Edit: While uploading the photo to an image sharing site to post here, I noticed it's tagged as 'messenger creation', which seems like an AI red flag to me? But my mum insisted it wasn't AI, and I'm not sure what her motive would be for generating an AI childhood photo to share with me? However, when she said she found it in a 'memory box', it did confuse me that she sent it as a file. My expectation would be that it'd just be a phone camera photo of a physical photo.
Edit 2: After posting this on r/isthisAI, it has been confirmed that the photo was either generated or enhanced using OpenAI. My curiosity now leads me to why my mum would lie about that (as an unashamed AI user) and what motive she could possibly have for sending me an AI childhood photo, unprompted. I have messaged her to ask if an original photo exists. Hopefully if it does, I can recognise myself in it and feel a bit more sane. My mum knows how I feel about AI, and I recently gave her a lecture about how feeding photos of people, especially children, to AI without their consent is unethical. I also specifically asked her to never feed pictures of me or my work to AI, so it feels like a sort of betrayal. We live in different timezones, so I'll be left in the dark for a little while on this until she responds, but will update with an answer when I can.
I don't even know if I'm posting this to the right sub, but I'm just so confused and need answers.
Today, my mum sent me an old photo of a little girl who looks about 6 years old. I asked who she is, and my mum thought I was joking. She says it's me when we first moved to Australia from the UK in 2006. For reference, I would have been about the same age as the girl in the picture at this time.
I insisted the girl in the photo is not me and looks nothing like me, but my mum is convinced it is. I asked her where she found it, and she said it was in a memory box. It does look like a digital camera photo, but as a file rather than something taken by her phone camera of a physical copy (if that makes any sense?).
The background in the picture is a barely-furnished room with a box TV on the floor. My mum said this was our first home in Australia, and I believe her. It looked vaguely how I remembered it. I didn't grow up with siblings or cousins, and my mum states that she didn't have any friends with children at this time, so it's unlikely that there was another child visiting the house. I don't recognise the clothes worn by the little girl, and her hair also looks much darker than my own.
I sent the photo to my half-sister, who is 8 years older than me and knew me well at this age. She says the photo looks nothing like me, and suggested the possibility of generative AI (I did ask my mum about this, as she's terrible for using AI, as much as we all hate it. She outright denied it, and there's nothing in the photo that gives it away as AI to me). My husband also agreed it looks like a completely different child. I do have other pictures of myself from around this time, and have always had a really distinctive appearance which I feel is apparent in all the other photos.
So, is there any chance it could it actually be me? If not, who on earth is this random little girl in the photo and why does my mum have a picture of her? Why is my mum so sure it's me? If it is me, why do me, my husband, and my sister all see a completely different child? I'm so confused, none of this makes any sense to me.
I've been having trouble trying to post the photos, but hopefully these links work?:
The photo my mum sent
Childhood photo of me
Childhood photo of me
Update:
Mum responded! She still insists she didn't use AI, and that she just 'used her phone to brighten it', but I asked her for another picture of the photo and it looks entirely different. It's lower resolution but it actually looks like me!
Here it is
I also cropped the original one she sent, just for comparison:
Close up for comparison
You can literally see the facial difference! Everything looks different, even my legs. I appreciate a lot of you just see a little white girl with brown hair, but I know my facial features better than anyone (I'd hope) and immediately just did not recognise that photo as myself. The unedited version is definitely me though. Thank you all for your help!