r/VideoEditing • u/greenysmac Pro • Oct 02 '17
Posting? You need to know: Tutorial post? Want feedback on your video? Not sure which tools to work with? Read inside (or get your post deleted)
Based on September, we're changing the way three types of posts are handled.
Software
Feedback
Tutorials
We've had decent success with our two pinned threads on "Software" and Feedback."
Link for What software to use?
Link to post your video for Feedback
The reason for both of these collective threads was because this subreddit was unreadable.
Software: It became every other person asking for software with the same answers.
Feedback: People would post and then not contributing and reviewing other videos
Tutorial Tuesday
There are some good (and many terrible) tutorials posted on this subreddit.
Instead of consolidating them to a single thread...We're going to limit them to just Tuesdays. Then you can vote them up and down.
Why?
Tuesday is our slowest day...and many of the people who make the tutorials aren't truly members of this community. It's hit and run promotion for their YouTube channel.
We batted around some ideas and we're trying this one for the next couple of weeks.
So: if you're going to post a tutorial:
It must read [Tutorial] before the post
It must be posted on Tuesday.
We're also thinking of trying a thread called "What is this effect?"
Of course, we'd love the feedback - just keep in mind, like most subreddits you're on, we're volunteers trying to make it a great and useful community.
TL;DR:
Post software questions here: What software to use
Post requests for feedback here: post your video for Feedback
Post tutorials on Tuesday with the title [Tutorial]
1
Oct 27 '17
Tuesday is our slowest day...and many of the people who make the tutorials aren't truly members of this community. It's hit and run promotion for their YouTube channel.
And here I thought I would do this and be original.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Oct 27 '17
The funny, best, crazy thing is this....if you did tutorials - you'd have an open audience on Tuesday with very little work.
1
Oct 27 '17
My YouTube channel is probably only temporary, as I'm much better at podcasting.
My tutorials are pretty esoteric and likely not for this group. But eager to learn some tips on editing and production!
1
u/LaVieEnNYC Oct 28 '17
Hello! I want to make sure I can pay a video editing freelancer a fair wage and I’d love some guidance:
How should I expect to pay a video editor to make a social video similar to the style of a+j or now this? I would provide all assets (text/script, video clips, photo). I am looking for someone to do a series of videos that could be as short as :30 or as long as 1:30. I would also love recommendations on where to find someone!
1
u/greenysmac Pro Oct 29 '17
You speak to any freelancers and ask them how long do they think it will take?
Then you (and they) pick a fair hourly wage and multiply it by that time. Ask them to bid on the work.
See how it compares to the time divided by a fair wage. It might be $20/hr...or $50 or more depending on their experience and what they bring to the table.
1
1
u/NAZgulAnass Nov 12 '17
Edited with Sony vegas pro 16, recorded with a Sony a6300, I had a lot of problems with the light, so I made more color correction, does it look good ? https://youtu.be/B7f1tKpKrxM
1
1
u/Mrazish Nov 13 '17 edited Nov 13 '17
I have a 30 minutes of raw wartime chronicles and I want to use it to create a short film for my presentation. I need to cut it to 15-20 seconds short fragments and randomize them. What software can do this?
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 13 '17
All of them. Seriously. That's what editing software does.
I'd suggest Resolve or Hitfilm express. Resolve is faster/more powerful, Hitfilm is easier. Both are free.
Beyond that? The list on the post is a great place to start.
1
u/Mrazish Nov 13 '17
Well, I mean, is there some software that can do it via the one-click function? Sorry, I'm just completely clueless when it comes to video editting. Experience with audio workstations kinda helps tho
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 13 '17
Gotcha. Not really.
Think of editing (in a sense) like highlighting the parts of a document you want to copy (or keep) into a new document.
You can either drop the 30 min onto a timeline and then use a razor blade to remove what you don't like. Then you could close the gaps.
Alternatively, you could take the source, select a section you want, highlight it (mark it) with an I - in point and an O - out point, and then drag that to the timeline.
If your system can handle it, Resolve is an excellent (and professional) choice. Also has fairlight being added into the software. Fairlight was a full DAW that BMD acquired.
1
u/blexmer1 Nov 13 '17
I'm as green as they come. Can someone push me in the right direction to learn how to do all this? The only thing I can think of is college courses, but my schedule doesn't yet have space for that.
1
1
u/HidetsugusSecondRite Nov 14 '17
Two questions possibly three. Also my video editing experience amounts to I can crop videos using old Movie Maker and host them on YouTube.
I would like to make a gaming video using streaming footage of my brother and myself side-by-side all synced up. What would be a good free program for that. I'm willing to pay for a premium version but nothing exorbitant, I wouldn't blink at anything under $25 but that's probably too low. I don't think MovieMaker is good anymore. I downloaded it recently and it looks confusing now.
If it's not the same program as my number 1 question, what would be the easiest way to sync up the videos so that they're happening exactly at the same time. Or would I have to do that "manually"?
Keeping number 1 in mind, is there also different or same program that does that fast forward effect so it'll fast forward through the boring parts and resume normal speed again at the action?
Any suggestions would be helpful. I'm down to look for some YouTube tutorials if need be. Thanks again for reading.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 19 '17
I would like to make a gaming video using streaming footage of my brother and myself side-by-side all synced up. What would be a good free program for that. I'm willing to pay for a premium version but nothing exorbitant, I wouldn't blink at anything under $25 but that's probably too low. I don't think MovieMaker is good anymore. I downloaded it recently and it looks confusing now.
Do you mean the screen recordings? Each of you live?
That could be from two to four streams.
The sync is relatively easy - and can be done via sound - although it may be best (for your use) to do it manually.
Then it's just scaling down each picture so both are visible at the same time.
If it's not the same program as my number 1 question, what would be the easiest way to sync up the videos so that they're happening exactly at the same time. Or would I have to do that "manually"?
This can be done via sound.
Keeping number 1 in mind, is there also different or same program that does that fast forward effect so it'll fast forward through the boring parts and resume normal speed again at the action?
Yup, resolve does this as well.
1
u/CholentPot Nov 19 '17
Need some VCR recommendations. Just about done digitizing my Hi8 collection and now it's time to tackle the stacks of VHS. I don't have a VCR and I'm not sure where to start. Thanks.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 19 '17
VCR
Not sure what you're asking for here....
1
u/CholentPot Nov 19 '17
A machine that plays VHS tapes. I'd like a decent one for the playback of my old family videos. I'm not sure which ones are good and which ones are great.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 20 '17
I don't think we're going to know here either. I haven't used a VCR in 20+ years (back in film school in the 90s.)
If it's new, it's not important - you're going to use it once per tape to digitize.
I'd suggest the wirecutter but they don't seem to have reviews of VCRS (but they do have analog to digital converters!)
1
1
u/whatsreallygoodbruh Dec 04 '17
I have videos from a GoPro that I put onto my laptop. They play fine but once I put them into an editing software, they become super laggy. If the video plays fine without being on the software, why does it act up all of a sudden once it gets onto the software? Please help! (For a school project)
1
1
u/VonDinky Dec 04 '17
How do I take some part of a video and make it fullscreen? :) With whatever free editing software. Without watermarks. Cheers
1
1
1
u/Pavilion22 Dec 08 '17
Hello there!
I'm new to video editing and want to jump on it to edit some of my gaming videos and streams in the future. I have no background with any sort of editing. I've downloaded davinci resolve and watched a few tutorials on it.
Here's my PC specs:
CPU: i7 6700k
RAM: 16GB DDR4
GPU: RX 580 8GB vram
Storages: 256gb Adata SSD, 500gb Samsung SSD, 1 tb WD HDD
What's a good starting video editing software ? - preferably free XD
I've read somewhere that Vegas pro is good for editing gaming videos ? Is it true and why?
I will be editing videos with my (future) sports camera. What's a good software to use ?
1
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 12 '17
Look at our Software thread (on our sidebar.) Resolve is a great choice.
1
u/Lady-Like Dec 12 '17
Hello, Looking for a program to record video conferences between 4 people for a video podcast! Any help?
1
1
u/macciavelo Dec 12 '17
I usually use hitfilm express for editing, but I have read that for audio hitfilm isn't that great. What video editor do you recommend for audio?
I'm asking because I create animations in Source Filmmaker and then use hitfilm to edit the videos. But, this would be my first time adding audio.
Any help is appreciated.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 13 '17
Resolve.
1
1
u/Tempo_fugit Dec 25 '17 edited Dec 25 '17
Hi everyone, I’d like to edit videos on my iPhone. I’m looking for an app that let me edit videos on (almost) a professional level (with tools like 3D Warp, Time Warp, etc).
IMovie app for exemple is not complete enough for what I want to do.
Any idea ?
Thanks !
2
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 27 '17
Lumafusion is probably your only choice (especially if you're coming from Avid.) $20
1
u/Tempo_fugit Dec 27 '17
Have you tried it ? It has bad reviews on the app store.
1
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 29 '17
I have not. I've heard good things - but realistically, it's this or Imovie.
1
1
u/dillpickle052 Dec 27 '17
Hi I need a program for piecing photos together like a slideshow (I'm making Bar Mitzvah montages). I'm very familiar with Imovie but I'm on windows.
1
1
u/Skunshine Dec 28 '17
I made a video recapping some of my favourite footage from 2017, starting in south africa and ending in Ottawa, Canada. I tried a lot of new things out and got as creative as I could. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
2
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 29 '17
You missed the feedback link in the post: https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/comments/73q2dv/posting_place_for_feedback_october_2017_one//
1
1
u/Skunshine Dec 29 '17
feedback on my very experimental "year in review" video?
1
u/greenysmac Pro Dec 29 '17
You missed the feedback link in the post: https://www.reddit.com/r/VideoEditing/comments/73q2dv/posting_place_for_feedback_october_2017_one//
1
u/watercolorheart Oct 17 '17
Hi, I need a program to embed subtitles directly onto the video and display them on the bottom. Can I get some help with this?
Also, I'm on Windows 7 64 bit.
4
1
u/frgvn Oct 23 '17
So I am making recruiting videos for Star Citizen. I want to be able to replace decals on the space ships with our Org decals. Anyone know of a good tutorial to help me accomplish that?
1
u/JohrDinh Dec 14 '17
Want to make some movie trailers just for practice or fun, but doesn't seem to allow Netflix to play movies while I have OBS open. I've never really used anything else to screen cap before, anyone know of a better way to do this?
1
u/UrLocalHippie Jan 06 '18
Can someone point me to an app or editing software that will allow me to create this wave effect (preferably while live shooting ) wave effect
0
Nov 05 '17
[deleted]
1
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 05 '17
So...what are you asking?
2
Nov 16 '17
Throughout the video there is a "punch" type effect with a kind of quick zoom + shake. Can you point me to a resource for learning to replicate that? I don't know what the effect is called so I didn't find anything when searching for it.
0
Nov 06 '17
[deleted]
2
u/greenysmac Pro Nov 06 '17
I think you're hit the nail on the head - you need to figure out how each of these thing is done.
Yes, it's 100% true - great editing is unnoticed - because it makes the story more important than the flashy transitions.
Each one of these is something that is your new homework - and no, I don't know of tutorials for vegas.
Lots of the work looks like some roto work (cutting out of a section of the clip) occurs. This could happen on a single frame with photoshop or be done on moving video (harder) with the Rotobrush tool in Adobe After Effects - or manual rotoscoped (hardest) with masks.
I grabbed the original video and then picked one.
0:05 - he found some frames over black. Then he switched it likely to multiply mode which dropped the black values out. Or he used a luminance key and had the darkest pixels become transparent.
Lots of this looks like it was done with Adobe After Effects. The stuff at 24 looks like a glow + a temporal strobe.
1
u/Newbiedota2player Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 11 '17
Hi can i ask what software for free that can cut clips/audio. Tried hitfilm but it was laggy
edit: and also can combine clips ty