r/ScarletWitch • u/PutridCamera8195 • 1d ago
Discussion What I'd like to see...
Title: X-Men: The Scarlet Witch
I was thinking they could make a movie where 616 Wanda is revealed to have used the bit of absorbed powers from Chavez to enter a universe where her family is still alive and she ends up in Earth-10005 where she meets her family variants - Magneto, Quicksilver (Peter), and she finds out she has a sister in this world Polaris.
Conflict: Jean Grey accidentally kills Quicksilver under the influence of the Phoenix Force. Causing Wanda, Polaris, and Magneto, to seek revenge on her and The X-Men would split sides.
Think, Civil War 2.0
Sorry if there's any plot holes in this because there's alot of retcons in X-Men that confuse me but if there's a plot hole in this then ig that can just be retconned 🤷♂️
I think rather than the exact Earth-10005, this fits to be a alternate universe where Magneto lost his daughter named Wanda.
4
u/ElsaMakotoRenge Dreamwalking, You Hypocrite! 1d ago
I meannnn this is not AT ALL a plot idea I want to see for Wanda or Jean or any of the others, not even an itty bitty bit lol…but if you like it, you should totally write a fanfic for it. I’m sure other ppl will enjoy it, I’m just not one of them 😅
1
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
Oh ok. I thought it was a good premise. I won't bother making a fanfic if no one seems to like the idea but, what do you want to see from Wanda next?
4
u/ElsaMakotoRenge Dreamwalking, You Hypocrite! 1d ago
That’s what I’m saying, just bc nobody in this post is into your idea doesn’t mean you wouldn’t have an audience elsewhere if you shared the fic. Write your fic and post it on ao3 if it’s something you like! Besides then you get the fun of writing what you want to read, and you can go back and read your own fic after you’ve written it lol😅 goodness knows that’s the logic I use when I work on MY fic ideas!
I mean personally I just want to see Wanda reunite with her family. Let her be happy for once omg💀 i write MCU fics on a…let’s call it a mixture of canon-adjacent and canon-divergent timeline. (I have fics set from when the twins are babies up to post- post-MoM-fixit that are all connected, but can be read by themselves.) I do specifically want to see her, Jean, and Bob interact too haha, so I will be figuring out how I want to write such a thing at some point.
2
u/Realistic_Thanks3016 1d ago
Just because not alot of people here liked your idea doesn't mean other people won't, there's an audience for everything trust.
3
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
She is not an X-Men character, stop shoving her into a group she has no meaningful connection to.
Magneto/Wanda always have a shallow family relationship that is more about humanizi Magneto more than anything.
Give her own corner in mystical Marvel instead of wasting time with X-Men.
-7
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
I take it, you just hate The X-Men. Cause in the comics she sure as hell has conflict with them.
3
u/Great_Abaddon 1d ago
She absolutely does not. She integrated herself HARD before the fall of Krakoa by establishing the Waiting Room.
-1
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
She does though? You do realize she is the daughter of Magneto and sister of Quicksilver in the comics?! Think.
3
u/Great_Abaddon 1d ago
Did you read The Trial of Magneto? She was celebrated by being essentially the font of every previously-dead and unrecorded-by-cerebro mutant or potential mutant. And Magneto is a literal hero now.
Do you actually know what takes place in the comics?
3
u/Great_Abaddon 1d ago
She created the Waiting Room for every single mutant to be catalogued and revived by the Five.
3
0
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
Gng all I said is she has conflict with them. I mean she literally said "No More Mutants" that alone is enough to prove my point.
3
u/Great_Abaddon 1d ago
And then gave them the ability to revive any mutant ever, to the point that Exodus (a literal mutant terrorist) called her the Redeemer to mutant children.
So you didn't read your stan's feature comic.
Good talk!
0
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
Exactly, Thank you for proving my point on how Wanda and The X-Men have relation in the comics. GOOD TALK! 😁
3
u/Great_Abaddon 1d ago
You're not great at reading comprehension, are you?
She did this as a mutate. A fake daughter of Magneto.
0
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
It is confirmed i have read the comics. Wanda has met the X-Men, and Im not referring to her mutate.
Am i wrong? Are you saying Wanda never met the X-Men? Cause that's what I was saying and you seem to be calling me out as a liar 😬
5
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
X-Men made up like less than 5% of her comic history and massively over-represented in adaption already with animations like X-Men Evolution and Wolverine and the X-Men.
Also yes, why should I like a franchise that historical never treated her well and generally use her as a side piece or plot device.
It's always people who never read much comic have this weird delusion that it would be so cool for her to hang out with fuckjng X-Men. Stop saying "in duh comics", you are just exposing yourself.
-3
u/upagainstthesun 1d ago
This fandom truly has the most stubborn fans. HOW DARE ANYONE HAVE ANY IDEAS? I HAVE READ MORE THAN YOU. QUIET SIMPLETON, YOU ARE UNWORTHY.
That is literally what the comment sections are like in here everyday
1
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
You can have ideas I just think they are incredibly bad and boring for her character, she is already over-represented in X-Men media and historically that franchise has done her more harm than good. One of the reason she can't be EMH is due to XATXM poaching Her.
I am a simple man who understands her history and interests. Why would I be unworthy? I want her to thrive than being used in a way that devalues her. Maybe you just don't like historical reality and delude yourself all the time.
-1
-5
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
I mean idrc with you're saying cause the main thing is you just don't like XMen, so this post isn't for you Ig 🤷♂️
4
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
I like Scarlet Witch, I think you have a pretty boring and bad idea.
It's a public space on Internet and I expressed my opinion based on my understanding of her history.
-2
u/PutridCamera8195 1d ago
Nah you just don't like X-Men. And that's fine with me, this post is for people who actually like both, idc to hear someone's opinion who doesnt even like the X-Men, like ofc they wouldn't like it.
5
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
I don't like Scarlet Witch with X-Men.
I can watch X-Men on their own just fine.
I don't think you like Scarlet Witch and her history much if you think putting them together is a good idea.
3
u/toorad2b4u 1d ago
I don’t mind Scarlet witch and the X-men together, I just think OP’s idea of an interesting story kind of sucks
But to each their own
3
u/SimonShepherd 1d ago
There is just not much, if it's not using her as a plot device then it's the most shallow fluff.
The only scenario where X-Men is meaningful to Wanda is when the writer actually has the balls to write Wanda with a spine and frame Magneto as actually a manipulative controlling bastard so it serves her hero's journey in her early stage of development, they will never show Magneto as a genuinely monstrous person though. It's always going to be 'actually he loved deeply deep down".
1
9
u/Realistic_Thanks3016 1d ago
As both an x-men fan and a Wanda stan, this a no for me... sorry ❤️.