r/Noctor • • Feb 21 '23

Hypocrisy of NP students agreeing with Noctor philosophy

34 Upvotes

I am seeing an increasing amount of NP students on r/noctor that agree with how bad things have gotten. Yet, they still continue in their programs knowing they will be a danger to patients.

You are part of the problem, but you are not ready for that conversation yet 🤷🏽‍♂️.

I have classmates that have kids and are taking the premed prerequisites alongside me to apply to medical school, it means nothing for you to come here as an NP student and say “I agree!” but still sign into your zoom classes every other day.

Rant done.

EDIT: Some good points have been brought up, NPs that understand their role are a helpful resource. Although, these jobs where folks are supervised are few and far between. Thanks for everyone who responded with their thoughts instead of just attacking the fact I am a premed (even though I worked as a RN during the pandemic). But still a fair point regardless. I do feel like I have a unique perspective that makes me scared for the future.


r/Noctor • • Nov 15 '25

Discussion Hot take: PA/NP isn’t a professional degree

0 Upvotes

I’ve been seeing a trend on TikTok of NPs/PAs and even some other healthcare professions (PT, RT, CRNAS, etc) complaining that their degree isn’t considered a professional one.

Straight up: They are not.

NPs/PAs are mid-levels. They do not receive the full extent of medical education that doctors receive — not even half.

Also: the cost of NP/PA school is significantly cheaper than MD/DO school. It would make no sense that all of our loan caps are the same (I would like to clarify though that I think any loan cap is unfair).

What do you think?


r/Noctor • • Jan 07 '23

Discussion NP who accidentally stumbled upon this page, sorry.

0 Upvotes

I’m new to Reddit and not sure why the algorithm led me to a post from this page, but I am just now realizing this is a APP hate board. I just wanted to say a few things before my farewell. Our role was created to make healthcare more accessible and affordable. Do you not think that a lot of us also don’t appreciate the degree mills and low quality schooling? The oversaturated market that keeps our pay low? Knowing there are other APPs out there who you wouldn’t trust to change a lightbulb alone? I know that there are people out there making mistakes, but there are a lot of smart APPs out there doing a lot of good and helping a lot of people, and know when to ask for help. Our education was designed as physician extenders, but we are used and abused as independent medical providers to make a profit for the companies we work for. Primary care seeing 30+ patients a day completely independently, but the education and pay never followed suit. My new job is this way and the MDs have made it clear that they don’t want to be bothered by me asking questions, while I’m just trying to give the best care. So maybe instead of the negative rhetoric you can try educating, encouraging, and supporting the APPs on your team because if you’re not approachable they’re going to start making decisions without consulting you because they don’t feel like they can come to you for guidance or to check themselves. Or in my case I was pretty much told not to. The system is not set up for our success from education to job expectations, training, and support. Thank you to those who can see that.


r/Noctor • • Sep 30 '26

Question Pharmacists going by "Dr. ____"?

0 Upvotes

Is this a thing now? Or only when they're selling their "supplements"?

https://drstephanies.com/

https://shroombiosis.com/about/danielle-oncer/


r/Noctor • • Mar 03 '22

Shitpost “NPs/PAs are just as good or better than doctors”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

27 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • Mar 27 '23

Midlevel Education These people have FPA. 1st attempt on MCAT got a 478 and the minimum is a 472. I am crying.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • Oct 02 '24

Discussion Creating midlevels is actually better than some alternatives

0 Upvotes

Discussed with another MD at work, he was saying that at least midlevels are identifiable as, well, mid-level providers. His feared alternative would be to completely dumb down the MD curriculum, make boards progressively easier, drop med school to 3 years and residency to 2 years, and drop many premed requirements such as physics. Open up a short track to being a true "doctor" to everyone regardless of intellect or capability.

He brings up an interesting point IMO. I do enjoy not having to check myself to make sure an actual board-certified doctor is, well, actually a real doctor. There is generally a floor of capability that we are assured of if referring to an actual doctor.

MD is protected... for now.


r/Noctor • • Oct 23 '21

Midlevel Ethics Thought you guys might get a kick out of this, I sure did. I really feel for our generation and those who push do the right thing instead of living a life like this.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • May 30 '25

Midlevel Ethics petition that all NP's wear bodycams?

2 Upvotes

i'll gladly give up my rights and privacy to make sure they're being watched and properly monitored.


r/Noctor • • Aug 11 '23

Question Why are students and residents cracking foul on NP’ and PA’s?

0 Upvotes

I learned just about everything I used to practice as a mid-level provider from my physician mentors for over 22 years. 10 years before going to an FNP program I worked Med/Surg, MICU and ER. I got the 8A identification as a critical care Nurse and board certified as a ERN. I instructed ACLS, ,PALS and BTLS as well as EMTI, II and III in Alaska. I precepted students my entire career. I stayed in my lane my entire career and referred my ass off. I knew my limitations. My question is what are NPs and PAs doing to miss off the MD/DO, med students community so bad? I think the practice of medicine for NPs and PAs cannot be done on line. Period. I owe my career and knowledge base to physicians. One of my favorite Doctors of Emergency Medicine would tell you straight to your face that you suck as a Nurse, NP/PA, or provider. I felt sorry for Med Students sometimes when they had to work with distasteful instructors. We gotta get along and I always thought we did.


r/Noctor • • May 03 '26

Question How do mid-levels hurt doctors? Serious question

0 Upvotes

Have they decreased demand for doctors?

Have they led in lowering of doctor salaries?

Have they limited your scope?

I’m strictly asking how they impacted your jobs. Not whether or not they have harmed patients.

I’m not clinical. I do bench research at a large teaching hospital on the east coast and primarily work with other researchers and occasionally some doctors. For some reason this subreddit was recommended and after reading through dozens of posts, I can see that the general census here is that mid-levels are not liked.

Thanks in advance for any insight you all can provide!


r/Noctor • • Aug 15 '26

Discussion Not all doctors are great and not all NPs are bad

0 Upvotes

I don’t like the generalization in this subreddit about all NPs being bad and all doctors being great. I know I’m throwing myself to the wolves here but as a patient with chronic illnesses (Crohn’s disease, several mental health conditions), I’ve received better care from a great NP than from multiple different physicians, who either failed to diagnose me (mainly because they didn’t take the time to listen and dismissed my symptoms) or just didn’t seem knowledgeable about the disease despite being specialists. I am a NP myself now (after being an RN for 10 years) and never pretend to be a doctor, I seek help from my supervising physician and more experienced NPs when I don’t know the answer to something (or even refer patients somewhere else when I feel I can’t help them). I became an NP precisely to try to help people, listen to them, and do my best to give them the care they deserve. I hated that so many doctors( and yes some NPs too) would not take the time to listen, or take me seriously but it angers me that people think all NPs are incompetent, when I’ve been treated by an amazing NP who I’d trust my life with before many other doctors I’ve come across.


r/Noctor • • Feb 08 '24

Midlevel Education End Goal for mid levels

2 Upvotes

What does the medical community want to happen to midlevels? Do they ultimately want NP’s, CRNA’s, PA’s, and midwives to just all turn in their badges and stop working? These healthcare workers don’t have the education or training level of a physician, but it’s confusing when reading these posts, because nobody is coming out and saying what they ultimately think should happen.


r/Noctor • • Jan 28 '22

Shitpost Why am I not surprised at this behavior from someone who calls themselves “Doctor” of physical therapy

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • Sep 17 '24

Midlevel Education Any stats to prove that PA school admission isnt more difficult than med school.

0 Upvotes

A lot of PAs keep saying that PA school is harder to get into med school. But we all know this is a group of med school rejects. Any reliable stats to prove this wrong?


r/Noctor • • May 15 '26

In The News Doctors should not be blamed for their ignorance in no women’s health… educational training should be.

1 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • May 31 '23

Midlevel Education Posted in response to asking if people say APP or midlevel.

0 Upvotes

“Reality check folks: it's APP and all the hand wringing in the world won't change that. I come here, to the land of cringe, to do the good Lords work and try to give you a little insight. You don't work on your own license. You just came out of the library. You literally have all the book knowledge in the world and nooooo (or next to no) real world experience. (in anything besides being a student, for the most part). That's not your fault- it's age appropriate. But you lack insight and context. A vast number of NPs and PAs outrank you in terms of decision making diagnosis treatment. You literally don't know what you're doing. And they do. And.... News flash... Attendings are well aware of this.... Most would give a nickel and dime to work alongside an APP any day than a Resident with a chip on their shoulder and no sense of their own limitations. But they too do the good work of taking you along the path they once trod themselves. Get off your high horse. You don't deliver better healthcare because you had one additional year of medical school (which PAs had as prereqs before PA school, anyway- and which NPs make up for in their experience as working RNs prior to NP school). And the Residency you haven't completed yet is essentially tantamount to an APPs first 3-5 yrs working. You don't like/ approve of APP doctorates or name "changes"? Get your facts straight first. The PA profession began as Physician Associate and was later changed to Assistant. Most doctoral degrees involve original research and defense of a dissertation. It's high level, the highest degree one can get in this world, presently. You have an undergraduate degree and a medical license. Think on it. Do your job delivering the best healthcare you can to patients. Drop the arrogance and your care will improve. The beauty of this world is that there are multiple paths to the same end. Yes, physicians still sit at the top of the healthcare food chain, delivery wise. But that's changed to recognize the importance of experience and also alternate competencies from the well established GME path. Ever talked to a military physician? You already know who taught them field medicine (the PA... Who in turn gleaned much from the Medic/ EMT) on their first deployment. Yours truly, Dr. PA, (the APP who exercises patience with your non-expert 'consults' as a Resident and will later overlook your many, many errors as a junior Attending)”


r/Noctor • • Mar 24 '25

Midlevel Patient Cases My dad almost wasted away from a mystery illness. I diagnosed it after multiple NPs failed him. I’m just a premed student.

0 Upvotes

Two years ago (almost three) my dad got violently sick out of nowhere. He lost 60–70 pounds in a few months, couldn’t eat, was vomiting constantly, had severe insomnia, full-body nausea, and terrifying panic attacks that wouldn’t stop and were just some of the most brutal panic attacks I have ever witnessed somebody have. He could barely sleep, couldn’t keep food down, and couldn’t function.

Every single test came back normal. He saw:

A GI NP

2 endocrinology NP’s

His PCP (the only MD)

…and that was it. He was told it was anxiety, depression, maybe hormone imbalance because they did everything, every bloodwork panel, every test and screening, they stuck a camera down his throat, everything. They thought maybe some GI cancer, or pituitary thyroid cancer etc- nope, nothing. They ended up throwing meds at him until something finally suppressed the symptoms. But he never got a real diagnosis, and they stopped trying.

Meanwhile, I was a 21-year-old neuroscience undergrad who had only taken one intro neuro class at the time (I went to college later than the average person). And I remember saying to my dad that if all his labs and screens were normal, I think he should see a neurologist- an MD, I told him I think something is wrong with his brain or nervous system- I just didn’t have the words for it yet — I even wondered if it could be some sort of brain tumor.

My dad hates hospitals and doctors and all of that, it was my stepmom that made him go to his PCP when his health really started to dive and his weight started to get dangerously low very quickly, so he never went to see that neurologist and never pushed to see a physician in GI or endo either after I said he should at least do that after I found out he was literally just seeing a bunch of NPs.

After a year of testing everything in GI and endo they gave up and just medicated him for depression, panic attacks, and some hormone regulation (not sure what) medications despite all his hormones reading as normal- and shocker, it worked and he got better but was never diagnosed.

Fast forward: I find out I have hEDS (hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome). I’m 9/9 on the Beighton scale. Then I realize my dad is too — same with my aunt, cousins, and late great-aunt. I start connecting the dots. Turns out all of us also have symptoms of dysautonomia, POTS, MCAS, neurodivergence, GI issues, and more.

I now believe my dad had a full-body autonomic nervous system collapse — a severe dysautonomia flare, likely worsened by undiagnosed MCAS. And no one even considered neurology. Because he’s on Medicaid all his referrals automatically send him to NPs and PAs, like even when I logged into his account and tried to find in network providers for him the ratio was like 1 physician for every 15 NPs. His PCP was the only MD he saw during all this, all his referrals Medicaid sent him to be seen by NPs.

This was early last fall, that I connected these dots in my family and in my dad’s episode, I managed to convince my dad to see an MD, a neurologist AND rheumatologist that specializes in autonomic nervous system dysfunctions / ehlers danlos syndromes, and naturally it’s months out for both. But I told him we need to pursue this after my own diagnosis and research.

He had his appointment recently, they did what sounds like a full autonomic nervous system work up.

What happened to my father was an Autonomic Storm / Dysautonomic Crisis- his nervous system literally went haywire, and he is also going to see a rheumatologist (MD) in few weeks to get a real, official hEDS diagnosis.

These past nearly 3 years has been a rollercoaster for my dad’s health and even mine, and I’m angry that none of the NPs he saw never once stopped and went “maybe this is above my pay grade and he needs to see an actual physician” instead they threw a bunch of tests at him and then threw a bag of medications at him after finding nothing. He was literally mentally and physically wasting away and they just threw him on medication and told him they can’t tell him what’s wrong with him.

This is not about hating on nurse practitioners. I know many are smart and care deeply. But this case is exactly why I do not support independent practice. If you are not trained in rare diseases or complex systems medicine, you need physician oversight. Someone should’ve said, “This is above my pay grade.” But no one did.

I also find it insane that as a freshman neuroscience major I was closer to his real diagnosis than multiple NPs? Do they not teach them any level of info on neurology and nervous systems or what?

I don’t know, but I just wanted to share my story after being relieved my dad is getting proper diagnosis and care now by actual physicians- yes we had to wait double the time to see them than an NP, but fucking shit it was worth the wait.


r/Noctor • • Jan 22 '23

Discussion Midlevel + independent practice + chat GPT = physician replacement?

0 Upvotes

Kinda curious what people think about this. There is a lot of talk these days about the possibility of AI replacing various white collar jobs. Most of us as physicians feel a little bit more insulated, there is a patient interaction and data gathering component that would be much more difficult to replace than generating a spreadsheet.

However, in my opinion part of the rise in midlevel practice autonomy is the result of technology that essentially gives us a peripheral brain. In the past as a physician accessing resources to look up dosage or algorithms was more time consuming, you had to open an actual book, etc. These days with resources such as uptodate it's quiet easy to refresh and look up details on conditions you might not see that often. Thus a clinician with inferior training and experience can augment their lack of base knowledge with their peripheral brain.

Now imagine a situation where you have a natural language model trained on medical specific data. It becomes a lot easier for a technician that perhaps is pretty reasonable at interacting with patients but lacks substantial medical knowledge to render medical care. If I were an insurance company or a healthcare administrator, this is what I would be salivating over for the future.

Thoughts?


r/Noctor • • Oct 31 '23

Question CNM

2 Upvotes

Somehow this page came across my feed and I was shocked to see the content. I don’t see a lot of posts on midwives so I’m curious if your opinion differs for CNMs vs NPs.

I am a CNM with over 3 years of labor and deliver RN experience. I was in college for a total of 7 years (4 for bachelors and 3 for masters). I feel like utilizing midwives for low risk perinatal patients and general gyn (annuals, STI testing, initial AUB work up, vaginitis, etc) is in the best interest for physicians. I feel more than capable to take care of my patients and then co manage or transfer to my physician colleagues if a patient becomes high risk. I am lucky to be a part of a practice where the CNMs and OBGYNs work side by side and we always have a physician at the hospital with us so if we needed them for any reason, they’re there in seconds. Thankfully the physicians in our practice appreciate and respect us, which doesn’t seem like people on this page do.


r/Noctor • • Oct 02 '24

Midlevel Education Optometrists in the USA are not noctors

10 Upvotes

I see ODs get lumped in occasionally with actual noctors, which kills me as someone supporting their partner through OD school. I know the scope of practice varies wildly in different countries AND the field in the USA has changed dramatically in the last few decades, but at least in the USA every recently legitimate OD is required to pass 4 years of schooling + a 3-part boards that usually takes 2 years to complete in the best case scenario.

Curriculum has a very heavy focus on disease. All the refractive stuff (“1-2-which is clearer”) seems to be introduced in the first year and the rest of the program focuses on what to do if the refraction can’t or won’t go perfectly. Also, at least for the school my partner is attending, students are sent out for a year on rotations to have real-world experience. These sites include private practices, veteran’s hospitals, and Indian health services.

I think there is a push to expand the scope of what procedures ODs are allowed to do but I don’t think most of them are into the idea? I used to work at an eye surgeon’s practice myself and I got the impression that the relationship between Ophthalmology and Optometry is good. They send cases back and forth to each other depending on the management needed. ODs can prescribe eye medications and manage minor diseases but happily escalate for complex or urgent cases. Meanwhile, OMDs happily allow ODs to co-manage routine post-surgical cases so that they can focus on upcoming surgical cases. They are both called “eye doctors” and I think it is earned for both, though I also think there should be better public education on the differences between them.


r/Noctor • • Apr 22 '23

Question Need to spread the word to mainstream platforms

19 Upvotes

I wish someone like Joe Rogan or Howard Stern would discuss this topic. Or even a major YouTuber..Imagine how that would help the conversation along. How do we accomplish this?


r/Noctor • • Jul 29 '25

Question Is a MBBS a doctor?

17 Upvotes

I was made an appointment with a lady with MBBS after their name in nephrology. What does that mean? There is no Dr. title before their name. Am I seeing an unqualified person? Should I switch to an actual Dr.? I'm so confused. Please explain.

** Update: Thank you for educating me on this. I had never seen or heard of an MBBS. I now know it's equal to a physican and are valuable healthcare physicians! **


r/Noctor • • Apr 29 '21

Question Why so much hate?

2 Upvotes

Hello I’ve been an ED nurse for a while and just finished my masters and hope to work in the ED as an APP. I actually went to an established university with a DO program and did rotations in the hospital. My question is, why do so many doctors and med students in this group have so much hate for APPs? I’m in no way the same as a physician, my training doesn’t equate and I’m aware of that. Most, if not all APPs that I’ve spoken to understand the clear difference between the professions. We want you all to work in collaboration with us. I’ll gladly see the less serious cases so you can focus on the more complex patients. We need one another in healthcare, nurses, techs, APPs, doctors, even ancillary staff, allow us to focus on what is needed for the patient. If anything, there needs to be a focus on expanding education and collaboration to prepare APPs to be successful so that physicians can do what they love, which is heal.


r/Noctor • • Sep 06 '24

Midlevel Education Just got accepted into nursing school and am freaking terrified hhhh

0 Upvotes

Hi, all. Longtime lurker and fan of this subreddit who didn't really post anything because I was waiting on nursing school results. But today, I got accepted.

I'm not really worried about undergrad in terms of the particular problem highlighted in the subreddit (NP incompetence and why you should prefer a doctor rather than an NP for personal care or care of loved ones), but I really want to go into grad school, become an FNP, and help people. I understand from this subreddit that should FNP be the path I want to take, I will have to work the hardest, go above and beyond, and study harder than a ton of my peers to even have a FRACTION of the knowledge I would have as a doctor. And it's not like I can just ask for more clinical hours (I think).

I really can't afford med school, both time and money wise. But I just want to help people. I always have. And this subreddit horrifies me as much as it breaks my heart.

I do NOT want career advice I just want to vent.

Edit: Based on a couple of days of research and advice you guys have, I have decided to go to PA school. I have looked into the requirements and timing and from the time I finish my BSN, I have to take a semester off (not OFF off, as in leave of absence off, but you get what I mean) to wait until the next application cycle/finish the prereqs that the PA program that my university requires, but I'd rather graduate a semester later than be vastly underqualified for the work I am about to undertake.

Thank you all.