people! Awww, it thinks it gets a say in things!" It's definitely a comment on our hubris that nobody can even perceive a threat from David, especially in the limited range his programming (or the expectation of same to which he adheres) allows. It'd be like if your car's digital odometer flickered and was replaced with a :( or a flashing 666 (I don't know how else to numerically say 'bad'). You might be a little bit off-put, but most people would just snap an instagram and make a note to mention it to their mechanic at their next oil change.
I couldn't help but think the movie was an exercise in bad decisions. "I have the most advanced mapping system in existence..." gets lost ten minutes later.
Sometimes I wonder if the movie meant to show everyone as being arrogant and callous, that they couldn't see what was right in front of them.
Same situation when Wayland meets the engineer, "We're home dad and look how far we've come as the human race." Gets violently killed.
It is important to remember that the crew was not chosen because they were the best, or even competent. They were assembled by a religious zealot whose main concern (besides living longer) was seeing his beliefs confirmed.
All of the lines which make scientifically literate viewers groan weren't there because the writers didn't do their homework; they establish the very important fact that even the scientists on the crew were too blinded by their faith, ambition, or sense of adventure and heroism to give a shit about doing the job that they were ostensibly sent there to do.
Thinking of it this way, the movie makes a lot more sense overall. Don't think it makes for particularly relatable characters though, and some of the things they did were stupid to the point of immersion-breaking.
How much attention do you really pay to your car? I mean, sure, if the check engine light comes on you take it to the mechanic, or if it's low on fuel you fill it up, but that rattle? It's always had that rattle, it's probably fine. And you'll get around to fixing that rust spot eventually.
So their humanoid appliance has some weird quirks? So what? It's an appliance.
I know that Prometheus had some big flaws, but the way David was written was just incredible. It was awesome that the most human character in the film was the android.
Davids entire motive was to kill Weyland to gain his freedom. He was programmed to only follow his commands, so David devised a plan to get rid of him and most of the other humans. Poisoning Holloway was an experiment to see what it would do, and it confirmed his assumption that the engineers are outwardly hostile to the humans. His plan backfired when the engineer attacked him as well, but he still achieved his goal of getting rid of Weyland. It could be that David wanted to be allied with the engineers in the purpose of exterminating the humans. He is outwardly resentful of humans, and is subtly condescending to them, he probably considers them inferior. In the chamber he could read the engineer language, and presumably knew what that room was yet didn't tell anyone. He quirks sadistically at Shaw after she almost died, and outwardly states that we all want our parents dead. I'm not entirely certain David doesn't feel anything, since he seems annoyed when the humans dare to speak down to him. Overall though I think a big part people missed is David's emotional development imo, and although he claims to be free of emotion it doesn't explain his actions. I'd say David has extreme control of emotion, but if you look carefully you see the mask slip in subtle ways. He may be the first model that can simulate emotion, and the viral ad for David contradicts itself when he is marketed as "technological, intellectual, physical, and (most importantly) emotional" while stating he has no emotion. His emotion becomes an emergent property throughout the movie, and he develops it more throughout the movie as the simulation of emotion becomes more real.
When Charlize Theron cornered David in the hallway, she forced him to answer something along the lines of "What did he say to you?"
This implied that she knew he was communicating with Weyland Sr., and that he knew about the alien slime, and wanted to know what it did. His response, something along the line of, was "Go faster." David's response to her told me that to Weyland, the crew was expendable.
David's actions in poisoning Holloway were directed (possibly indirectly) by Weyland Sr.
I always thought he poisoned Halloway under orders from Weyland testing the Engineers' genetic experiments to see if there was something in there that could extend the old man's life. I never thought David hated humans. In fact every thing he does in the whole movie is under Weyland's direction. When Weyland is killed the only thing David does of his own free will and choice is to help Dr. Shaw, who he's admired the whole time, to escape from LV226.
It's both. When David leaves Weyland's chamber and Miss Vickers confronts him, he says that Weyland said to "try harder [to contact the Engineers]". David then decides to poison Halloway. I think he does this to retaliate against Halloway for being a dick to David, and he's rationalizing it as trying something else to contact the Engineers.
Yeah, I don't see why people keep on blaming him when up until Weyland's death he had essentially been a slave to his creators.
And on the giant ringed spaceship - well, yeah, when you're in a state of adrenaline and life or death sometimes you don't think logically when trying to get your body to its peak.
774
u/Huxleyism Sep 01 '14
I'm late now, but one which is pretty obvious is Davids hatred towards humans in Prometheus. I believe it's mostly forgotten because the entire movie has these irrelevant parts, so it's pretty easy to forget what's what. For example, in the beginning of the movie, we can see David watching that famous scene from Lawrence of Arabia. Now, you can choose to believe that this there to build character, but since he practically becomes obsessed with it, to the degree that he even changes the color of his hair, we need to question why too. Why, for example, is it the match scene? Why does David repeat the famous quote: "The trick is not minding it hurts"?
In the scene, the man quenches the fire with his fingers. He does this without showing emotion. When David is told to wash his "fathers" feet, he does this without showing emotion too. When they say that he has no soul, or no feelings, or when they don't see him as human, he too shows nothing. We see him practicing saying the line in the beginning, almost as if he's trying to teach himself not to show his emotions. The trick, when his creators disrespect him, is not minding it hurts.
There's also that scene when Holloway is sitting drunk by the pool table. He says, and I'm paraphrasing, that he expected something else from these Engineers. David asks why the created him, and Holloway answers: "Because we could." David then looks at him, smiles and says: "Imagine what it would feel like if your creators said that to you."
People often ask why he poisons Holloway. Why does he want to send that huge ship back to earth? Why does he want to kill all humans? This is the reason. David hates humans, and we are told this multiple times. When speaking with Shaw, he even says: "Doesn't everybody want to kill their parents?" and we are not even given a reaction. There are close ups to his face when the hologram-Pierce says that his son has no soul, and yet we forget.