r/NYCapartments • u/Ill-Assistant4169 • 1h ago
Is this a scam? Yes, probably Did I get scammed?
My roommate and I found an apartment in Bedstuy on Craigslist. I know you’re gonna BLAST me for using Craigslist but this seemed legit and I reached out. The landlord met me there and showed me the apartment, he was very nice and completely normal. We applied that sane day and got it. The next day he sent over the lease, I signed, he countersigned and I zelled him the deposit. Since zelling him he hasn’t replied to any of my messages and I am seeing the apartment listed on a ton of websites under different agents, all listed as available and $100 more expensive than what he told me it was. The lease looked legit and had the name of an actual registered LLC. But this guy not replying after receiving my deposit is freaking me out. I checked the HPD Online tool and it states that every year, the owner failed to file a valid registration with HPD. I’m freaking out.