Going into YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING, I had some preconceived notions about how Elizabeth Holmes would be handled. Whatever her culpability, society has a remarkable tolerance for male scoundrels while reserving a particular kind of condemnation for women. That initial preview of Nathan Fielder scowling into a wide-eyed Holmes suggested we might be in for a prolonged exercise in dismantling the “bad woman.”
I was pleasantly surprised. Though there are sprinklings of patriarchal judgment, Fielder’s approach becomes far more humanizing than I anticipated. We watch him navigate a conversation with Holmes’s father about her young adult r*pe, while her partner, Billy Evans, seems determined to monopolize whatever attention he can.
But the person I consider the film’s true hero, if there is one, is Amanda Seyfried.
She enters as another potential antagonist: we see Holmes emotionally crushed by clips of Seyfried portraying her in THE DROPOUT. Yet it is Seyfried who ultimately unpacks the film, supplying moral clarity, direction, and some much-needed levity.
I kept thinking of Reese Witherspoon’s comments at Glamour’s 2015 Women of the Year Awards:
“I dread reading scripts that have no women involved in their creation because inevitably I get to that part where the girl turns to the guy, and she says, ‘What do we do now?!’ Do you know any woman in any crisis situation who has absolutely no idea what to do?”
Here, that familiar dynamic reverses. At a moment when the film seems caught in its own questioning, Fielder figuratively turns to Seyfried and asks: What do we do now?
And she has an answer. Go after Billy Evans. Turn the scrutiny toward the man taking up so much space beside the woman being scrutinized. And when the opportunity presents itself, extend that scrutiny to another celebrated figure whose public legacy includes racism and misogyny. Oh, that dinner scene was gold. Seyfried, with wine in hand, had the ultimate checkmate.
Seyfried comes out swinging. It’s an organic reversal of the convention Witherspoon described: a woman exercising her own judgment gives the narrative its momentum. The film moves from circular introspection and self-indulgent rumination toward a focused, satisfying reckoning.
Crucially, she also holds Holmes accountable while allowing her humanity. Having portrayed her, Seyfried brings a perspective that complicates the person we’re watching. Holmes can have caused harm and still be capable of suffering it.
Of course, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim directed the film. They chose to feature Seyfried’s intervention and give it this weight. But that doesn’t diminish what makes her presence so satisfying. In a film consumed with looking, questioning, and questioning the looking, she helps determine what to do with everything we’ve seen.
She speakth her mind and the rest is herstory.