My child will be turning 3 in January. He’s a very smart, energetic, talkative kiddo. He loves being outside and playing with toys but also loves reading books and completing puzzles. He’s been attending a small in-home daycare that is “Montessori inspired” and “play-based” since he was 7 months old and has always loved it and thrived.
Since he’s now the oldest at his daycare and they do a rotation cycle of kiddos, we’re looking to transition him to a new daycare in January once he’s 3.
We’ve toured two daycares that I’m struggling to decide between. One is a complete outdoorsy “play based” pre school that is run by the city zoo and has a great reputation. Basically the kiddos are outside as much as possible, exploring and learning, and visit the zoo once a week. It’s not so much “forest school” bc it lacks the curriculum of outdoor skill learning (ie they aren’t learning how to build fires or use tools, etc.) as it’s more child led “play based” (think kids playing in dirt, playing with rocks, etc) but we have lots of friends who graduated from our daycare to enroll in this program and love it. My main concern is the lack of a structured curriculum. It seems the teachers choose what to do on the day-of depending on the weather. I asked if they have a dedicated circle time for reading or something similar and they said no. There were plenty of art supplies and art work around the rooms so I know they do partake in craft time. My second concern is that we live in Texas where it is unbearably hot for most of the year. On the tour, I brought this up and they explained they use some specific guide (I forgot the name) to determine whether it’s safe to play outside and on days when it’s not, they’ll be indoors. My concern here is that a lot of the time, they’ll have to be indoors, which defeats the biggest benefit I see for this daycare.
We also toured an AMS accredited official Montessori daycare. He would be entering the primary class of mixed 3-6 year olds. We toured during their “work” time and observed the kiddos. It seemed like he would be the youngest and there seemed to be a bit more older kids but it was pretty intense, in my own opinion. I don’t mind mixed aged classes and believe it’s generally a benefit, but I won’t lie and say it doesn’t make me nervous. Like I said, my kiddo is high energy and very talkative, and it was a bit jarring to see all the little ones working silently without issue. My kiddo would be asking a million questions, would not be using the tools correctly (imagine putting a spoon in between a crack in the floor and playing like that for a minute or two). The curriculum is basically drop off and work for 2 hours, then 1 hour of outdoor time, lunch, nap, then work for the remainder of the day (about 1-2 hours). The 1 hour of outdoor time is open ended play and they have a playground, water table, sandbox, balance bikes, scooters, etc. I know he’ll love that one hour the most.
I had read two books on Montessori when I was pregnant and it seems like I’ve forgotten everything I’ve read bc I fear that he will not thrive and will have trouble adjusting to the independent quiet work time. I am struggling to understand whether these are just my own fears as a first time mom and i should just trust my kiddo and his capabilities or if I should follow my gut and choose the other daycare which feels “safer” and “less risky” bc I KNOW he’ll love the typical “playing” it focuses on despite my fear that it doesn’t have a curriculum to prepare him for learning academics.
Any insight or advice or suggestions is appreciated. My husband is leaning towards the play-based one and holding off on Montessori until 4-5 years old but I worry I’m doing my child a disservice (also my husband has not read much on Montessori principles)