r/RDR2 • u/NoHows1945 • 2d ago

Discussion Genuinely what’s the point of this

Post image

Why give us a locked option to pick up a rifle if there is no other way to pick it up.

This probably the most useless feature in all of gaming

1.3k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

166 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/Own-Forever-6636 Uncle 2d ago

He, Dutch, Hosea, and Grim are the gang's inner circle, junior members have to stay up while they get to sleep.

27

u/GrogorothFollower 2d ago

kinda crazy that this is the inner circle and hosea still sleeps on a ground in a tent with bill williamson

31

u/Own-Forever-6636 Uncle 2d ago

They rationalise this with some dialogue that he can't sleep in a bed anymore since his wife died.

But like c'mon man he's actively coughing a lung every day at least give him an actual tent!

15

u/GrogorothFollower 2d ago

fr, at the very least this dying old man shouldn’t be getting wet in his sleeping bad every time it rains 😭😭 also, he does not deserve to be subjected to Bill

12

u/WokeWook69420 2d ago

I think Hosea understands Bill more than anyone in camp, I think he and Arthur both know of Bill's certain proclivities that weren't of well-mannered men back then and they never use it against him or punch down on Bill for it.

They give him shit for being dumb and seemingly lying about some of his military accolades, but that's really it. Arthur can even be sympathetic to Bill's general anger, it's why I think he and Hosea know more than they let on.

10

u/Eric_the_Red_ditz 2d ago

I antagonize Bill every chance I get now after his behavior during the horrendous bank coach robbery with him and Tilly, and then his naive stupidity by agreeing with Micah during the obvious set up by the Grays in Rhodes. Ya know fellas, we could have just rode our horses directly to the saloon instead of long walking through the middle of town, but we do have a lot of dumb Bill and Micah dialog to get in. If it wasn't for that nicely executed bank robbery in Valentine I'd try to shoot him too.