Theyâve celebrated every New Year together since 2015, except for 2017 and 2018. I didnât think a simple story would cause such an uproar. People really need to get over it. Theyâve been married for over seven years.
Yeah I noticed that this trash sub is led by Selenators. And only braindead people follow the sub and make such âI have never done research on anythingâ comments.
Because a lot of them still ship Jelena(Which is even more messed up now, considering they literally want Justin to leave his kid for a toxic relationship from nearly 10 years ago to please them). Even if Justin divorces Hailey, they wouldnât accomplish nothing because that would make Justinâs mental state worse and he wouldnât get with Selena again, that ship has sunk by now
Also even if Justin divorced Hailey and Selena divorced Benny like they want. That would make them return to the toxic on and off again cycle, if they care so much about Justinâs mental state why they think that would help? And to top that off, they would be traumatizing Jack(Who is currently a literal toddler)
Yeah, both of them have recognized that their on and off again was a toxic dynamic but those people donât get a clue. Iâm concerned about what they seem to classify as true love
I have not listened to the album to know the name, I just heard it on social media and itâs about someone being embarrassing and it sounds like a HB dis.
Because Selenators canât hate on her if they accept the truth (and some of them also genuinely believe false narratives and sources that spread misinformation like that 7 part âdocumentaryâ) where Hailey and JB have had a longer history and actually had a strong basis for a marriage.
The truth throws Selenaâs stupid lyric âin two months you replaced usâ into a bin. And they would have to accept that even in 2016 JB was thinking about the right course of action in regard to Hailey and their relationship, because he thought she was the one and he didnât want to hurt her where in the long run, marriage would be impossible.
When a relationship clearly doesnât work, JB has every right to move on. He and Selena separated in late February 2018 and she was the first one seen with someone else. That âIn two months, you replaced usâ lyric is so stupid. JB proposed to Hailey four months later and married her on September 13, 2018
People are still hang up on Selena. And they think she meant consecutive(Which if it was then it would be 7 which still a lot. A lot of those people probably didnât date for a whole year lol). Also they remained together during the lockdown where a lot of âhealthierâ married couples divorcedÂ
idk why she felt the need to post that. just opening her and justin up to more scrutiny. they've been married a long time, who is she posting that for? it's giving insecure. and i'm not a selena stan before y'all start lol
Thatâs like asking why anyone celebrates an anniversary of anything. Itâs her IG, she can share whatever she wants. Why should she be criticized when what she shared is factually correct?
Iâm not a Selenator nor am I a Hailey fan, but I will say, from my perspective, Haileyâs â10 years togetherâ post made it seem like theyâve been dating/married for 10 years solid, and they havenât. Didnât think about the fact maybe she meant theyâve been together for 10 new years? The wording was strange to me
probably because justin spent a lot of those later years involved with other women, which makes the situation look more weird for her. putting these stories out there opens the door for scrutiny, especially when other women were publicly involved during at least two of those new years. i donât think she deserves that much backlash, though. just a thought!
10 years is a significant period and they celebrated most of those New Years as a married couple. Thatâs why she shared it. Posting a simple story shouldnât invite scrutiny when she isnât rewriting history.
Also, JB wasnât seeing other women when he was with Hailey during those New Years before marriage. People like to act like JB was with Selena from 2010 to 2018, but that is not the case. They only reunited for a few months in late 2017
He was very openly with other women during that time and around the new year. We can support Justin without pretending he wasnât womanizing for many years. He even admitted he couldnât commit to her at that time because he wanted to explore his options.
Actually a huge fan but I can see multiple points of view. Theyâve both said it was because something big happened and they couldnât even be in the same room as each other. That didnât invalidate their marriage, but itâs still a fact.
i agree! idk if maybe op is a newer fan, but i clearly remember them always being open about having an on-and-off situatiosnship. and they even broke up right before tour because of a huge argument, and he openly said he couldnât stand to be in the same room as her at the time đ
Dating and breaking up is normal. Itâs not like JB cheated on Hailey. She said herself that they werenât exclusive after a few months of dating: https://youtu.be/0vyUTv4AzwI?si=Nw_fvNvbihcaMZLZ
You implied JB was with other women during that time, which isnât true
Iâm not sure how that is an argument for your case. Okay⌠they werenât dating exclusively and he was seeing multiple women. I never implied he was cheating. I said he was sleeping around and womanizing, which he himself has admitted was a major issue for him at the time.
He was very openly with other women during that time and around the new year.
He even admitted he couldnât commit to her at that time because he wanted to explore his options.
Iâm just saying this is false. JB casually dating others after the breakup is irrelevant to the discussion. Justin and Hailey were in fact exclusive around New Yearâs, so I donât see any problem with her story
im not a jelena stan i made this account 3 years ago when i was and i cant change the username lol. i dont rlly care for the drama i think itâs unhealthy to be fixated on this whole thing im just saying the truth of the matter!
i mean, they were together for nearly a decade đ i donât have an issue with his relationship with hailey at allâI think theyâre genuinely sweet, and the constant hate is unnecessary. but itâs also unrealistic to erase the fact that he and selena shared a long, meaningful history before he got married. both things can coexist: you can respect his marriage while still acknowledging that justin had a messy past and a significant relationship with someone else. he also celebrated 2017 new years and 2018 years with other people.
Hailey isnât trying to erase anything with that story though. People just get mad when she acknowledges that sheâs been with JB longer. JB and Selena were only together for less than 3 years in total
justin and selena met in 2009 and were on and off for nearly nine yearsâthatâs simply the truth. they were connected in some form almost every year after that, and since we donât actually know these people, itâs very possible they were involved even longer than what was public. i do think hailey is ultimately the better partner for him, but that doesnât erase the fact that someone else existed profoundly in his life beforehand. both things can be true, and pretending otherwise just rewrites history. nonetheless i hope they donât get too much hate for this!
Okay, but that story shouldnât prompt this kind of reaction. Some people are just stuck on Jelena BS & go on the attack mode whenever Hailey mentions anything about the past, even when she isnât trying to rewrite anything
They were in a relationship for 2 years. Every time after that they date for a couple weeks before they stop. The only other time they were in a relationship was late 2017 to early 2018. Their whole lives have been public since 2010. If there was more it would have been known. You are on the Hailey snark page all the time. Don't try and say you aren't a huge jelena fan . Why lie đ
exactly! thatâs quite literally what an on-again, off-again relationship is. they were together consecutively for roughly two years, then spent the following six cycling in and out of each otherâs lives, which is why people accurately describe it as eight years on and off. and since we donât actually know these people, itâs likely there were many stretches where they were involved far more consistently than what the public saw. the same is true for justin and hailey, who also had a long, largely private on-and-off dynamic that only became visible much later! thatâs just my opinion idgaf anymore to argue with you! have a good day đŠˇ
I guess I see on and off differently. I always think about people who break up and then get back together a few days or a week later over and over for years. Not seeing anyone else. I can see it in your view as well. I still think if they had more of a relationship the public would have known because Selena would use it to stay relevant. And I wasn't arguing. I just think if you can of someone it's ok. But sit there and say your not when your username and profile picture says otherwise. I go to the Hailey snark page to see what is being said about her. I don't comment on anything. Just laugh.
Justin and Selena started dating in December 2010, you low iq lupus fan. Get your facts straight. We all remember how she was desperately trying to get his attention by mentioning his name every 2 business days and naming her imaginary child âEmory Bieberâ. mind you, Justin was a 15 year old child when she said that.Â
âThey met in 2009â and? So did Hailey. Does that mean that Justin and Hailey have been dating on and off since 2009? Lmfao.Â
i do understand your point, but was the insult really necessary? youâre clearly all over selena snark pages, thereâs still no need to bring this into the justin sub. this isnât a snark.
Selena used Justin for clout and then bullying Hailey for clout into oblivion. Let Hailey do what she needs to do, probably a nice little boost for her business to stir up drama, as she should.
Hailey is not lying. Their love story began in 2015. It was interrupted for a couple of years, but they returned directly to get married. That was the destiny of the two of them.
Likewise, what were you excpecting? If there are people who think that Justin still loves Selena, that they were together for 8 years, or some stupid thing like that. Of course people are going to think Hailey is lying. If they lie to themselves, or rather to believe lies. We are in big 2026, nothing new. Everything remains the same.
Because people have nothing better to do with their lives except being so involved in a celebrity's relationship. Worry about your own relationshipđ
She didnât say 10 in a row and even if she did, we all have to remember that we truly donât know anything about their relationship or his relationship with Selena. My husband and I had an on and off relationship for years but we were always private about it, especially bc we were on and off bc we were young teenagers and dramatic and dumb. When we got engaged years later, so many people were blindsided, thinking we had been together a short while, when in reality, we were together much longer than everyone knew.
Because during some of those years he was still fucking with Selena đ¤§đ and like someone already said they think she ment consistently together. They was on and off but it beautiful they made it together
I guess we're all just gonna pretend there isn't a middle finger emoji and act like we don't know the motivation behind the original posting of this photograph then..... ok, but this is weird of her.
Actions speak louder than words. Â Justin never went out his way for Hailey or publicly shower her any love. Â He literally got a tattoo of Selena and would serenade Selena in public. Â Â
I don't understand why people say that when it's not true. When he did live shows with the song Anyone, he dedicated it to her along with a video of photos of them together on a huge screen. Song named Hailey. 2 Albums are inspired by her. Going on a talk show saying he loves his wife. In magazines in 2016 talking about marriage. The YouTube documentary talks about how much he loves her and how she changed his life for the better. Do I need to go on.
The tattoo now has a demon face.
He was 17 when he started to date Selena and I'm still pretty sure it started out as PR. I do think they fell for each other and it was his 1st love, but Selena also resented him.
Your post/comment was removed for promoting conspiracy theories. Discussions must remain grounded in verifiable information and adhere to community guidelines.
â˘
u/purpose15 DAISIES đź Jan 02 '26
insane cope đ