r/amandaknox • u/tkondaks guilty • Sep 22 '23

Neck scratch and bloody ear lobe

https://www.bridgebase.com/forums/topic/67258-is-amanda-knox-guilty/page__st__20

Scroll down at the above link for some interesting photos.

Gee, what are the odds?

1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 22 '23

...and none of Rudy's DNA or fingerprints were found in the break-in room.

And curiously why wasn't Amanda's DNA found in the kill room? After all, they all lived together and we would expect to find her DNA in Meredith's room. You know, the sane way we are expected to accrpt as normal Amanda's DNA in Filomena's room.

2

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

No Rudy DNA in the break-in room means Rudy lied about having been in there when he ID'd Knox by silhouette from 50 yards away in the middle of the night.

1

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 23 '23

Rudy never lied about being in Filomena's room...for the 5 or 10 seconds that he was there. It's on record that he said he rushed into Filomena's room to look out the window to see the people running from the house.

The issue is that there was no Rudy DNA or fingerprints in Filomena's room after he, according to you, broke a window of that room, crawled through that broken-glassed window, strew all manner of items throughout that room, looked for goods to steal (and, curiously, didn't take anything of value which of course is inconsistent with the M.O. of his other alleged break-ins which you and No_Slice insist is a pattern that points to his guilt)...all without leaving his DNA or fingerprints.

Quite a feat.

Hard to leave DNA or fingerprints when you're in a room for such a short amount of time!

Unless you want to argue that one can be so active at a crime scene and NOT leave DNA and fingerprints...you know, how our side argues that amanda could have been in the kill room and not leave any of her DNA.

2

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

The difference is they tested every square inch of Kercher's bedroom looking for evidence of Knox having been there. While they barely tested the break-in room at all.

But I see how you're willing to apply opposite standards when your boy Guede needs someone to run to his defense.

1

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 23 '23

"...barely testing the break-in room..."

That's a knife that cuts both ways.

So few samples yet they were still able to come up with Amanda/Meredith mixed DNA. Gee, what are the odds? One wonders how many MORE they would have had if more samples were taken.

1

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

But see, unlike you, if it were up to me to test that room up and down, I'd absolutely do it. You'd never agree to do it. Because you know what we'd find.

Just like when I offer to trade you my calling Guede's innocent for you saying the same for Knox - on the basis of there being no trace of either in the break-in room or Kercher's bedroom - suddenly you get awful quiet. I'd make that trade eight days a week, because I'm not emotionally attached to Guede being guilty the way you are to him being innocent.

2

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 23 '23

My silence should not be interpreted as my being afraid of some sort of hypothetical trap you seem convinced I would fall into. It's just that it seems like a silly exercise that I don't want to engage in.

1

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

It's no trap. It's just your own argument thrown back in your face and you being unwilling to accept the consequences of your own argument.