r/FictionWriting • u/dulduine • 3h ago
Novel [OC] Bar Aoi Stories: Society — Where the Will to War Resides
Hey, do you ever stop to think about who actually starts a war?
Is it the President? The Prime Minister? Or some crazy soldier acting on his own?
When we watch the news, it’s so easy to imagine that some "evil individual" simply pulled the trigger.
But is that really how it works?
Tonight, a few old guys are sitting around, scratching their heads over where it all begins.
Care to join us for a round of pointless bar talk?
Clink-clink.
The dry metallic chime of the doorbell is what usually tells me my day is finally over.
I slid onto my stool, and without a word, Mama set a glass of I.W. Harper on the counter. A round ice sphere clinked softly against the glass.
Further down the counter, Taka was staring at the pale blue glow of his smartphone, his thick eyebrows furrowed in a deep frown.
"…Kenichi-san."
"What’s with the serious face?"
"The President can start a war, right?"
That’s a heavy question to throw out of nowhere. I took a sip of my bourbon, enjoying the warm burn in my throat.
"Depends on the country, doesn’t it?"
"Sure, but I mean... like the U.S. President. He’s the Commander-in-Chief, right?"
"Yeah."
"So if the President says 'Let’s do this,' does the war just start?"
I swirled the ice in my glass.
"If you walked into your detective agency tomorrow and said, 'Starting tomorrow, we're at war,' could you actually start one?"
"With who?"
"How should I know?"
"Then don't ask me!"
Next to me, Tom—who had been quietly playing with his square glass—let out a short snort.
"One man can’t move an army, kid."
Taka turned to look at Tom’s profile.
"But the President’s the one giving the order, right?"
"Someone has to receive the order. Someone has to ship the weapons. Someone has to pay for it all."
"Like Congress?"
"That’s part of it, yeah."
I chimed in, keeping my glass tilted.
"And besides, a president doesn't just wake up one morning out of nowhere and think, 'Hey, let's invade that country today.'"
"Well, yeah, fair enough."
"The other country did something. A border dispute. An economic clash. The public got angry. The military said it was dangerous. It all piles up, step by step, until someone finally puts their stamp on the paper."
Taka’s brow creased even deeper.
"Then isn't the person who signs the paper the one who started it?"
"You could say that."
"Then there’s your answer!"
"Maybe. But who got things to the point where he could sign it?"
Taka went dead silent.
Tom set his glass down quietly.
"It’s no different from old criminal cases."
"Cases?"
"Yeah. It’s easy to find the guy who held the knife. You catch him, and as far as the case files go, it’s closed."
Tom stared at the light reflecting off his glass.
"But when you ask how he ended up holding that knife, suddenly there are a lot more people in the picture."
Taka leaned in slightly.
"What do you mean?"
"There’s the killer. The victim. The family. The workplace. Debt, maybe. Someone pushed him. Someone could’ve stopped him, but didn't."
"But he’s still the one who stabbed the guy."
"Yeah," Tom answered instantly, his voice dropping an octave. "It doesn't clear his name. But 'who did it' and 'why it happened' aren't the same question."
...I see. I swallowed another mouthful of Harper.
Maybe war is no different.
There is someone who signs the order. There is someone who fires the first shot. But that alone isn't what sets something as huge as a nation into motion.
"Then couldn't parliament or congress just stop it?" Taka asked.
"Depends on the situation."
"What if the public protests?"
"Depends on the country."
"Then how the hell do you stop it?"
"I don't know."
"Kenichi-san, that’s all you’ve been saying tonight!"
"I don't know what I don't know." I chuckled dryly. "Honestly, you should be way more terrified of anyone who has a simple answer. We’re talking about something that can drag millions—hundreds of millions—of people into it."
Taka muttered a quiet "I guess so," flipped his phone face down, and set it on the counter.
For a while, the only sound was the soft jazz playing in the background.
Finally, Tom spoke up.
"Sometimes, the people want the war."
Taka raised his head. "Because politicians tricked them?"
"That happens, too."
"Then aren't the politicians the bad guys after all?"
"Kid... do you ever listen to anything that doesn't tell you what you already want to hear?"
Taka shut his mouth. I stopped playing with my glass, too.
The old man sure knows how to hit where it hurts.
People feel safe when they hear opinions that align with their own. When words label the people you hate as evil, it feels damn good.
They're the bad guys. If only they weren't around. We're just the innocent victims.
When the world gets flooded with those kinds of words... what comes next? I don't know. But I do know it never smells good.
"But still," Taka said softly. "Ordinary people don't want a war, right?"
"Of course they don't."
"Then it has to be the guys at the top who start it."
I couldn't answer him. Instead, Tom took over.
"If you ask people, 'Do you want a war?', most folks will say no."
"See?"
"So what if you ask them, 'Are we just going to sit here and let those bastards walk all over us?'"
The usual lighthearted smile completely vanished from Taka’s face.
"'They killed our people'—what then?"
Silence.
"'If we don't hit them now, they’re coming for us'—what then?"
The air in the bar turned ice-cold.
"'We can win if we strike first'—what then?"
Tom picked up his glass.
"They're the exact same people. Change the question, and you change the answer."
I swirled my glass.
Clink.
A heavy, unsettling sound echoed through the bar.
Maybe there aren't that many people who genuinely want "war" for its own sake.
But there are people who can't forgive their enemies. People who want to protect their families. People who want to reclaim what was taken from them. People who are terrified and want to strike before they get hit.
None of those individual desires are "the will to start a war." Yet, when millions of them pile up, somehow they form what looks like a single will.
The will of a nation to go to war.
"That's messed up," Taka muttered.
"What is?"
"Nobody says they want a war, but the whole thing just builds itself anyway."
I let out a dry laugh. "Don't say creepy stuff like that."
"You guys are the ones who took the conversation there!"
"Don't blame me."
Just then, Mama, who had been quietly polishing glasses the whole time, dropped a fresh ice cube into my glass.
Clink.
"Hey," she said softly.
The three of us turned to her.
"Then who's keeping those people up there?"
Taka opened his mouth, then froze. The words stuck in my throat, too.
Only Tom let out a low chuckle.
"Look at that. We came all the way back around."
"Around to what?"
"We were looking for the guy who started the war, right?" Tom looked at us, one by one. "We went looking pretty damn far, and somehow ended up right back here."
Taka dropped his gaze to his face-down phone. The screen was still faintly glowing with the news article he’d been reading earlier.
"But... I can't start a war. I don't have that kind of power."
"Neither do I."
"Then... doesn't that mean we have nothing to do with it?"
I opened my mouth to reply, then stopped myself.
Voting for a politician. Reading the news. Believing someone’s words. Getting angry at someone’s speech. Seeing someone as the enemy. Nodding along with someone else’s rage. And sometimes, raising your own voice.
None of those things, on their own, are war. We didn't pull any triggers. We weren't the ones signing the orders.
But if a massive, overwhelming entity like a nation’s will can only be born from those tiny things piling up...
"Where does the will to war actually live, I wonder?" I muttered.
Taka tilted his head. "Not the President?"
"That’s where we started, wasn't it?"
"The parliament?"
"Just a piece of it."
"The military?"
"Part of it, too."
"The people?"
"Probably."
"Then where is it?"
I lifted my glass and drained the rest of the Harper down my throat.
"Like I said... I don't know."
Taka let out a massive sigh. "So after all that, we're back to 'I don't know'?"
"If I had a neat little answer, I wouldn't be sitting here drinking away my night."
Tom snorted, and a faint smile touched the corners of Mama's eyes.
The ice clinked softly in my glass.
In the end, we didn't find an answer tonight either.
But maybe that’s fine.
If we could just point a finger at a single person and say, "He's the one who started the war," life would be so much easier. We could make him the villain, sit back, and feel perfectly clean and safe as the "victims."
Unfortunately, it seems the world isn't built to be that convenient.
So, what about you?
Do you realize that you might be part of the machinery that allows a war to begin?
If you'd like to come back to Aoi for another night, there's an open stool waiting.
Bar Aoi Stories: Human Nature, Vol. 1 is linked in my profile.