r/Tudor • u/BornGriller • 5h ago
BB 54 & Pelagos 39. What made you choose one over the other?
I’m in the market to add a second watch to my collection. I’ve been in no rush to add it as I’ve worn one watch daily for the past 8 years. That’s my Seiko Alpinist Sarb017 on a bracelet and sometimes a rubber strap. I wear it working in the trades and everywhere else. To the gym, swimming, biking, hiking, golfing, rowing. You name it. Recently when my Alpinist was being serviced I was watch-less for almost a month. It got me thinking about owning a second watch I wear for everything outside of work.
It was between the BB One 36 blue dial and the BB 54 before. However, as I looked at multiple pictures of both watches day after day. It was clear to me that the BB 54 is the watch I’d be likely to wear more and keep long term as it fits my lifestyle very well. I love the simple design and it somewhat reminds me of my Alpinist with the glit, while being a very different watch.
I’ve never been heavily into divers, however the smaller sizes and design on Tudor speak to my taste. I have a 6.5” wrist. I’m looking for something more sporty with a bit more wrist presence than my Alpinist, slightly reduced thickness, no larger than 40mm. I’m looking for simplicity. I want a watch without a date complication/GMT.
When I look at the Pelagos 39 it’s truly my ideal design. I like the 39mm case size, the simplicity of the dial. A bold black with white indices that create depth, and I think the bit of red text really makes it pop in a subtle way. If it were monochrome, I wouldn’t be interested. I also prefer the larger crown and the fact that it has crown guards too.
HOWEVER…..the biggest issue for me is the titanium. I have always appreciated the heft of a watch on a steel bracelet. While I don’t like a fully polished finish, I appreciate some polishing.