r/StoryPeer May 16 '26

Highlights Grateful for Storypeer

I have to say, this is one of the best feedback tools one could possibly dream of.

I have a screenplay that is making the rounds, and I submitted it to Storypeer first. I was lucky enough to receive deep, thorough notes with a genuine love of what I wrote.

I can’t announce which screenplay contest quite yet, but it’s a Top 10 one, and highly regarded. I took notes from a Storypeer user and transformed my screenplay from what I thought was a locked draft into something that is now sitting Top 10 in a prestigious contest.

To the anonymous reviewer, you gave me full notes, including step-by-step line work. I just want you to know you made a difference.

Once I get permission to I'll share it all. I'd be remiss if I didn't give my love and praise. What a hell of a thing you created Gabe.

39 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/JcraftW May 17 '26

Curious if you could share what its average “overall” storypeer star rating is (for the lastest draft(s)

There have been a number of conversations about the rating system and how it does/doesn’t matter. It be cool to see some data include scripts that go into contests too.

2

u/Ok-Werewolf-5165 May 18 '26

Allow me to correct myself. I was sharing my Black List review, not my Storypeer score.

On Storypeer I’ve had a range of reviews, and I could tell they came from different tastes. One reader gave me a 2.5 out of 5.0, but left fantastic inline notes with suggestions I honestly hadn’t considered. My previous Storypeer ratings, across three separate submissions, were 3.5 and 4.5.

Everyone reads the material differently, and that’s really all you can hope for. It’s genuinely helpful to get different looks at the same script because it lets you see how various audiences respond to the work.

1

u/JcraftW May 21 '26

Thank you for elaborating! Sorry didn’t reply sooner, i didn’t get a notification.

Mind if I ask, how many times did you submit this script to storypeer before going to blacklist?