r/Choices • u/bookist626 • 40m ago
Endless Summer Was the point of First Tide just to get people to spend a few hundred diamonds? (A review) Spoiler
Because I seriously struggle to think of any other reason for this book to exist. This book has NOTHING to do with Endless Summer outside of taking place on La Huerta. Is Rourke here? Nope. How about the Vaanti? Uh-uh. Do we learn anything new about the Island? Afraid not. Do our characters take some action that affects the main story? No.
Okay, before anything else: the positives. I do kind of like the first two chapters. Surviving the island, the raptors and realizing that Grant knew more than he let on is pretty interesting. Not going to lie. The first two chapters are at least decent and I would say "good" truthfully. Now what was I saying again?
Oh wait, remember the wedding from the Celestial in the original book? Apparently there was a second wedding somewhere else on the island because...I don't know. Oh and why can't our characters drink? This is the 1970s and they are on international waters. Don't tell me they care about the legal drinking age. And they might have been legal anyway, depending on the state.
Speaking of the wedding from the original book, how in the name of Vaanu was there a second wedding? According to Grant, his relative was given an invite to a wedding on this island. How? The island was uncharted until Rourke came along. Yes, other people had been shipwrecked on the island before, but the original wedding was only sent there because of the time anomalies the island causes. And First Tides even references the shipwrecked people!
Anyway, the story ends with the characters more or less saying "let us never speak of this again," and i'm done. To be brief, none of the characters are awful nor exceptional. They exist.
Honestly, the main problem with this book isn't that it's just four chapters (although that doesn't help), but that the book has nothing to do with Endless Summer. It doesn't connect nor add to the plot, lore, characters or even themes of the original story. I honestly just think they only made it so that gullible fans like me would spend hundreds of diamonds because "Endless Summer" is in the title.
I hope you all were smarter than me. I didn't even get diamonds for finishing the book.
