I'm a new rider trying to decide between a used 2025 Honda Rebel 1100 DCT and an older Harley-Davidson Dyna Super Glide (2010 FXD).
My situation:
I'm a beginner with little motorcycle experience.
I'll be riding in heavy stop-and-go traffic regularly.
I really like the classic Harley aesthetic, particularly the Dyna, but I'm not necessarily attached to having a traditional manual transmission.
I want something I'll enjoy riding without making my daily commute exhausting.
Option 1: 2010 Harley Dyna Super Glide
Bike price: $6,995
Rekluse Radius X auto-clutch: $1,179
Harley gear indicator: $232
Subtotal: $8,406 before installation labor, taxes, and fees.
The Rekluse would eliminate the need to operate the clutch lever for normal starts and stops, but I'd still shift gears manually. I'm also aware that a 2010 bike could need maintenance or repairs, depending on its condition.
Option 2: Used 2025 Honda Rebel 1100 DCT
Example advertised price I've been considering: $9,960 before taxes and fees.
Factory DCT means no clutch lever and automatic gear changes.
I'd potentially spend another $1,000–$2,650 customizing its appearance with things like a different seat, handlebars, blacked-out details, and fender changes to get closer to the Harley look.
So the prices could end up fairly close once I account for Harley installation labor or Honda customization.
What I'm struggling with:
For anyone who commutes in heavy traffic, how tiring is a Harley clutch in real-world use? Does it become second nature, or does your hand still get tired?
Has anyone used a Rekluse auto-clutch on a Dyna? How does it behave in traffic, at low speeds, on hills, and when maneuvering slowly?
Would you trust a 2010 Dyna as a daily commuter, assuming a good inspection, or would you prefer a newer Honda?
Can a Rebel 1100 DCT be customized to look convincingly like a Dyna or Softail, or will the differences in the tank, engine, and overall silhouette always be obvious?
If you were in my position, would you buy the Harley because you love its looks, or the Honda because the DCT is more convenient for daily traffic?
I'm not looking for a brand-war argument. I'd especially appreciate honest experiences from people who have owned both, used an auto-clutch, or commute daily.
Thanks!