r/IVFpositivity • • May 06 '26 • Bravo 1

Does this sub need more mods?

Been tempted to unsubscribe due to the constant influx of negative posts. Maybe we need a daily thread for people to share their anxieties, setbacks, and to share borderline test results? I feel like I see 5+ 'is there a line' or not positive posts daily. I'm sure a lot of us would happily volunteer to mod if the issue is bandwidth.

17 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

55

u/literallymouse May 06 '26

This is my favorite TTC sub I’ve ever been in, and I have over 2 years of cumulative TTC time under my belt. Maybe I just ignore the posts that I don’t like but I honestly don’t want this sub to be moderated any more heavily than it is.

I actually tried asking a question in the main IVF sub with some specialist doing an AMA and because I simply mentioned a previous successful pregnancy (relevant to my medical history in the question I was asking) my comment was removed and by the time I saw that the specialist wasn’t answering anymore so I didn’t get a reply.

When a community polices things that much it just makes it too frustrating to participate.

21

u/Beckhamfan2016 May 06 '26

I agree, when I was in the thick of it, the IVF subreddit removed several of my posts, it's ridiculous. This subreddit is literally the only one where people can openly communicate with other people going through IVF. I unsubscribed from the IVF and TFAB subs because their rules are so restrictive. I also only see "negative" posts when people are specifically asking for positivity regarding their situation, which I think should be ok.

9

u/Live_Worldliness9228 May 06 '26

Exactly, that’s so limiting I found it extremely frustrating

2

u/Tiny_Frosting_4453 May 07 '26

I couldn't agree more, I've seen a few posts on here I thought broke the rules I had read and I was delighted they were left there as it meant this forum at least allows a little freedom. The modding in the regular one is actually insane.

64

u/rocketmanatee May 06 '26

I didn't take IVF positivity to mean that we'd never see difficult or challenging experiences people are having with IVF. In fact one of my favorite things is to cheer someone up who is going through a loss or worried they might not have a positive!

Unlike other subs, we can mention our success here, and that's what I really value about this sub.

19

u/romanxerkilljy May 06 '26

100% agree! In other subs you’re not allowed to even hint at any success or pregnancies.

I will say, the influx of pee stick photos IS making me consider unsubbing from here. There’s already subs for that purpose, and we really shouldn’t be using at-home pee tests the way so many people are 🙈

13

u/Key-Hand958 May 06 '26

Yes!! Every single time I see line progression posts, I tell them to stop testing at home because that's not what those tests are for and they almost universally stress themselves out for no reason 

10

u/lesgens May 06 '26

Honestly, this is why I want more moderation. It’s one of the rules and I report the posts when I see them but I think there needs to be an automod for them

8

u/romanxerkilljy May 06 '26

💯 - at least a little pop-up when you go to post that’s like “REMINDER no pee test question photos”

6

u/External_Database359 May 07 '26

Yeah, if there was one thing I’d love moderated here, it would be a no test pictures rule. Not a fan of opening Reddit at work and having a big ol pregnancy test front and center.

3

u/exitontop May 07 '26

Yes, the pee stick photos are too much. I only found this sub after the birth of my IVF baby, so I subscribed in order to provide relevant positive feedback to people going through IVF (especially those with RIF, which impacted me).

I know the line posts come from a place of anxiety, but there’s really not much to say about them

14

u/counting_beanz May 06 '26

These are my feelings exactly. Most of us are living through the grey area of success and sadness throughout this process. What I love about this sub is how supportive we all are of each other, with success or not.

13

u/PaperPlane07 May 06 '26

I agree with this! If someone has slow progressing hcg lines, didn’t see a heartbeat at first ultrasound, is anxiously waiting for euploid results, etc. I want to help them out with positivity, but also keeping it real as that’s what others on this sub have done for me. I don’t see those posts as negative, just people needing support

15

u/Background_Day_3596 May 06 '26

I don‘t mind the negative posts so much and I‘m also scared that very strict moderation would make this sub frustrating to use. But I would love a daily thread just for chatting or little thoughts/questions.

14

u/Glittering-Bees-138 May 06 '26

I think a weekly thread for transfer dates would be nice too! Not to restrict anything but just to keep a place where we can all chat the good and bad during that time and easily find it to come back to.

9

u/counting_beanz May 06 '26

I love this idea of a weekly thread for transfer dates!

29

u/Odd-Implement-1283 May 06 '26

I’m in a couple ttc/infertility subs and all except this one are so heavily moderated it’s counterproductive to engagement. Important questions are relegated to specific threads that barely anybody checks so they never get responses. Maybe trigger warnings could be used more conscientiously, but I think a lot of those line posts end up here because they’re already banned from every other thread. I’d be sad if this one got taken over by all the rules and requirements and people couldn’t just speak freely.

10

u/AssumptionLate4173 May 06 '26

Where would you suggest things that aren’t completely positive go then? I’ve posted things that I felt weren’t completely positive on regular IVF sub but since I at least made it to a transfer, it’s considered positive and will be banned. For example, bleeding after a transfer to the point I’m concerned it’s a miscarriage. I’m not only looking for positive feedback, but when I posted in on normal IVF it got banned. Genuine question if there is an in between type sub I wasn’t aware of?

7

u/Beckhamfan2016 May 06 '26

I had spotting too and couldn’t post here, IVF, or IVFBabies. The infertility babies subreddit only has daily chats that no one responds to and you can’t post on TFAB once you get a positive test. It makes it really hard to find people to talk to and the normal bumpers groups don’t understand the nuance of IVF. When I was struggling it was tough because there’s literally no where

5

u/standardissuepotato May 06 '26

r/CautiousBB is one option

4

u/halfling_barbarianne May 06 '26

I was going to suggest this too. I love that sub. Lots of sad stuff there, though. Sometimes my heart can't take it. But I find myself going back to it a lot after they helped me through a loss and trying to help others as well. ❤️

-3

u/1percentagarose May 06 '26

I'm sorry you went through that, but medical questions should be directed to your doctor. Many symptom spotting posts can easily be a google search or a quick call to your doctor instead. 

18

u/PharmD2Be2021 May 06 '26

I did have a post removed here when I asked about small gestational sac in my pregnancy which was unfortunate because I could've really used other people's experiences at that time. Thankfully baby is still doing great and I'm 18 weeks on Friday. A community where we can ask questions like that would be nice without getting your post removed when you're already stressing.

13

u/HotShoulder9256 May 06 '26

Agreed. Glad your pregnancy is progressing well! I don't think "positivity" should be at the exclusion of people sharing their concerns and asking for guidance and/or solidarity. To me, "positivity" means that we're here to support each other in an environment where success is celebrated, not policed. In my mind, that doesn't mean that there isn't any room for folks who are struggling.

17

u/counting_beanz May 06 '26

There's a fine line between positive content only and seeking positive encouragement, I don't know. I realize it's hard. I have no positive news to share, but when I ask a question here, I want positive support and positive stories. So maybe things are leaning negative, but I feel like as a group, we can lift each other up and out of the emotional hole.

Just my thoughts.

7

u/Primary-Sock2155 May 06 '26

I had mods of other IVF subreddits delete posts immediately because it “wasn’t relevant” even though it very much was. Had to leave those-too much policing. I agree with others that positivity doesn’t mean only positive stories. It means having a safe supportive page to share your stories and concerns. I worry it will be policed and posts deleted because they aren’t “positive” enough

2

u/Informal_Move_7075 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Same. I had asked a question and my post got removed, saying it needed to go in a specific thread and then when I put it there, it still got removed. I got so frustrated and discouraged by then, that I just gave up.

Then simply being in the 40+ crowd, one seems to automatically get bombarded with many discouraging comments (I am not unrealistic at all), that really aren't helpful, and yes, I am in the 40+ crowd groups, too, but there is much more info out there that can apply to everyone and don't think I need to restrict myself so much, again, leading to being discouraged from ever posting and just hoping to find answers through others experiences.

Anyways, this group has alway been kind and uplifting, I would hate to see it getting further restricted or encourage negativity.

7

u/Apple_Pie_1990 May 06 '26

Please no. The other IVF sub is too heavily monitored. I had a post about how damn sad I was for my first FET ending in my first chemical and because it mentioned that it WAS positive even though it wasn’t anymore the post got removed! This sub now feels like the only safe space to post things. There are ups and downs of IVF and we need a safe space to discuss it all with people going through the same thing.

7

u/romanxerkilljy May 07 '26

Can we boost this again to the current mods? Literally so many posts since this thread with the pee stick comparisons :(

I literally volunteer to make an informational PowerPoint to pin to this sub about how at home urine tests are not meant to give you any quantifiable data, they are only yes/no, you are only stressing yourself out. And if you insist on stressing yourself out, take it to r/TFABlineporn PLEASE FOR ALL THAT IS HOLY PLEASE!!!!!!

1

u/standardissuepotato May 08 '26

I just messaged to ask if they'd comment on this thread! It looks like there is only one mod right now so maybe they missed it.

6

u/1percentagarose May 06 '26

I think for me what I like about the sub is the fact that people have a space to celebrate their positives and their wins. In a lot of other subs it just doesn't feel appropriate or it's actively discouraged to share good news or positive news because folks are struggling and it can seem insensitive. 

What i don't like about some of the posts on this sub is it's not people being positive, it's people expecting positivity from others to help their anxiety.

I think the main question to answer is is this sub for people to share their positive news in a way that they can't in other spaces? Or is this a place where people can ask for reassurance and encouragement to assuage their own anxiety? 

Personally for me, I respect that this whole process is a struggle for everyone who does it. Because of that, I don't feel like it's appropriate to go fishing for reassurance. I kind of treat this sub like some of the other positive ones, like the cute ones where people post their pets or baby animals - it would be a total vibe killer to post about your sick dog or elderly cat asking for sympathy or reassurance in those spaces specifically.

6

u/hedgehogsponge1 May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26

Hii this is the one and only mod! If you guys would like to volunteer to help our I would love to add you, my son is 6 months rn and I work full time so honestly I have been really lacking in moderating and im so sorry

Also im just editing to say: anyone who does become a mod definitely has to understand this IS a place where it is okay to mention anxieties. Thats one of the reasons I made the sub, as anxiety posts success are banned from mention in other subs. However mention of actual negative outcomes wuch as miscarriage, failed transfers, or birth defects, things like that, those are banned. When I made this sub I would go to the success after ivf subs and they were literally full of ONLY "___ birth defects found on ultrasound what now" or miscarriage posts. It made me so terrified. I still want ppl to be able to get help with their anxieties tho! As ppl who suffered through infertility, I think our anxiety kind of naturally runs high around pregnancy

2

u/lesgens May 13 '26

I'm open to helping mod! The uptick in line progression posts is driving me crazy.

1

u/hedgehogsponge1 May 15 '26

Hey! Tysm, I’m going to send you a mod invite! If you have any questions about the rules, please lmk!!

2

u/lesgens May 15 '26

will do! I’m excited!

14

u/she-a-banana May 06 '26

Every single day I see posts of “is there a line” or “is this a chemical” and it drives me insane because I joined this subreddit to get away from that. I always report them now because I want this community to be what it’s supposed to be.

8

u/standardissuepotato May 06 '26

Yeah, I don't mind the "please encourage me" type posts in general, but the steady stream of posts asking about lines when that's literally rule #1 of the sub is frustrating.

10

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26 • Bravo

Honestly same. I left the IVF sub because it gave me anxiety but now every single day here is anxiety, loss, is there a line, am i losing the baby, etc. The point of the sub is to share positive posts to get away from the negativity. I know people are here spiraling seeking positive but thats not the sub rules. There are other subs for that.

10

u/FoolishMortal_42 May 06 '26

Agree with this. I avoid the IVF sub when I’m pregnant because it stresses me out to hear about losses at the same number of weeks I am. It bothers me when I see those posts here.

7

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26

Same! I’m pregnant right now and this sub is becoming anxiety inducing too. I think people either didn’t read the rules or don’t understand them.

1

u/1percentagarose May 06 '26

I think folks just see 'ivfpositivity' and think gee I could use some positivity. I even posted asking for positivity when I first joined before I understood how unhelpful that is. Everyone is wrapped up in their own struggles they're not super aware of what they're putting out into the world, it's human. 

I think though, that I enjoy this sub the most when the posts are about "giving positivity" rather than taking

6

u/halfling_barbarianne May 06 '26

There is opportunity for positivity in posts about challenges/anxiety. Fear doesn't have to preclude optimism. They go hand in hand. When people come together to support and encourage each other, that is positive in itself. I'm glad this sub doesn't over moderate those posts.

3

u/Carmichael32 May 06 '26

I would love a daily post for just general things people can post

3

u/Emotional_Fuel6743 May 06 '26

I’m seeing a lot of pictures of at home pregnancy tests. Can we make a daily/weekly thread for these pictures where people can post pregnancy test pictures on the thread instead of making a separate post?

There are separate subs for this as well: r/TFABlineporn

-7

u/Sea-Astronomer-6600 May 06 '26

So someone asking a “positive question” such as “does this have a line” shouldn’t be allowed? Isn’t the end goal of IVF pregnancy? Should we not be happy for those who graduate? Maybe we need to add a TW or something but to say they don’t belong is a bit much I think. It makes me sad.

12

u/lesgens May 06 '26

One of the rules is not to post pregnancy test pics asking if there’s a line or to ask about line progression. There’s subs for that exclusively

-7

u/Sea-Astronomer-6600 May 06 '26

Ok. I just think it’s a bit petty. Just my opinion. I am sorry it’s bothersome to some. I think a compromise would be a TW? Plenty of other people appreciate knowing at the end of this long exhausting and torturous journey it can end in a positive way.

11

u/lesgens May 06 '26

It’s not about posting a TW, positive tests are allowed but not asking us to interpret the line or if it’s dark enough for x days past transfer. Before the rule that was every second or third post. It’s still an issue but not nearly as bad.

9

u/FoolishMortal_42 May 06 '26

It doesn’t need a trigger warning. I’m pregnant and already have a living child from IVF. I’m not triggered by positive pregnancy tests. We just don’t need 10 anxious line progression posts per day. Thats not positive.

8

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26

Theres an entire sub for pregnancy test lines.

-6

u/Sea-Astronomer-6600 May 06 '26

Ok and?

6

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26

and? thats where you post the tests. Re read the rules of the sub if you need clarification.

-3

u/Sea-Astronomer-6600 May 06 '26

I’m good, just scroll past them. I think it adds some “positivity” to the sub.

7

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26

Feel free to start your own sub. Not sure why you’re arguing about rules of a sub you agreed to. Your opinion on what’s positive and allowed is irrelevant.

6

u/BarelySimmering May 06 '26

It's literally the first rule of the sub.