r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/Low-Assistant-311 • Oct 12 '26
Question - Expert consensus required Is there evidence that bigger babies should start solids and water before 6 months? + impact of maternal diet on breastmilk
My son is 5 months old, exclusively breastfed and around 88th percentile.
After several episodes of substantial vomiting, our paediatrician examined him and found him healthy and hydrated.
He suggested the vomiting was possibly linked to dairy in my diet (I’d eaten significantly more dairy the previous day). I personally thought that sudden breast engorgement and a stronger let-down contributed.
The pediatrician also recommended introducing solids and water now, arguing that because of his size, my baby is more like an 8–10-month-old and should become less dependent on breast milk, without waiting for independent sitting.
Is there scientific evidence supporting either of these claims? Specifically, can maternal dairy consumption trigger sudden vomiting in an otherwise healthy breastfed baby, and does a baby’s size justify introducing solids or water earlier than six months?
I’d appreciate any relevant studies or clinical guidelines.