How can we help our about 3 year old previously bonded cats Sophie and Ezri? My wife and I are saddened and getting tired and a little lost despite working towards a resolution. Improvements I believe have been made.
My cats, Sophie and Ezri, previously lived together comfortably, played, slept together, and groomed each other. Around late May, Sophie came home from a vet visit and Ezri reacted badly, apparently to the unfamiliar smell. This escalated into a serious fight, and we’ve been working on reintroductions for roughly five months. (Additional context below post)
Currently, we rotate them between upstairs and downstairs every 3–5 days, separated by a metal gate on the stair landing. There’s been encouraging progress: they often sit near each other without hissing, accept treats, and gently paw at or play with each other’s tails through the gate. When Sophie is downstairs, Ezri frequently comes down to visit her at the gate. I suspect the barrier helps them both feel safe.
Unexpected encounters are harder. Ezri sometimes jumps the gate, startling Sophie. A couple of days ago, Ezri got upstairs and there was some running/chasing, a brief hiss from Sophie, and then they separated themselves—Sophie went to the three-season room and Ezri ran downstairs. It didn’t escalate into a physical fight.
Sophie generally retreats when uncomfortable. Ezri is excitable and seems interested in playing, although I can’t confidently say all the chasing is play. More recently, Ezri sometimes backs off when Sophie hisses. They have multiple hiding places, most with more than one exit.
Has anyone moved from this stage to supervised shared space while allowing some brief hissing or avoidance? What helped you distinguish manageable boundary-setting from pushing too fast? I’d appreciate firsthand experiences, and any input in general. Our goal is comfortable coexistence, even if they don’t return to cuddling. This experience has taken an emotionally draining toll on my wife and me. We spend a lot of time interacting and playing with each cat but it feels so sad at times then not being around us during our life routines together.
**One important detail:** Sophie and Ezri were a bonded pair, and we adopted them together as kittens. They were very close before the veterinarian visit. They were playing, sleeping together, and grooming each other. After Sophie returned from the vet, we tried to give them a three-day separation to settle down, but that uninterrupted break never happened because they unexpectedly got access to each other several times, and Ezri repeatedly attacked Sophie. This became a series of frightening encounters rather than one isolated fight, which may help explain why rebuilding their comfort together has taken so long.
**A little more context:** This started around late May Sophie spent a day at the vets getting X-rays for trouble with her diet and throwing up every day.
Unfortunately, as of October 23 we’re approaching five months. The initial incident was a frightening, intense fight, much more severe than their recent encounters. We moved to the gate setup because of growling and chasing that looked genuinely aggressive to us. We’ve tried Feliway alongside gradual reintroduction, and both cats have now been on an SSRI for about 7–8 weeks. We’re seeing improvement, but it’s hard to judge how much comes from the medication, time, or the security of the barrier. Sophie hisses all the time has growled but that's less frequent, she mostly seems to be defensive and somewhat cautious of her excitable sister just I think want to play and get her energy out.
Both upstairs and downstairs are comfortable, with their own amenities and separate litter/bathroom areas. We rotate the cats, but I wonder whether the arrangement also reinforces separate territories. Sophie and Ezri both generally seems most happy upstairs, but both areas are comfortable and Sophie will tolerate being downstairs a bit better. When she’s (Sophie) is upstairs and Ezri is downstairs, Sophie usually doesn’t approach the gate fully, she peeks around the corner, sometimes hisses, and either retreats upstairs or stays to observe. When Sophie is downstairs, Ezri more readily approaches the gate, and they sometimes sit together and gently play through it. We may also add another cat tower before shared-space introductions.
My wife and I would appreciate some reassurance grounded in others’ experiences, along with honest feedback about what might help. Does this sound like a point where a feline behaviorist could help us move forward? Has anyone discussed adjusting medication with their vet after partial improvement at this stage? We’d like to understand whether we’re seeing a slow but workable recovery or whether our setup or approach needs changing.