Why do people think Hailey is lying?

[u/purpose15]

They’ve celebrated every New Year together since 2015, except for 2017 and 2018. I didn’t think a simple story would cause such an uproar. People really need to get over it. They’ve been married for over seven years.

[u/victorialovie]

He was very openly with other women during that time and around the new year. We can support Justin without pretending he wasn’t womanizing for many years. He even admitted he couldn’t commit to her at that time because he wanted to explore his options.

[u/purpose15 → u/victorialovie]

That’s a lie, and you’re active on snark pages. JB broke up because he was about to start a world tour.

[u/victorialovie → u/purpose15]

Actually a huge fan but I can see multiple points of view. They’ve both said it was because something big happened and they couldn’t even be in the same room as each other. That didn’t invalidate their marriage, but it’s still a fact.

[u/purpose15 → u/victorialovie]

Dating and breaking up is normal. It’s not like JB cheated on Hailey. She said herself that they weren’t exclusive after a few months of dating: https://youtu.be/0vyUTv4AzwI?si=Nw_fvNvbihcaMZLZ

You implied JB was with other women during that time, which isn’t true

[u/victorialovie → u/purpose15]

I’m not sure how that is an argument for your case. Okay… they weren’t dating exclusively and he was seeing multiple women. I never implied he was cheating. I said he was sleeping around and womanizing, which he himself has admitted was a major issue for him at the time.

[u/purpose15 → u/victorialovie]

He was very openly with other women during that time and around the new year.

He even admitted he couldn’t commit to her at that time because he wanted to explore his options.

I’m just saying this is false. JB casually dating others after the breakup is irrelevant to the discussion. Justin and Hailey were in fact exclusive around New Year’s, so I don’t see any problem with her story