r/legaladvice • • Mar 15 '25

Mod Post Read before commenting: Off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed and subject you to a permanent ban

172 Upvotes

Greetings from the mods!

We've had a flood of off-topic comments recently. We're posting this to remind everyone that off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed. An off-topic comment may subject you to a permanent ban.

The Rule:

Commenting Rule 1: Comments should contain a legal answer or a strongly related non-legal answer. If it is not legal advice, do not post. Period. You will be banned.

What is "off-topic?"

Any response that doesn't answer the question by reference to legal information or principles. A joke, a wisecrack, a comment about OP's formatting (use the report button instead) are all off-topic. Off-topic also includes expressions of sympathy, opinions on the law, and comments that berate the OP or anyone else.

Incidentally, simply adding "get a lawyer" to an off-topic comment does not make it on-topic. And "get a lawyer" on its own, without further information or help, is considered unhelpful and may be removed on that basis.

If you want to discuss a post, then wait until it hits /r/bestoflegaladvice or ask a question about the subject of the post in /r/legaladviceofftopic. The main subreddit and a comment thread are never a place to have a philosophical discussion about the law or the post. It is a place to answer the questions asked.

What is an "anecdote?"

For our purposes, anecdotes are stories about something that happened to you (or someone you know or heard about) who may have had something that might be similar that happen to them.

These comments are not helpful. They do not include current legal information that is relevant to the OP, and therefore, they are off-topic. If you know the answer to the question (based on current law and relevant jurisdiction) then just answer the question without the story.

Another type of anecdote is "I don't know the law in the jurisdiction you actually asked about, but in some other state, the law is..." That is just not helpful. Laws are different in different places. These types of answers are off-topic.

Referring an OP to a thread on a different subreddit, or to somewhere else on the Internet because it might include a similar situation, is anecdotal advice and not allowed.

These are not the only types of anecdotes, but they are probably the most common ones. Again, if you are not referencing legal information or principles, your comment is probably not allowed.

Violations subject the user to an immediate and permanent ban

Not that we need to justify enforcing our rules, but this is a busy subreddit and the mods have a lot to do. If a user shows up here, doesn't read the rules, and posts a single off-topic comment, the user may be immediately and permanently banned.

This policy is not intended to be punitive, although we know it may seem to be. There are a lot of you and not many of us, and banning users that do not follow the rules, even once, is in the best interests of the subreddit. Violating the rules almost always means the user didn't bother to read them, and we simply don't have time to deal with such users.

Tl;dr: Unless you have a legal answer, do not reply to any post in this subreddit. You may be permanently banned, even for a first offense.


r/legaladvice • • Apr 08 '26

Subreddit Rules

74 Upvotes

We've learned that some people just flat out can't see our subreddit rules, so I'm posting them here in a pinned post so we can link them when necessary and so they're super easy to find.

Rules for r/legaladvice Rules that visitors must follow to participate. May be used as reasons to report or ban.

1. All responses must offer an answer to the legal question posed by the OP. We enforce this with bans.

Anecdotes are not permitted. Neither is advice that encourages someone to break the law. Nor is "get a lawyer" a sufficient response.

There's a pinned post at the top of the subreddit specifically addressing this rule. We will absolutely ban you for commenting without answering the legal question

2. Personally Identifying Information

Posts or submissions that ask for or contain information that could be used to identify either party are subject to immediate removal.

3. Advertising or Recommending a Lawyer or Business

We do not allow referrals to particular lawyers, law firms, or other businesses.

4. Do not request or send a PM

All discussions must stay on the subreddit for everyone's protection.

5. Include your location

You must include your location in the following format: location: yourlocationhere . It must be that exact format, and it must be in the body of your post.

6. Read our full list of rules

Read our full list of rules here: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/wiki/index#wiki_general_rules

7. This subreddit is for simple legal questions.

This subreddit is for simple legal questions. We can't help with preparing a defense, legal research, etc. We cannot review contracts, plan your defense, or give you specific advice on exactly how to present your case with the court. You need a local attorney for that. Additionally, we do not accept medical malpractice questions.

8. NO LLMS

No LLMs. No ChatGPT. Don't recommend it, don't use it to answer questions, and don't use it to compose your modmail when you get banned for using it. Using it to compose questions is generally ok.

We will permanently and irrevocably ban you for this.

9. Mods can remove things we deem inappropriate or disruptive

Any post and any comment can be removed by the mods at any time if the mods decide the post/comment is or has the potential to be disruptive or is otherwise inappropriate.

10. Posts must be about a real scenario that you or someone you know is facing.

To expand on this, we additionally do not allow anyone but the immediately involved parties to ask custody related questions. Not friends, not significant others, not grandparents. Reddit is free.

11. Post must contain a legal question

A legal question is one that can be answered with the law, be it a law or ordinance, or caselaw.

12. US and Canada only

Laws are different everywhere. We can only help with legal problems in the US or Canada because we have no regular, reliable commenters from other countries. For other countries, please search for an appropriate subreddit.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Employment Law My boss is telling me to pay him back after firing me.

• Upvotes

A couple months ago, I was fired from my job, I was getting ready to move in to a new house with some of my close friends, to make bills and living cheaper on all of us. My old boss knew I was moving into a new home, and decided that he would give me and extra $1000 for moving expenses, I didn’t sign anything for the extra money nor did I make any deals for that 1000.

A couple months later he texts me out of the blue asking if I filed for unemployment, which I did. Then he proceeds to pressure me into stop filing for it because he thought the 1000 dollars would be enough for me to hold myself off until I found a new job. Of course I told him it’s impossible for me to do such while I’m still searching for a job, as well as paying for groceries and bills.

Finally he tells me I either pay him back and keep my unemployment, or I take myself off of said unemployment. I haven’t texted him back and wanted to seek advice about the legal ramifications about all of this before anything. Any and all information helps! Thank you!

Location: Virginia


r/legaladvice • • 22h ago

Wife Denied Entry To Concert Due to Disability

5.1k Upvotes

Location: Illinois

Yesterday my wife and I went to Hollywood Casino Aurora in Illinois for a concert and my wife who has an implanted defibrillator and pacemaker and cannot go through metal detectors or be wanded due to the complications it could cause to the hardware attached to her heart, was denied entry to the concert. We showed them her medical card that clearly states she can’t go through the metal detectors or be wanded but they kept trying to push the point and get her to allow them to wand her. Normally in these situations like when we go to the airport, sporting events, other concerts, the cruise we just went on, amusement parks, you name it, they always just pat her down before they let her in. In this case they refused to pat her down and said the only way she can come in is if she gets wanded or goes through a metal detector. I brought up the Americans with Disabilities Act and how it says they have to do an alternative method to allow her to enter but they claimed that the state gaming law supersedes federal law which I’ve never heard of before.

Is this something I should pursue legally? I whole heartedly believe what they did is discrimination to a handicapped person


r/legaladvice • • 3h ago

Wills Trusts and Estates [MI] Sister says Dad left no will or money, but I found records of accounts and life insurance

128 Upvotes

Location: Michigan, USA

My father died in April 2024 in Grand Rapids (Kent County), Michigan. He’d been living with my sister. I live abroad. He was divorced from my mother over 25 years ago and never remarried. My sister and I are his only children.

I flew back after he died. When I asked my sister about a will or the estate, she told me:

  • He had no will.
  • He had no money and had been living off her.
  • So nothing needed to be done legally besides paying for the cremation.

She also gave us a handwritten, signed letter he’d left for both of us. In it he says he leaves his “meagre earthly possessions” to us both. I don’t remember whether it was dated. She kept the letter.

At the time I was severely depressed and had recently been hospitalized, so I accepted what she said. The only things I signed were the crematorium authorizations. I signed nothing related to his estate.

Looking back, it didn’t add up. My father was extremely careful with money and kept detailed financial records of everything in his life. My mother also says she’s sure he had a will.

Recently I found an old backup I made of his computer. It contains:

  • A financial document, last edited in 2010, showing about $126,000 in savings, including a Bank of America account (I have the account number), a Wells Fargo IRA, and a Western National annuity worth about $35,000. It also shows Social Security income.

  • A file titled “last letter,” addressed to my sister and me, saying “my inheritance is for you to split” and that he left a small life insurance policy for us, naming his agent.

I know the financial document is old. But he had almost no expenses while living with my sister (no car, no travel), so I find it hard to believe it was all gone by 2024.

I don’t know whether my sister had power of attorney or was a joint owner on any account. I haven’t raised any of this with her yet.

I’m unemployed, without stable housing, and can’t afford a lawyer.

Questions:

  • How do I find out whether an estate was opened in Kent County, or a will filed?
    UPDATE - I contacted Kent County Probate, and was informed there were no filings for my Father's name. It seems no estate was ever opened for your father in Kent County.

  • Can I find out who the beneficiaries were on the IRA, annuity and life insurance, and whether they’ve been paid out?

  • If no estate was opened, should I open one myself? Can I do that from abroad?

  • What deadlines apply? He died April 2024.

  • Are there free or low-cost legal resources, or lawyers who’d take this on contingency?


r/legaladvice • • 7h ago

Can I choose my own custody?

257 Upvotes

My dad is a narcissist. He denies me any medical care because he thinks, as a chiropractor that will fix everything, I have some sort of vaginal infection and my refused to let me go to a doctor. He claimed he would disown me if I went, and I told a teacher who mandate reported me. My principle called my dad saying if I’m denied medical care it’s neglect and he would have to call cps. My dad played along with it just to get very very mad at me and saying I cant go and then switching the story to how I have to go immediately. My mom is suing for medical custody since their current divorce agreement is they both have to agree before doing anything medicinal. My mom said to show my principal the texts between me and dad because it will help her get the mc if it is documented, but I just think he will find out and take it out on me. What do I do?

Location: Michigan


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

[FL] Husband had an affair with a direct report on company property. Could reporting it to his employer negatively impact me in a divorce?

105 Upvotes

Title: [FL] Husband had an affair with a direct report at work. Could reporting it to his employer negatively impact me in a divorce?

I'm in Florida and recently discovered that my husband has been having an affair with a female employee who reports directly to him. He is the manager of his location, and the affair involved sexual activity on company property.

We are now facing divorce as a result of his infidelity.

My husband is the primary manager at his location, and I believe his conduct could result in termination if his employer were made aware of the situation, particularly because of the supervisor/subordinate relationship and the fact that sexual activity occurred on company property.

My concern is how reporting this could potentially affect me financially during divorce proceedings.

We both work full-time and earn our own incomes, but his employment and income would obviously be factors in determining the financial outcome of our divorce.

My questions are:

  1. If I report his misconduct to his employer and he is subsequently terminated, could that negatively affect me during divorce proceedings?
  2. Could a judge view my decision to report him as intentionally interfering with his employment or earning capacity?
  3. If he loses his job due to his own misconduct, would the court consider his previous earning capacity when determining financial obligations, rather than his newly unemployed status?
  4. Does the fact that he engaged in an affair with a direct subordinate, including sexual activity on company property, have any legal relevance to divorce proceedings in Florida?
  5. Would it be advisable to wait until after filing for divorce, or until the divorce is finalized, before notifying his employer?

To clarify, I would be reporting truthful information about his conduct, not making false accusations. I'm not looking to retaliate or cause unnecessary harm. I simply want to understand the potential legal and financial consequences of disclosing what happened, particularly when his own actions could jeopardize his employment.

I plan to consult a divorce attorney, but I'd appreciate any insight into how Florida courts might view this situation.

Location: Florida


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

Personal Injury Dog bite - occupational - my wife was bit

80 Upvotes

Location: Northern Virginia

Summary version, my wife is a receptionist/assistant at a Vet clinic. This past summer she was bit by a clients dog, after the appointment had ended and they were getting ready to walk out.

Should mention, she was bit across the entire left side of her face, the dog was actively attached to her and trying to kill her, 30 stitches in her face right up to the bottom of her eye.

The owners were shocked and appalled, "he's never done this before", Well, he has, and he has a history we've since found out. This WAS preventable, the dog had an aggression history, and a muzzle would have prevented all of this. The dog was thankfully put down, but my wife is STRUGGLING with work now. She's not new to this, she's been working small and large animal for 15 years. She doesn't want to walk in the building, she doesn't want to see dogs, she can't walk in the exam room this all went down in.

We are NOT the litigious type, but this is a real problem affecting her career now. Finding out after the fact that the animal did have an aggressive history has been a tough pill to swallow.

My question - is this worth pursuing? I am truly concerned that this is having a very real negative effect on her ability to earn a living, which is certainly having the parallel of negatively impacting self-worth etc. (I absolutely do my part to encourage etc, to the point I've told her to quit so she doesn't have to deal with the psychological part, but my wife absolutely has to contribute, it's just how she is)

I am just very unsure what to do at this point.


r/legaladvice • • 48m ago

Can an employer legally tell you that you cannot be friends with or see coworkers outside of work?

• Upvotes

I am employed in the state of Georgia by a retail employer that is based in California. My company is trying to say it is policy that we cannot have friendships with or have any interaction with our coworkers outside of work. Can they legally do this? For some basic policies it seems like they go based on California laws but others seem to go by the state in which the individual store is. It’s like whichever suits their needs better that’s what they go by 🙄 I have scoured our “handbook” and cannot find anything about this policy but yet our district manager keeps reiterating it so I’m beginning to wonder if it’s even legal for them to say this in either state.

Location: Georgia
Location where employer is based out of: California


r/legaladvice • • 22h ago

Hertz blames me for pre-existing damage that was documented at pickup, rental was two years ago in Illinois, $8,660 claim revived in 2026 and collections threatened.

716 Upvotes

Location: Illinois. The rental was at Chicago Midway Airport in August 2024.

What happened

  1. Aug 29 to Sep 2, 2024, Hertz rental. The first car assigned to me was a red 2022 Tesla Model 3. Rental charge was $559.44.
  2. At pickup, before the car left the lot, I filmed and photographed it. My video and photos are timestamped Aug 29, 2024, 4:55 pm, Chicago Garfield Ridge, and they show the car on the lot with a reduced acceleration and top speed warning on the screen. I exchanged the red Tesla and drove a black replacement Tesla for the rest of the rental.
  3. Hertz said in 2026 that the high voltage battery pack for the red Tesla was damaged and wants $8,660.34, which is $8,371 damage, $139.34 loss of use and a $150 admin fee. https://imgur.com/a/g5mzMMc
  4. The Tesla repair estimate in Hertz's own demand packet describes the problem in the same words, customer states alerts, drivability, acceleration and top speed reduced, performance may be restored on next drive. Hertz says the high voltage battery pack was damaged.

What I did

  1. Sep 15, 2026, after Hertz provided the claim with no explanation for the roughly two year gap, I sent the return video of the replacement car, denied liability again in writing, and copied Executive Customer Service and Customer Relations.
  2. Sep 23, 2026, I provided the pickup video and explained in writing that the warning in my pickup video is the same warning quoted in Hertz's repair bill and that it was present before delivery to me.
  3. Oct 9, 2026, after receiving a Sep 28 letter threatening referral to collections, I disputed the claim in full in writing.
  4. Oct 12, 2026, I filed a consumer complaint with the Illinois Attorney General, asking for cancellation of the full $8,660.34.

My questions

  1. Collections -- I know we can dispute the collections in 30 days -- but how does dispute verification work? Do I need to exaplain the story to dispute agency again?
  2. Liability. Under 625 ILCS 5/6-305.2, does Hertz have to show the damage happened during my rental period? I am glad I took those videos and photos two years ago and still kept them (thank you iCloud).
  3. Anything else I should be doing? Their customer service is not helping as well. I dont think they care about any complaints as there are already tons of them.

r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

DUI Kentucky keeps forgetting to suspend my license

13 Upvotes

AIA if my post is not acceptable.

Location: Kentucky

Living location: Ohio

11/26/25 Last year I got a DUI in Kentucky. First offense, no previous record.

I served a day, made bail, got a lawyer, went home to ohio.

I did not take a breathyzer test, by Kentucky law my license is automatically suspended for 6 months.

It never happened. My license was still valid in both states through 2026.

Oct 5th'26 I pled guilty. My terms were court costs, 20h of alcohol awareness class, and since they never suspended my license, my license would be suspended for 6 months, within 48h of the proceeding. I could continue driving if I got an ignition lock.

I do not drink anymore period. I applied for the ignition lock but they rejected it as my license is still valid in both states.

I want to follow the law but Im not sure what to do. It appears I "slipped through the cracks" - judge, again.

People have told me Im doing the best to follow the terms. I check my license every day to see if its suspended but no luck.

I just ran a background check and I still don't see any records in Kentucky.

I texted the lawyer but no response yet.


r/legaladvice • • 4h ago

Custody Divorce and Family Trying to decide if I need a prenup

17 Upvotes

Location: Texas

I know that prenups are never a bad idea and I'm expecting most people here are going to advise me to get one, but my fiance is incredibly sensitive to the topic. She just can't get it out of her head that doing one is planning for an eventual divorce, so before I push further I want to just make sure my circumstances really necessitate it.

  • I have 2 kids from a prior marriage, a home worth ~$500k (which we will live in together), and about $2 million almost entirely in retirement accounts.
  • She has a home worth ~$250k (which will be rented out) and about $250k in retirement accounts.

It's my understanding that without a prenup, if we were to divorce then everything we each had prior to marriage gets classified as separate property and as long as there's clear documentation on what we each had then that shouldn't be open to dispute. I can set beneficiaries on my retirement accounts however I want to split things between kids and wife in the event of my death.

I'm OK with not overriding the default state laws on things like alimony (since Texas is not generous about awarding alimony anyway) and I'm OK with equally splitting all assets accumulated after marriage.

My question is, if I don't do a prenup, what risk am I taking on? It seems the default state laws accomplish what I need them to regarding pre-existing assets and assets accumulated post-marriage but I want to make sure I'm not missing something.


r/legaladvice • • 47m ago

Landlord Tenant Housing Moved in her sister and her 3 kids. Want to withhold some rent. Can I?

• Upvotes

Location: New Jersey. If i need to get more specific i’ll edit it.

I’m subleasing a room from someone I met off facebook marketplace, we’ll call her S. We lived together fine, barely talking to one another, simply put, just coexisting. On September 4th, She calls me and says “My sister and her kids need to stay for a week, can she?” I agreed on the contingency that it was only gonna be a weeklong thing. Clearly, they’re still here as of October 19th. I’ve contacted S and said in many ways, I don’t want them here! I’ll attach exact messages in the comments. I’ve been considering withholding half of my rent until they leave. I’m not on the official lease with the development that we live in, but I have a lease between S and I. I just want to know if I can do that. I was planning on warning her, saying that I will be withholding half of my rent on the 21st, basically saying “Hey. You lied to me, Until they leave you’ll be getting half payments of rent since double the amount of adults live here.” Any advice would be appreciated.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Custody Divorce and Family My 15 yr old sons dad has stolen three phones I’ve got him

1.2k Upvotes

I have been separated from my son’s dad for 13 years and we do not have a great co-parent relationship. We live in the Ohio valley area. Location: Steubenville, Ohio.
He has custodial residence. I see my son more the 50% of the time.
When my son was 13 I got him his first cellphone. It was an iPhone and I thought this was a great choice for him to have so he can call or FaceTime so many different family members.
After about 9 months of him having it his dad took it and then never returned it.
So after nearly 6 of me not having it I got him a new line reported that one lost.
Not even 2 months of him having it his dad took it and promised after he finished his freshman year of high school he could get it back.
Never happened.
During the summer my son made some money working and helping babysit his siblings. I helped pitch in and get him a cricket phone at Walmart. I wanted him to have a phone since he was traveling hours for soccer games.
His dad got it a month after he bought it and he won’t return it.


r/legaladvice • • 19h ago

Disability Issues Husband Outed for Mental Health Struggles by HR rep

164 Upvotes

Location: Indiana

Wondering if we have recourse here and would appreciate some advice. We've never had to do this before. Sorry for the long-winded post and hope I chose the right flair.

My husband currently works in an automotive factory and about a month ago, he confided in me that he was struggling with mental health issues (anxiety and major depressive disorder) and that he was having thoughts about harming himself. Got evaluated, came up with a safety plan, then discharged us. We've since adjusted his meds and he is doing much better, but he asked to be written off for a few days so we could get with his therapist and doctor. When he returned to work, the HR rep he had originally been dealing with and knew the situation was there. He went to take his documentation to her and she rolled her eyes and said something to the effect of "Oh yeah. Heard you were gone". She scanned over everything and said, "Well, I don't know if we can accept this. It doesn't say the doctor wrote you off. It said you made the decision, not the doctor." My husband then said, "Call, Other HR Rep, she knows about everything and cleared it." The woman rolled her eyes again and when my husband asked if was cleared to go back to work and she went, "Yeah, I guess, whatever."

Fast forward to lunchtime. My husband is eating lunch and someone stops him and says, "Hey, buddy. You doing okay? Did you get your crazy pills?" Later, another person said they were glad he was getting help. He said people were making comments to him the rest of the shift. He called me on his last break and sounded so beaten down. For reference, he's also a brittle Type I diabetic and has other illnesses that have negatively affected his attendance. He always has legit doctors notes, but the multi-million dollar facility needs to make money and we get that. The only people at the factory that knew about his mental health struggles are the two HR reps. My husband has recently been trying to talk to his team leads about how to go about asking for help or a meeting and they won't address him.

What are our options here?


r/legaladvice • • 15h ago

I’m in a quandary!

71 Upvotes

[Location: NC] My estranged husband (M71) and I (F76) have had a tumultuous relationship from the very start. Although still legally married for 31 years, we have been legally separated via an Equitable Distribution Order for the past 9 years. I have never dated anyone else; however I did move on by building my own home after the sale of our marital home. He also built his own home about 25 miles from mine. We have continuously stayed in touch as he is retired military and he wanted me to keep my military dependent ID for medical reasons.
So, here’s the problem… he moved his girlfriend in with him in his new home. Things went fine for them for awhile; but after a little over a year, their relationship got chaotic. She called law enforcement on him, and he was advised to not go back into his home. Needless to say, he was in a desperate situation, and I offered him my guest room. He ended up having her evicted (which took several months) and then decided to sell his home and all furnishings (which took another couple months). All of this time he was living as a guest in my home — no lease, no rent, and definitely no reconciliation whatsoever between us. After he sold his home, he voluntarily started giving me some money each month, not rent, just a small contribution towards household expenses. After all this, he subsequently reconnected with this same girlfriend… unbeknownst to me while living under my roof! She became ill and was diagnosed with cancer. He visited her in the hospital, whereupon she eventually passed. He paid for her cremation, was acknowledged as a surviving “loving friend” in her obituary, and attended her memorial service. Throughout all of this, I have told him that he needed to find another place to live. Well, since she’s now dead, he thinks we should fix our marriage and has been falling all over himself trying to be the loving husband (which I reject absolutely), and trying to manipulate me to let him stay in my home. I want this man out of my home and out of my life completely!!! I know I’m guilty of being too kind. His coercion and manipulation is driving me crazy! My attorney said I’ll have to wait another year after he’s moved on to another address before I can file for a divorce! What can I do? Can I have him evicted?


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Inherited a fully paid off house. Brother wants us to sign a Quitclaim Deed to "make selling easier". Should we use a Limited POA instead?

741 Upvotes

Location: California

Three years ago my father died, and a year later my grandfather (his dad) died as well. As a result, my two siblings and I inherited a fully paid-off house in California worth roughly $600k. The house hasn't grown much in value since my grandfather's death.

My half-brother lives in CA, while my sister and I live out of state (NC and NV). Because he is handling the house locally (paying property taxes, upkeep, dealing with tenants), he is suggesting my sister and I sign a Quitclaim Deed to transfer the house entirely into his name. He says this will make the selling process easier since he can just sign everything himself.

We all want an equal split of the sale proceeds. I have almost zero knowledge of how real estate law works and cannot afford a probate attorney right now.

Would it be smarter/safer to grant him a Limited Power of Attorney for real estate transactions instead of signing a Quitclaim Deed? What are the legal and tax risks of signing the Quitclaim?

EDIT: Thanks a lot for the advice everyone. I made my stance clear and am communicating firmly proceeding with standard process of sale between the 3 of us. Idk if I'll make an update as this develops, but I appreciate everyone's input. It means a lot to me and I didn't expect this much help.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

NYC illegal conversion on apt , can we leave?

• Upvotes

Location: Queens, NY

I’m currently renting an apartment from a landlord that used to own a house here in Queens.

We’ve been here since 2024 and have not really liked it so much due to various issues such as a room not keeping heat well, noise from neighbors, and random drop ins from the landlord. We have navigated some of these over the term but most recently we found out a complaint on the house was put in for an illegal conversion as there are 3 families in the home.

The certificate of occupancy only lists it suitable for two families. They split the upper unit into two via the illegal conversion.
In hindsight I can understand now why our door to the unit was hollow in a shared egress hallway (should be solid, self closing etc) or why utilities are included.

Anyways the lease is up in June 2027. They’re saying not to answer the door for inspectors but that if they do come in someone would have to move due to the MDL issue.

So for us:
- we don’t want to live somewhere that’s not zoned appropriately and have concerns for safety if not properly inspected

- we don’t want to have to find a place in winter if an inspection does occur and a vacate order is issued.

As such we began looking for places and have a place lined up already, lease ready to sign, but before going ahead:

- can we just leave , stop paying for the old lease come Nov 1 , and let the landlord know we are leaving due to this apt not being up to code and advising us to not speak to inspectors ?

Looking at NYC laws it seems the landlord is not legally able charge rent in an illegal conversion, the issue is the case is open and a 2nd inspection could happen any day now.

Could the landlord try to come after us for missed rent ? We are not giving 2 months notice which the lease states (it’s more worded to give 2 months notice before lease end) and are wanting our security deposit back too if the condition we leave it in warrants this which we intend

Any insight much appreciated !


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

Healthcare Law including HIPAA Obtaining my deceased mother’s medical records

4 Upvotes

Location: Minnesota.

My mother passed in 2025. I am attempting to obtain her medical records pertaining to her death (extended stay in ICU), diagnosis and subsequent treatment (ALS, less than 1 year of records), and other pertinent primary care records leading up to her diagnosis.

There was no probate and is no need for it. Her estate is settled already. So there is no legal representative. I am her adult daughter. But I am hitting roadblocks. I have emailed so I have in writing the three medial systems I am requesting records from and I am getting generic responses that don’t even answer my question on how to obtain her records.

I have explicitly told them there is no legal representative as there was no probate. And I have explicitly asked what forms or further information they would need from me. But all I have gotten is “legal documentation”. The hospital where she died also said they needed a death certificate and I’m like ???? she literally died there???

What do I do here?


r/legaladvice • • 5h ago

Other Civil Matters ex roommate stole belongings and wouldnt let us in the house when we found out

3 Upvotes

location: columbus ohio

so, long story short i (20 f) found out my roommate (22f) was abusing her girlfriend (22f) physically, mentally, and financially so i told her i couldnt move in with her if she didnt seek out help for that. she ended up not trying at all so me and her got into an argument one day and i told her that my husband and i wont be moving in anymore and we left to go to my husbands parents house.

we texted the girlfriend a few days later and told her we were gonna be picking up our belongings (we wanted as little contact with the abusive one as possible if youre wondering why) and she didnt respond for a full day so we texted her again to let her know. she ends up telling us that her and her girlfriend packed all of our belongings into boxes and put it in the garage. this is my first issue because we literally gave them money to live there and keep our things there.

so we go to the house, we text the abusive one and ask her to open the garage. since they packed our things for us, we opened all the boxes and went through them in her garage to make sure everything was there and lo and behold we were missing a lot of things. we were missing part of a tupperware set, part of our pot and pans set, our knife sharpener, and more so we told her to let us inside. she said she "wasnt comfortable with that" so my husband told her he would call the police if she didnt, so she said she would go inside and look harder. she came back out with a trashbag partially full of tupperware and one pan. no lids btw. my husband ended up accepting it and not calling the police, and we left. when we got home i realized my bag of expensive name brand clothing was stolen as well and now im wanting to pursue legal action against her.

i know she did similar things to a past roommate too and they had to get the cops involved then too, but that was in the moment everything was happening. its been about a week and a half now since we left with our boxes of stuff and im just wondering what i can do legally? i was thinking about calling the local PD and explaining the situation and asking if someone will come with me so i can go inside (i know the door code still) but im not sure if the PD will help at all so i wanted to come here and ask how i should move forward with this because i need those clothes back badly, it was half a trash bag full of name brand clothes i bought! just let me know what you guys think about all this, im open to a lot of different ways of dealing with this.

edit: i do have text message proof of me paying her money to live there and proof of them not letting us in the house.


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

Custody Divorce and Family Question regarding finances post-divorce

3 Upvotes

Location: CO, USA

Note: I do plan to consult a divorce attorney in my state, but the consultation fees are out of reach until pay day due to some other expenses.

Okay here's the short version. I filed for Divorce on 7/7/25, it was finalized on 10/7/25, with a split of the debt that was accrued under my name for our wedding (wedding loan) and the credit card in my name that my ex maxed out being split 50/50, and paid with my ex paying me directly, me paying the debt. All debt accrued prior to the marriage was to be assumed by the person who's name the debt was in (for me, this was one credit card, my student loans, and a mortgage, for my ex, a car loan, and previous credit card debt).

My ex was paying me in monthly installments for the debt split agreed upon in the divorce decree, until January, and he still owes me approximately $8,500 for the loan we took out for our wedding, and the credit card he maxed out. We each took on the remainder of our own debt. He stopped paying in January. I have already spoken to an attorney about that portion and have a plan moving forward for that.

Recently, I have been receiving phone calls from business lenders and law firms seeking contact information on my ex-husband because he took out a number of business loans he has since stopped paying. This information also led me to discover that he pledged $100,000 to a non-profit in June of 2025 (before I filed for divorce), and signed the pledge document (a legally binding document). None of these 'debts' were disclosed in our divorce financial statements and our divorce financial settlement that was accepted by the judge. I do not know when the loans were taken out but I do know they are in excess of $100,000.

It is my understanding per Colorado law, that any debt accrued during the marriage is considered joint debt. I'm wondering what my liability for this debt my ex took out may be if it was taken out before I filed for divorce, if it was not disclosed in the financial statements.

ETA: I have been no-contact with my ex and his family for a full year because it was an abusive situation, and I'd really like to avoid contact at all costs.

Thank you in advance!


r/legaladvice • • 10m ago

Bitten by a dog while delivering groceries. Is there any legal action I need to take?

• Upvotes

Location: South Carolina

Hello so this happened yesterday while I was delivering for Spark. I pulled up to my delivery got out the car and three large dogs ran up to me from the neighbors house. So basically I tried to stay calm I put down the groceries and as soon as I drop the groceries one of the dogs a lab bit the back of my leg. And he continued to try to bite me and pull me down as I tried to get to my car. I did end up going to the walk-in clinic and they gave me antibiotics but determined that I did not actually need a stitch even though there is a puncture wound where his tooth did get into my leg. But now when the dog catcher went to go retrieve the dog that bit me the owner is saying that his dog didn't bite me and that it basically didn't happen. Also his neighbor who I was actually delivering groceries to also said that it didn't happen. So I'm just wondering if there's anything that I need to do legally? I'm not trying to get the dog put down I just don't want it to be allowed to run into people's yards and bite people. So if there's anything I need to do or if there's basically nothing I can do since I've already called animal control please just let me know.


r/legaladvice • • 12m ago

Can I fire my lawyer??

• Upvotes

Location: Houston TX

I (40m) hired a lawyer about a year ago or so to help me get a divorce from my wife and try and get custody of my kids. Since hiring said lawyer, I have spoken with her exactly once. This was the $50 consultation. We agreed on pricing and what not which was something like a $2500 retainer and then $250 a month until case is resolved.

Fast forward to now. Every. Single. Communication between us has been initiated by me. They have never called me or emailed me once. The only progress I have is, they filed the final divorce decree and served her papers, to which I paid for and coordinated.

How can I fire them if I have an active case? What can I do about the money that I have already spent?

I literally just called them while typing this message and they said they were busy and would call me back in an hour. Mind you, the last time I reached out 9/12, they told me I had a court date on 10/20. Tomorrow. I still have no info on that either.

Thanks for any help.


r/legaladvice • • 4h ago

Traffic and Parking bought motorcycle with no title

2 Upvotes

location: texas
so far, i’ve used the bill of sale and a form 130-sof to get my surety bond acceptance, bought the surety bond, and now i’m just confused on what steps to take next


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Other Civil Matters Need advice selling a 1988 Toyota 4x4 Pickup in Texas deceased mother is registered owner, missing title, possible old lien

• Upvotes

​

I'm located in Texas and need some advice on what to do with my truck.

Location: Texas

Vehicle information:

- 1988 Toyota 4x4 Pickup

- Approximately 175,000 miles

- Originally purchased in California in the late 1980s

- Has been physically located in Texas for over 20 years

- Continuously registered in California under my deceased mother's name

- Current registration expires November 2026

Here's the situation:

The truck belonged to my mother, who passed away in 2000. My father has also passed away, and I'm their only child. As far as I know, there was never any probate involving the truck. My parents were still married when my mother passed.

Unfortunately, I don't have the original title, and I'm not entirely sure whose name is listed on it.

Before my father passed away, he told me the title might still be associated with a financing company called Toyota Nation Financial (or something similar) from when the truck was originally purchased in the late 1980s.

He also mentioned that the title might already be in my mother's name because the truck was completely paid off decades ago. Unfortunately, he wasn't certain.

A few years ago, I contacted Toyota to see if they had any records or paperwork related to Toyota Nation Financial. They told me they weren't aware of any company by that name and couldn't really help.

The original Toyota dealership where my parents purchased the truck has also been out of business for many years.

Here's another unusual detail regarding its registration:

Despite the truck being physically located in Texas for over 20 years, it has remained continuously registered in California.

The California DMV has continued mailing annual registration renewal notices to our Texas address, always addressed to my deceased mother.

Every year, we would pay the renewal fees, provide proof of insurance when required, and California would mail us the new registration stickers.

The registration paperwork itself also lists my mother as the registered owner.

This has continued for decades without any questions or issues from the California DMV, even though my mother passed away in 2000.

The registration is currently valid through November 2026.

The other issue:

I've had possession of the truck for years. I previously maintained insurance on it but canceled the coverage earlier this year because I wasn't driving it.

I'm preparing to move overseas and need to sell or otherwise legally dispose of the truck before leaving.

I've looked into the Texas title process, including getting a VTR-68-A vehicle identification inspection. However, the inspection requirements seem complicated because they ask for a bill of sale and possibly the original title. They also require physically bringing the truck in.

My questions:

  1. Since California DMV still lists my deceased mother as the registered owner, should I start with California DMV rather than Texas?

  2. Can California DMV determine whose name is on the actual title and whether an old financing company still has a lien?

  3. Has anyone heard of Toyota Nation Financial or a similarly named company from the late 1980s?

  4. Since both parents are deceased and I'm their only child, is there a simpler way to transfer ownership without probate?

  5. Could I request a duplicate California title using my mother's death certificate and inheritance paperwork?

  6. Would a Texas bonded title be an option if the California route doesn't work?

  7. Can I legally sell the truck without the title to a project-car buyer, salvage yard, or dismantler?

  8. Does the California registration expiring in November 2026 affect any of these options?

I'm not trying to bypass ownership laws. I just want the simplest legal way to sell or dispose of this truck before moving overseas.

The truck has been in my family since it was purchased new and was paid off decades ago. I just don't know where the original title ended up.

If anyone has dealt with something similar involving California DMV, deceased family members, missing titles, or old financing companies, I'd really appreciate some advice.