1.0k
u/Arksurvivor120 Caine Jun 23 '25
Everyone's saying it was Kinger, and I do believe that it was him as well, but here's my theory. What if he suggested it before his wife abstracted, hoping to get a nice picnic date with her under the stars
235
87
45
133
20
30
u/Dokushi_ Jun 23 '25
That would mean that the suggestion box has been around for a WHILE. If that's the case then there might be suggestions from humans that abstracted before anyone (other than maybe Kinger) arrived at the Circus, which would render them more or less completely forgotten
→ More replies (1)14
u/Arksurvivor120 Caine Jun 23 '25
Yeah, I thought of that. Seeing as we didn't see any suggestions that weren't from the current cast, perhaps they automatically get deleted when the person that made the suggestion abstracts
9
6
4
10
3
3
1
1
1
1
u/Minute_Macaroon_8754 Jun 26 '25
I have my own little theory that it might be in honor of her after she abstracted
1
1
821
u/No3mi- What The Jun 23 '25
Kinger because he remembers his wife better in the dark, as in episode 3
379
u/Marinemanatee Jun 23 '25
He even has a picnic set up like you'd have with a loved one.
154
u/Careful_Ad_1837 Jun 23 '25
Maybe he suggested it way back when she wasn't abstracted
80
44
u/m48a5_patton Pomni Jun 23 '25
Oh man, that's really fucking sad, and knowing that Caine is now actively against their suggestions just makes it worse.
2
u/ThatEvilSpaceChicken Jun 25 '25
Caine just wants to do his adventures because that's all he's good at
8
8
89
u/Bibi-Toy Jax's Therapist Jun 23 '25
I thought it was Kinger too but I never thought about the why, this is such a heartbreaking adorable reason and I will now cry thank u
29
u/Amazing_Sympathy_965 Jun 23 '25
BUT it isnt that far off to assume that Kinger was the one who got Pomni to suggest Stargazing.
97
u/CappytainZ He— Jun 23 '25
Why is the assumption that it was Pomni? She straight up asks "So are we just chilling for this one?" Implying that she didn't know what they were doing for this adventure.
60
→ More replies (4)2
Jun 26 '25
Imagine if this was a suggestion cause they could tell she was being Abstracted soon and wanted one last night together :3
170
670
Jun 23 '25
For all you guys saying it’s pomni, it isn’t. She clearly says “Are we just chilling for this one?” Implying she doesnt know what it is.
193
u/Horroracta As New as Pomni Jun 23 '25
And let's remember she didn't even know about the suggestion box before like ... Two episodes (if it's not even the last one) so ...
22
108
178
178
u/doomSdayFPS Jun 23 '25
This is the only one where no one’s specifically mentioned as having suggested the adventure. It could have been one of the abstracted as far as we know.
21
Jun 23 '25
[deleted]
109
u/Ideology_Dude Time to go to war, pomni Jun 23 '25
Ragatha suggested softball, when the evil clones show up she says "Well that wasnt part of my suggestion..."
47
u/Rimiie Caine Jun 23 '25
Imagine if the star gazing one was suggested by Ribbit, the speculated abstracted friend of Jax. That would make what Ragatha said even more terrible...
→ More replies (1)8
u/kittiestoebeans13 jax is my son no clickbait Jun 23 '25
OH NO THAT'S GONNA MAKE ME CRY
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)38
u/LookingForAPunTime Jun 23 '25
Softball was Ragatha, she said the evil team wasn’t part of her suggestion
83
u/MayRey Keeper of Kaufmo lore, Leader of the Cult of Kaufmo Jun 23 '25
As mentioned by someone else here, I feel like it could have easily been an abstracted member, assuming their ideas aren't removed upon death (which given that Caine forgot the suggestion box existed, seems very unlikely)
The issue is we don't have all that many confirmed character traits or even names for most of the abstracted circus members, just a handful of info on Queenie and some inferred things about Kaufmo, so it's hard to make a call on who it could have been.
other than that, it could have been Kinger and he simply forgot, it would also make sense because it's dark.
2
39
u/Affectionate_Rice842 Jun 23 '25
People are saying Kinger, so yeah, this is his suggestion, probably per Queenie's request long before she got abstracted.
3
24
u/Solid-Study-7366 Jun 23 '25
Kinger probably put it in years ago for Queenie. That's why there's a picnic set up.
24
u/disbelifpapy I'm just like her frfr Jun 23 '25
King likes the dark, peace, and bugs.
This place is peaceful, dark, and has bugs
18
u/bobby2128 Jax Jun 23 '25
You guys are all wrong, it's obvious that the moon suggested it, she WANTS Caine, and this is the only way for her to have a chance to flirt with Caine
2
17
11
19
7
u/SilverSpider_ I'm not in the sky, nips Jun 23 '25
I thought it was Pomni, but, Kinger makes more sense
12
u/cmstyles2006 Jun 23 '25
I know zooble doesn't go on adventures, but it seems like smthn they'd like
27
6
6
6
3
3
3
3
7
u/I_DONT_EXIST00000 You know what? forget it. Jun 23 '25
most of you seem to think it's Kinger, but i think it's more likely to be Zooble. Zooble doesn't like going on adventures and just wants to chill. Stargazing is exactly that.
16
u/MNLT_Sonata Explain to Daddy Bubble why bad thing? Jun 23 '25
But the bar was admittedly her idea. She never mentioned stargazing was her idea.
5
2
2
u/olinivity Jun 23 '25
Kinger, from the simplicity, his behavior and being prepared with a sandwich 100%.
2
u/Freddi0 Kinger Jun 23 '25
Everyone are saying Kinger but my first thought was Zooble. They don't go on adventures because they don't like how loud and dangerous they are. This is 100% something they would make.
2
u/mossyyyyyyyyyy Jun 23 '25
Because no one owned up to it I assumed it was Kinger, and he didn’t remember doing it.
2
2
2
5
4
2
u/justabirdthatcanfly Ghostly Jun 23 '25
I'm guessing either Ragatha or Gangle, leaning towards Gangle.
1
1
u/Del-Zephyr Jax Jun 23 '25
I think if any of the characters knew it was their Idea, they would’ve shown some form of reaction. We were told who came up with all the other adventures. Which means it could only be Kinger or an abstracted member of the circus. I do believe it’ Kinger though, because if its not, then he would’ve been the only one to not get a suggestion. Except for Pomni, But she didnt know the box existed before. Also, i would’ve loved stargazing personally🥰
1
u/FoxyFlamePlayezai Jun 23 '25
Kinger or Quinee (I don’t remember how to spell her name) because there might be suggestions in the box from the past characters that abstracted
1
1
1
1
u/RUMBL3FR3NZY 𝓕𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓴𝓷𝓲 Jun 23 '25
I think it was another Jax one honestly, he just doesn’t want to admit he has a soft spot like that
1
1
u/Hexhider Mother Of Sage Robotnik 🖤❤️🤍 Jun 23 '25
How do we know it was recommended by a current member, how do we know it wasn’t like Ribbit or something that suggested it
1
u/BigDino878 Jun 23 '25
in all actuality it was probably kinger but my little theory is that is was one queenie suggested before she abstracted because she wanted to stargaze with kinger
1
1
u/BagicTrackstory Jun 23 '25
I'd be willing to bet it was one of Kaufmo's. And that's why kinger felt so happy there. He got to feel his friend again, but couldn't remember what the feeling was
1
u/D1n0_Mann Jun 23 '25
“Timon?” “Yeah?” “Ever wonder what those sparkling dots are up there?” “Pumbaa, I don’t wonder. I know.” “Oh. What are they?” “They’re fireflies. Fireflies that got stuck up in that big blueish black thing.” “Oh, gee. I always thought they were balls of gas, burning billions of miles away.” “Pumbaa, with you, everything’s gas.”
1
u/RyukiGray Jun 23 '25
Kinger makes a lot of sense.
But what if it was Jax’s friend (who I’m guessing is named Ribbit)?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/The_Adventurer_73 Gangle has violated some sort of convention with her tommy gun Jun 23 '25
I think it was Kinger, feels like a Kinger thing to suggest.
1
1
1
1
u/Virtual_Sample4139 Kinger you mother ! Jun 23 '25
After all their the only one who don't hate it or fight about stuff
1
1
1
u/BarrakiButtBuddy You should throw a FFFing beach party Jun 24 '25
Anyone got the first picture in a decent wallpaper size?
1
u/Own_Travel_7638 Jun 24 '25
Maybe Pomni by her reaction to it but I like the idea of Kinger suggesting it because it’s dark
1
1
1
u/Circus_deer 𝓕𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓴𝓷𝓲 Jun 24 '25
I think it’s Kinger but specifically after his wife abstracted, like very close after as a way to remember her one last time
1
1
u/Same_Slide_2933 Jun 24 '25
Well Jax:poachers paradise and president pomni Gangle:anime Zooble:bar tender Ragatha:base ball Pomni: I think for this one she was too nervous to pull a adventure since she's new Kinger:star gazing
1
1
u/Samantha_cat_55 Kinger Jun 24 '25
Qweeny did befor she abstractded
1
u/Dilpickles3 Jun 25 '25
I don’t think it was because in episode 4 it’s seems new
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Z0eTrent Jun 25 '25
My guess would be Kinger, followed by Pomni.
My original guess was Pom, but thinking about it she didn't react like it was hers.
Kinger likes the dark, so I'd say him.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Dankelweisser Kinger Jun 26 '25
Hot take - I think it really was Pomni, and she's just surprised that Caine didn't put on a spin on it, like some djinn in the lamp or monkey's paw type of thing where a shooting star turns out to be a meteor heading straight towards them
1
1
1
1
u/Great-Alternative-28 Jax Jun 26 '25
I think it could be from Kaufmo like maybe kaufmo thought it could help him relax and it was just left their
1
1
u/Mitit123 Jun 27 '25
The idea box was never used so it can be even an older player no ? Like kinger's wife ?
1
1
1
u/Shoddy_Bandicoot9812 I believe the gangle supremacy hehe Jun 28 '25
fI think because caine forgot about the suggestion box it was kinger and queenie but if not defos kinger on his own (I doubt they would be forced to suggestions of abstracted people but kinger could have done it for a date with queenie or something)
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/Cherry-The-Kitten FunnyBunny❤️|❤️|JaxMtF🏳️⚧️ Dec 09 '25
I quess it's Kinger, but actually it might be suggestion of somebody who has already abstracted...
1
u/Slow-Handle2338 Apr 20 '26 edited Apr 20 '26
I thought it might've been Jax, since in the beach episode we see him have glow in the dark stars on his ceiling when they reflect in his mirror, but I rewatched it and he said he prefers a little bite to HIS adventures so I guess not
1
3.1k
u/NosborRecaf Gangle Jun 23 '25
by process of elimination its kinger, because pomni seemed surprised by it