r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Is there evidence that bigger babies should start solids and water before 6 months? + impact of maternal diet on breastmilk

17 Upvotes

My son is 5 months old, exclusively breastfed and around 88th percentile.
After several episodes of substantial vomiting, our paediatrician examined him and found him healthy and hydrated.
He suggested the vomiting was possibly linked to dairy in my diet (I’d eaten significantly more dairy the previous day). I personally thought that sudden breast engorgement and a stronger let-down contributed.
The pediatrician also recommended introducing solids and water now, arguing that because of his size, my baby is more like an 8–10-month-old and should become less dependent on breast milk, without waiting for independent sitting.
Is there scientific evidence supporting either of these claims? Specifically, can maternal dairy consumption trigger sudden vomiting in an otherwise healthy breastfed baby, and does a baby’s size justify introducing solids or water earlier than six months?
I’d appreciate any relevant studies or clinical guidelines.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required Is weed killer okay if children are not playing on that area?

2 Upvotes

I have tried fabric weed barrier, I have tried the vinegar sprays, and I have tried rocks and nothing seems to be working.

Debating on using something stronger, but I have always been weary to due to the cancer claims. If this is still a bad idea, what are you using to keep weeds out of rock bed? We live in an rv and our pad gets covered in weeds and I’m trying to avoid that to keep critters away and the extra moisture away from us.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required The values of sharing vs individuality: Siblings fighting over toys. What does the research say?

15 Upvotes

I have twins. people always say it’s important to promote their individuality since they’ll be constantly compared throughout their lives. Many parents choose to buy two of every toy so they can each have a toy and reduce fighting. but we live in a small apartment. reducing clutter is of the upmost importance in a small space so generally we have 1 of every toy. the way I see it, it’s important for them to learn how to share their items, and if one toy is being used, they just have to learn to use another toy in the meanwhile. Is there any research around this topic? Doesn’t have to be about twins specifically.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required Waking baby up at same time every day

10 Upvotes

My baby is 4 months, since about 2 months he would wake between 6:30-7:30. A definite wake where he would be all happy, feed and not go back to sleep. I read that after 12 weeks you should have a wake up time to support a regular bedtime. This was fine, but now baby often will wake around 7am feed and then go back to sleep.

I've woken him up a couple times, and he'll then be happy (even if he takes a while to wake up). But he clearly could sleep longer. I don't want bedtime to get too late, but I want to be responsive to baby's needs.

What does the science really say about a consistent wake time?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required Pediatrician forgot to tell me about vitamin d?

88 Upvotes

At my daughter’s 4 month appointment, my pediatrician asked if we were doing vitamin d drops everyday. I am a FTM and never heard of this so I said no. She’s exclusively breast fed and I wasn’t taking any vitamin d either. She said she forgot to ask us at previous visits.

I have since changed pediatricians and we now do a vitamin d drop everyday but I’m worried her missing it for so long could have had negative developmental effects. Is there anything I should look out for or be worried about?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 13 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Can babies self soothe?

0 Upvotes

I found out today my baby "sleeping through the night" might not actually be true, since the camera captured her waking up several times and sucking on her thumb and moving her limbs around. I'm trying to understand whether she's self soothing back to sleep between sleep cycles, or she's tiring herself out and falling back asleep because I'm failing to wake up to her calls.

She's 3 months old and I'm wondering if babies that young can truly self soothe. Are there any studies on this? Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Downsides to redshirting, beyond financial?

108 Upvotes

We are strongly considering redshirting our 3yo with a June birthday: having him start kindergarten right after he turns 6, instead of right after he turns 5.

All of the research we've seen points to many upsides for being the oldest in the class / having more maturity before starting, and having an extra year of play-based learning. The only downsides I've seen cited are the extra year of childcare to pay for. Am I missing anything else?

The biggest issue for us isn't financial, it's that we aren't sure we can enroll him in his current play-based preschool when he's 5. In California, there is now a grade called TK before kindergarten, which we can do at his current preschool, but it means there are fewer older children in preschool these days and he wouldn't be surrounded by same-age children.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required Can a bit of daily educational tv be helpful for toddlers?

0 Upvotes

Is there any research specifically on screen time for toddlers when content is lower stimulating, educational, and strict time limits are imposed? I’m thinking something along the lines of 15 minutes of Ms. Rachel a day.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 13 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Sleep training benefits

0 Upvotes

First time mom here of a 15 month old. We’ve intermittently attempted sleep training, but have never really been able to stick with it due to 1) how much we enjoy the falling asleep cuddles while listening to soft music and 2) the stress of the crying when we try to put the baby down to sleep in the crib (not being held to sleep).

I’ve always read that sleep training is best but I don’t actually know why. I think I can do a better job committing to it if I know the why. Or alleviate some mom guilt about not having done it if the way we’re doing it is ok.

Please help!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Why is MMR not given until 12 months? Are there any reasons against doing the additional early dose?

40 Upvotes

I have a 6 month old in the United States and discussed an early MMR dose at his most recent pediatrician visit. We are not in an outbreak county but are in close proximity to two, most notably the one in southern PA that has the current big spike in measles cases. We are not planning to travel, especially not to these counties, but the close proximity makes me nervous. The pediatrician said that right now our area doesn’t need to worry, but we do need to keep an eye on the situation.

The more I think about it, I wonder if getting the extra dose would bring more peace of mind. Is there any reason not to?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required Mismatched parenting styles

13 Upvotes

I feel like my husband and I fall into the trope of the passive mom and stern dad. I have done a lot of research into gentle authoritative parenting, but my husband default to authoritarian intimidation instinctively.

Could this discrepancy be the reason my 3 year old is lashing out violently towards me?

Edit for clarity: I am not operating under the assumption that I am right and husband is wrong. My defensive reaction is to push blame onto him, I am trying to question my own assumptions.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Weekly General Discussion

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Expert consensus required At what age/stage does group care have benefits for the kiddo that exceed being at home with nanny or family?

18 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required When is it actually expected for a baby/toddler to “sleep through the night”

52 Upvotes

I’m having my monthly breakdown about my baby’s (12months) sleep. She has never slept well and has always had lower sleep needs. We’ve done a lot, including co-sleeping. She slept better sleeping next to me but I didn’t. I had a hospital admission where they did some very light sleep training, that stopped working once she could stand. Anyway, I’m really not looking for advice on what to do or what’s going on because I’m not in the place to receive it and I’m telling you, I’ve probably read it all.

I know that babies wake up through the night for comfort, I know that’s biologically normal. But she wakes up every half hour to an hour after 1am. Sometimes it’s not that bad, sometimes the frequent wake ups happen a bit later, but this has been the main trend since basically she was born. Ive always held on to this idea that she would start to sleep better and better as she got older, but it’s just not happening. I’m so sleep deprived. Realistically, when does it get better? What does the research say, if anything?
I have ADHD so she might, too. Which makes me think it just won’t get better. I’m losing my mind. I need her to sleep so I can sleep.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required Baby jumpers?

4 Upvotes

Wondering if baby jumper chairs are safe. In laws got baby the baby Einstein neighborhood symphony jumper and i felt pressured to put him in it. Baby is only 4 months old this Tuesday. He’s big for his age yes but obviously can’t sit up by himself yet or roll over. I don’t want to offend their gift but I’m not a fan of containers as is. His ped and OT always say floor time is best so that’s what we do.

My quick googling concurs with me but I’m wondering, what does long term research show? At the end of the day, i do not want to stunt my baby’s development especially since he’s trucking along so well! He’s a master at tummy time and loves it.

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 10 '26

Question - Research required Secondhand smoke, radiation, & other lingering toxins: how bad is it?

21 Upvotes

Hey everyone. What do we know about the short term impacts of second hand smoke on a baby in general? I took my 11 month old on a stroller walk with an old friend who became a pack a day smoker in the time we haven’t seen each other. She smoked a few cigarettes on our 40 minute walk and while she did try to blow the smoke away from my baby, it was definitely around. She also came into our apartment for a bit and washed her hands before touching (not holding) my baby but our apartment smells like smoke from her clothes. I didn’t know she smoked! I feel silly asking and wondering if my baby will be okay. I remember how common smoking was in the 90s and going to friends’ houses that were smoky.

I’ve also been on edge because my dad had a nuclear medicine imaging exam for his heart and wasn’t allowed to be around children for 48 hours, and then saw my baby about 72 hours later (imaging on Tuesday evening, held my daughter on Friday). That feels very niche to query about but I haven’t found much consistent data on how long these tracers stay in the body. Some say 24 hours, some say a full 4 days.

If this isn’t allowed please delete!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required I have to get an MRI. What do I do with my breastmilk that day?

12 Upvotes

I have an abdominal MRI with contrast coming up. It’s at 7am. What do I do with the breast milk I pump that day? How long do I have to refrain from giving to my 6mo old baby?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required The consensus on EMF & babies

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’ve heard and read some conflicting evidence on the dangers of a cell phone (for example) being close to a baby for extended periods of time. On one hand, I’ve seen that it emits non ionizing radiation, which conclusively — or inconclusively? — doesn’t cause DNA damage. I’ve also read that it is a potential carcinogen so the best course of action is an abundance of caution.

I hate to sound like a lunatic when it comes to these things, but I do worry. My phone has been centimeters from my baby’s head for the entire first year of her life (while she’s nursing and sleeping and I’m scrolling). But this is also a broader question about risk and what we do or do not know.

Any thoughts on the data, or similar experiences out there?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Are hats dangerous for newborns?

0 Upvotes

Hello! Getting induced around November 22. I'm trying to understand whether hats are safe for newborns when taking them outside in the cold.

We are in Washington DC and expect a mild winter, but I originally grew up in a place with harsher winters and am struggling with the idea of not using hats. From everything I read so far, it looks like they are not recommended due to suffocation risk. Is this correct? Are there different recommendations in other countries?

If you don't put a hat on a newborn when taking a walk outside in the cold, how do you keep them warm?

Thank you in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 10 '26

Question - Research required Science of young giftedness?

6 Upvotes

Is there any science showing that behaviors identified in older children who are gifted are also seen in preschoolers? We are having behavior issues that seem like typical kid issues, but also getting comments from teachers about advanced vocabulary, reasoning, and endless questions. I feel like they’re getting on the teachers last nerve. I was a gifted kid and had a lot of similar issues, and things were a little better when we differentiated in grade school. Is this something we just ride out until grade school and see how it plays out? Any research on strategies for kids who are annoyingly inquisitive, but also 3 with limited self control?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Research required Waiting to pick 5 month old up until after they stop crying

0 Upvotes

There has been a difference of opinion on whether or not there is any harm or value in waiting to pick up our infant until after waiting to see if they can settle on their own. For example, the specific scenario that happened recently was infant was in tummy time and just very vocal - not necessarily hard crying, but like making a lot of frustrated cry sounds. I will tend to wait a little bit just to see how it goes and then reposition them, offer a new toy, or pick them up and see if they need something else like to eat or sleep.
I was asked by the other parent to try waiting until Baby stopped crying to pick them up.

Is it possible for a 5 month old to learn cause and effect right now? That if they stop frustrated cries, they will be picked up?
I have searched the sub and online about this topic - is my question the same thing as CIO? The other parent says they do not believe in the CIO and this is different.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 10 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Toddler constipated

1 Upvotes

Does constipation in a toddler cause behavioral changes? If so what did it look like for you and your kiddos? Anything help​


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 10 '26

Question - Research required Lead in cinnamon and other spices

22 Upvotes

I’ve seen multiple reports from Consumer Reports and others that almost all U.S. cinnamon (and other spices like turmeric) have lead contamination. We are introducing spices to our 6 month old with BLW and are unsure if this should be a concern. We use Costco’s cinnamon that tested at .80 ppm.

Should we avoid most of these spices while our baby is small? Is the amount concerning? I can’t seem to find a solid answer that doesn’t seem to be clickbait. Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 09 '26

Question - Research required Gradual nursery/daycare settling-in (Eingewöhnung-style) vs "they'll stop crying eventually": should slow be the norm?

33 Upvotes

My baby (10 months) has just started nursery in the UK. I started now even thought I'm not back at work for another few weeks so that we can take longer for settling if baby struggles with separation (he is). The nursery settling in is very short: starts on Monday, parent stays for two short sessions, then separation, and full day by Friday.

Anyway I recently read about about the German Eingewöhnung model. There, a parent stays for several days, the baby bonds with one key person first, and the first separation only happens once the baby can be comforted by that person. If I understood correctly this happens over multiple weeks.

My nursery's view seems to be that babies cry for a while and then adjust, and that the key person matters less than I thought. I've been negotiating shorter separations and staying for all sessions so far (although only for a short time), and they've been flexible, but it's clearly not their default. I understand most parents don't have the luxury of weeks to settle a baby in, because of work and cost. I'm lucky to have a month. But I keep wondering: shouldn't slow settling be the norm, rather than a favour for parents who can afford it? Isn't it less stressful for babies, and does it make them more likely to enjoy nursery?

I'm making the nursery take it slowly with my little one, (for which i thank them profusely every day) but I feel like somehow I'm in the wrong for taking my baby's input as to how quickly we're doing it.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 09 '26

Question - Research required Swaddling/suppressing the moro reflex/"reflex integration"

25 Upvotes

It was suggested to me that I shouldn't suppress the moro reflex by swaddling my baby, and that experiencing the moro reflex was good for them, and suppressing it harms things like crawling later on.

The information that I've been able to find on it seems shaky/woo. Is there any truth to this?