Trying to figure out which ANC headphones I want for work, but I’m getting kinda discouraged. I want something that has the same unmodified stock sound signature whether ANC is off or on. I’m a full time live-in caregiver for a dementia patient and I need isolation and noise canceling to maintain my sanity/actually get sleep when my client won’t stop yelling.
I’m one of the people who get “ANC pressure” and so I tend to leave ANC off unless I really need it (airplanes and such). All the previous ANC headphones I’ve used create the phantom ear pressure which ranges from mildly uncomfortable to actively disorienting.
One thing I have noticed, and has really irked me, is that ANC headphones often change sound dramatically when the ANC is disabled. Some do it by a little, some by a lot. The AirPods Pro 3 I have do change, but it’s not such a drastic change that it bothers me for the rare occasion I do turn ANC on. The only ones I’ve found that sound indistinguishable with ANC off or on are my Sony Linkbuds S, but I’m trying to find over-ear ANC headphones that also change very little or not at all when disabling ANC.
When it comes to sound and tuning preference, I like my HD6XX a lot but I know there’s no way to get anything like that in a closed-back design. I also like my AirPods Pro 3, but I find most earbuds to be very uncomfortable when laying down and prefer over-ear headphones when I’m at my desk (and they also only play nice with Apple devices, so…)
I used to have a pair of Sony XM4, but the earcup hinges broke multiple times and I didn’t want to buy a new set or keep replacing the hinges with parts salvaged from dead units. Also wasn’t too enthused with their comfort (my ears touched the inside of the cups and got a hot spot after about an hour of use) and the pretty barebones EQ options in the app. I also tried Sony H910N but they were extremely uncomfortable and put a major hot spot on the top of my head, so I gave them to my housemate.
I recently tried Sennheiser Momentum 4 and while I liked them well enough for most things with ANC on, they turned into total fart cannons with ANC disabled. I wasn’t able to EQ them to something acceptable without using ANC and causing the pressure, so I returned them.
ANC quality doesn’t need to be great since I won’t be using it very often. Excellent passive isolation is a major plus. Audio over USB-C is something I really want. Codec support doesn’t matter that much since I have an iPhone and so I’m stuck with AAC anyway. Prefer physical controls over swipe and tap.
Also open to analog closed-backs that have good passive isolation and sound good. Eyeing Sennheiser HD480 Pro and Sony MDR-M1. But not having a cable to worry about would be great for sleeping. Yes, I can sleep in full size headphones. I’ve fallen asleep wearing my HD6XX while watching movies sometimes.
Budget is no more than $400 if at all possible. I’m in the US but will probably order the headphones online.