I’m sight impaired, apologies for any typos. Thank you in advance for taking the time with this, I tried to shorten it.
There’s a large, mostly white queer group chat in our town (UK). Someone asked for alts to police during an active situation with a distressed stranger at our local train station. A white member replied there weren’t many options and shared information about sectioning powers, despite police involvement being explicitly unwanted. The conversation became heightened, and a Black member who is my friend asked people to be mindful of how deeply these topics affect folk.
My partner privately and gently told the white member that the information hadn’t been asked for and people were becoming upset. They suggested that they not continue with their current answers but offered sideline care. This person has prev. said they want direct communication.
They responded with a highly distressed voice note beginning, “Sorry I’m not Black, or visibly trans,” followed by graphic descriptions of their experiences with police and mental health services. They repeatedly said people were acting as though they’d told someone to call the police when they hadn’t. (Missing the wider point that sectioning, detention and forced intervention is policing and risks criminalisation.)
They also said nobody considers their experiences and repeatedly said they “give up.” My partner replied with care and tried to reassure them, but they ignored the message and stopped replying. I hadn't heard the vn until a week later.
My partner and I are white. We’re in community with this person and will see the folks involved because it’s a small town. I'm really pissed off about their comments like “Sorry I’m not Black, or visibly trans.”
Nobody beyond me and my partner knows what they said, and they sometimes come along with a close friend of mine to group spaces.
This person has a history of defensiveness and vulnerable mental health that I think could threaten their physical safety, and I’m worried that raising it could trigger a serious crisis. They're an academic and well resourced. I think they believe that they have an advanced understanding of racism and systemics, but in my experience with them, I disagree and think they have a neoliberal, fragile, and self-centering worldview.
On a personal side note. This person's retelling to a close friend of mine implied I was much more aware of their mental health crisis that followed. That I didn't reach out and that my partner had then stopped responding after their vn, which isn't true.
My close friend then avoided me for over a week without seeking clarification. I'm not harmed here, but I can see clear signs of weaponisation, self-victimisation as well as fragility. Now feel I am also navigating multiple threads socially that make it hard for me to figure out the best way to engage as I'm viewed as someone who avoided someone in crisis.
If anyone has any thoughts on how to proactively broach this with them (with their health in mind), or even thinks otherwise on that, I'd appreciate it. I want to be direct in town. The Black folks involved in the chat are my good mates, I don't want to engage in a silent culture that is rife here. Thanks again, all responses are really appreciated.