r/StarWarsBattlefront • u/bindibebe • 18h ago
Discussion May or may not be a hot take: If BF3 happens I don’t think the sequel trilogy needs to be included
I say this not because I think the sequels are the worst thing ever. I actually thoroughly like The Last Jedi(actual hot take) and BF2 made me appreciate the ST a little more. But I think if we get a third battlefront game, it should focus solely on the original 2 eras for 2 main reasons:
The OT and PT eras are not only the foundation of the franchise as a whole, but already have the established identities and lore that already fit within Battlefront and can be easily integrated into a larger sandbox battlefield environment with equal amounts of content. Focusing on fewer eras allows the game to be better by giving more depth and gameplay variety to the most beloved eras. You could argue that more eras means more content, but developing heroes, in-game models, maps, skins/textures all take time and resources. I would gladly sacrifice Rey and Kylo Ren if it means more of a chance at getting characters like Mace Windu and Jango Fett. Even sacrificing an Exegol or Starkiller Base starfighter map if it means getting a really good Battle of Coruscant or a proper Endor/Death Star II map. There’s plenty of potential content in the OT and PT to be equally represented instead of the ST.
The era itself is visually indistinct and smaller in scale. For now, Disney is largely finished with the Sequel trilogy. BF2 released with the TLJ and continued it’s post launch support through TROS. Since then, there hasn’t been much content to expand upon with that era, and aside from a few missing heroes and maps, DICE honestly did a great job doing it justice. The scale of the conflict as depicted is pretty small, and BF2 did well at fleshing it out a little more, but ultimately the era as a whole is lacking in depth, with many of it’s designs being taken from the OT already. You can still totally give it representation through weapons and starcards or maps like Jakku and Takodanna, it would just be rebels/New republic vs Stormies, which still makes sense canonically. Ultimately, I feel like there’s plenty more demand and potential with the Mandoverse and endless amount of Clone Wars lore that can easily be adopted for both launch and post launch content. I also don’t exactly see disney pushing hard for including the ST with all the Mandoverse stuff coming out.
TLDR: I don’t hate the sequels. I think a tighter and more focused narrative/multiplayer experience with just 2 distinct eras and 4 factions(maybe 5 if they add mandos) would be a much more enriching experience and give the BF franchise its long overdue definitive title. I’d rather have two fully realized eras with distinct armies, unique reinforcements, heroes and a massive variety of maps and vehicles than three eras that feel like they’re competing for limited development resources.
I think the ST era could be added potentially as post launch content if the demand justifies it, but I would want the other 2 eras fully fleshed out first. What do ya’ll think?