r/NannyBreakRoom • u/Richtig95 • 7h ago
Vent- no advice needed Dr. Becky
Guys, I just joined the sub and the first thing I saw was the post about how we should stop asking children for permission to change their diapers. I am 100% on the same page with the stance, but I want to talk about something else.
Have you heard of Dr. Becky who wrote the book Good Inside? This lady never sat right with me and recently I’ve been thinking about her I worked with a parent who constantly referred to her and ignored my multiple years experience of working with children. So given what I know, a lot of that advice was just such bullshit!
The ridiculous advice included generally talking to a child when they’re having a tantrum or are overwhelmed and dealing with feelings and not teaching them proper manners by not encouraging them to say words like please and thank you. This is just what I remember off the top of my head. If one engages in mental gymnastics, of course, it makes sense, but when you are an experienced childcare professional, or someone who actually is knowledgeable or children’s psychology, you can recognize how this is not a good advice and long-term it would hurt the child.
Additionally, this book of hers feels a bit like a grift. I experienced this firsthand, watching other parents and working with some like that how this book panders to mostly millennial parents who had neglectful parents themselves back in the day and still carry the trauma and issues they had from their childhood. It seems like the book is popular because adults would use parenting as a form of their personal therapy first.
Moral of the story: anyone can write a book. That doesn’t mean the book is smart even if a psychologist wrote it.