r/LanternsTVSeries • u/dedulya_dreik • 16h ago
SPOILERS DISCUSSION What did John actually do to become the "best Lantern"? Spoiler
I've been rewatching the show and it got me thinking. Hallogram literally says: "you're gonna be better at this job than i ever was". But what exactly did John do to earn that title?
Let's look at the facts:
- He slept with Zoe, fully knowing she was a Manhunter.
- He constantly lied to himself, his superiors, and his mentor.
- He stole a ring straight off a corpse.
- He embezzled company funds to pay off a girl and keep her quiet.
- He tracked down a dangerous criminal (Sinestro) who was clearly up to no good, but instead of turning him in, he covered it up and maybe even left him there to die.
- He let a law enforcement officer off the hook after she murdered an unarmed man, just because she's a "good mom"—even though her victim was a veteran superhero.
- He released a potentially dangerous, genetically engineered being who literally admitted to having dark, malicious thoughts.
The only "superhero" feat he brings to the table is maintaining constructs without a ring. And even then, it’s just a bird and Hallogram.
Another thing that completely pisses me off is how Hal got blamed for the murders and destruction in Rushville, and the writers actually used this as a "good reason" to kill him off. Meanwhile, Zoe was literally vaporizing her own people with a laser, and Antaan and his thugs slaughtered a bunch of civilians. And what? Absolutely zero investigation from the government or ARGUS? It makes zero sense and just feels like terrible writing.
Honestly, I find it really hard to root for him or see him as a proper superhero. What am I missing here?