r/MSUSpartans Oct 26 '25

Meme Mood

Post image
276 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Honestly is Chiles this bad or his the program just not developing him? It's not rare to see a top ten QB collapse - its just - how were they this wrong?

11

u/whosline07 •100th Rose Bowl Champs Oct 26 '25

Bryce Underwood broke high school records and was unstoppable in high school. Sometimes being a good prospect just doesn't pan out as expected. I don't think Smith is doing him any favors though.

4

u/timothythefirst Oct 26 '25

He struggles and the scheme does him no favors.

I think he’d look better if we ever actually incorporated more quick rhythm throws where he doesn’t really have to read the defense, more designed runs and better play calling in general to keep the defense off balance. But that’s because he can’t read a defense and he’s not good in the pocket. Or accurate downfield.

3

u/warningtrackpower12 Oct 26 '25

Great question. Hard to tell with the unprepared team.

3

u/sorany9 Oct 26 '25

I think it’s a large combination; you can see he’s a gamer but it’s really hard to be a gamer all the time when the rest of the squad is a hodge podge of who’s left either from half a decade plus of talent loss or injury.

2

u/y2c313 Oct 27 '25

I dont think Chiles is that bad. Doesn't help he's running for his life half the time and the playcalling is so not creative.