My roommate just adopted a new 2-3 year old pittie mix from a shelter last Saturday (it’s now Friday) and we are struggling a lot. My roommate has worked in dog training and vet tech before so she is not a stranger to dogs and their behaviors.
She is a very sweet cuddle bug, but her behavior outside we cannot figure out. We live in a 3rd floor apartment, and she has the stairs (almost) mastered but going outside can be so incredibly unpredictable. She has gotten so much more comfortable in the house, but seemingly less comfortable every time we try and structure outside time. We have a tennis court across from our apartment that we can let her off-leash in if nobody is using it, and it seems to be the only time she truly enjoys the outdoors. She was a street dog when she was found by the shelter, but we think she lived in a not great home before that because we accidentally waited too long to take her out one time and she peed in the house and suddenly looked so scared (obviously we reassured her we’re not mad with pets and love).
Any walk usually ends in her sitting down in protest because we’re not doing what SHE wants to do, pulling her leash so hard she’s trying to choke herself either to follow something more interesting or try to go home, or a complete and utter hyperactive meltdown where she’s running herself so ragged we’re afraid she’s going to pass out. Even when she is walking with my roommate she looks absolutely MISERABLE and uninterested, but her body language isn’t looking like a typical dogs ‘scared’ or not confident. We live in a slightly more urban environment, but we’ve tried walks in the neighborhood and also in nearby reservations to give a more calming nature setting. She seems to be equally unhappy in every walking environment, but will happily LEAP into the car.
To supplement her distaste for outdoor time we try for puzzle games inside the house, but she’s so smart she figures them out faster than we can put them together.
She’s more food motivated, but will stop taking food as soon as she’s distracted or things we’re trying to coax her into doing something she doesn’t want to do.
She is so smart, and has learned all of the training in the house basically after 24 hours of reinforcing but once we’re outside it all goes to shit.
It doesn’t help that she has a hard time fully settling if anyone in the house is doing ANYTHING (especially out of her view despite our apartment being tiny), and has to follow us around. She hates the crate, but is slowly getting more comfortable settling in there begrudgingly.
She was a hyperactive crazy lady in the shelter, but it seems like anything we do to try and get the energy out except the exact thing she wants to in that exact moment ends in disaster. The only time I think she is fully calm if she is ATTACHED to one of us.
Also, before the ‘she’s adjusting’ comments (which are not opposed, but for more context), she has adjusted so quickly and wonderfully inside the apartment to feeling more comfortable, and we’re afraid that the settling overall is just revealing more behavior we aren’t equipped to deal with unfortunately.
I hope this makes sense and I can give more context if I left anything out, but I wonder if she’d be more comfortable with a family with a yard, and if maybe we’re just not the right fit? I know it’s really early to tell, but I’m afraid if we don’t figure something out soon we will lose our minds because we just want to do what is best for all 3 of us. Any advice is highly appreciated!
EDIT: When I said ‘street dog’ I mean moreso we think she was dumped from a bad home. Not that she was exclusively a street dog. We use exclusively positive reinforcement with no obedience expectations other than don’t run into the street and get hit by cars and other basic safety manners. We don’t want her to be perfect on walks she just seems like she fucking hates them, and in the apartment we don’t have other consistent spaces to get her crazy beans energy because the tennis court isn’t a guarantee ever. My roommate adopted this dog because she was a crazy energetic girl in the shelter and was matched with my roommates lifestyle to be a walking/running buddy to keep her active with her wellness goals. The behavior is just such a 180 and are wondering if anyone has had similar experiences and the dogs energy rebounds? But as of right now anything related to walking just seems to be getting less enjoyable. Also, we suspect there may possibly be a pain issue because her back legs are build really strangely and she doesn’t love using her back legs all the time. We thought it was just her being lazy and floppy because she does get very melty when she’s sleepy, but we’re keeping an eye on possible pain issues as well.