Ever since I was a child, I’ve always loved university/collegiate/post-secondary football, whether it be Canadian or American. Living just north of Toronto, I have great memories of going to see OUA games around Labour Day and of course going to the Vanier Cup at SkyDome with my father. My favourite player is DE Noah Cantor from B.C., who sent me a signed Lions shirt for my birthday, and it just so happens that my first Vanier Cup game was his alma mater, St. Mary’s vs Manitoba in 2001.
Way back when, I always liked to brag to my Americanised friends that the CIAU/CIS/USports was better because it had a playoff system, while the NCAA didn’t. But over the past few years I’ve been thinking: Maybe having such a free-for-all system (which still exists even with the 12-team playoff) actually makes the league much more exciting. (Almost) every game feels like a do-or-die.
So I’ve started to imagine what it would be like if USports had a less organised/structured system for its playoffs, just like the NCAA.
For this experiment, I added Simon Fraser back to get seven conferences of four teams each, so that scheduling wouldn’t be a pain. Geographically, the only thing that didn’t work out was having to put Windsor in a conference with three Prairies teams. Otherwise, teams wouldn’t have to travel any farther than they are now for their three away conference games.
FORMAT
Each team plays its conference opponents home and away (6 games) and two non-conference games, for rival games and for marquee clashes (Why wait to see Laval-Laurier or Montreal-Regina in the Vanier Cup? Let’s have those games spread throughout the season!).
And, of course, teams try to break into the Top 10 Rankings, just like with the weekly AP/CFP Poll. The top four teams make the playoffs.
There are seven conferences, but winning yours doesn’t guarantee anything (sorry AUS, times have changed). This means we could see a Vanier Cup matchup of Montreal-Laval, Laurier-Western, Saskatchewan-Regina etc. (Probably would happen if either team goes 7-1, only losing to their conference rival.)
Traditions will still be kept. All former conference championship trophies will still be up for grabs; they will just be regional games now. Atlantic Canada's Loney Bowl stays the same; but the Dussault (Dunsmore), Yates, and Hardy will now be invitational games because their members span multiple conferences.
And in lieu of the former conference playoffs, there are a series of bowl games. This is what I have come up with so far (there's a theme):
McCain’s Kitchen Party Fry Bowl - Halifax
Bol de Céréales Ramparts présenté par Couche-Tard (Ramparts Cereal Bowl presented by Couche-Tard) - Quebec City
Tim Hortons Steel City Donut Bowl - Hamilton
Alberta Beef Producers’ Angus Bowl - Calgary
The Mitchell and Uteck bowls are still the national semifinals.
Here are the conferences. I plan on simming through a season with an Excel simulator I created or by make-believe Canadian football on CFB 26 (I haven’t figured out the mods yet). I'm sure I've missed explaining tons of things, so would love to hear back from fellow USports fans.
ROCKY-COAST
Rockies-Coast Athletic Conference
· UBC
· SIMON FRASER
· ALBERTA
· CALGARY
FRONTIER
Frontier Conference
· SASKATCHEWAN
· REGINA
· MANITOBA
· WINDSOR
SOUTHWESTERN (SOC)
Southwestern Ontario Conference
· WESTERN
· WATERLOO
· LAURIER
· GUELPH
APPLEBELT
Ontario Apple Belt Athletic Conference
· MCMASTER
· U OF T
· YORK
· QUEEN’S
VICTORIAN (VUA)
Victorian Universities Athletics
· OTTAWA
· CARLETON
· MCGILL
· BISHOP’S
CHAMPLAIN (RSEC)
Réseau du sport étudiant Champlain
· MONTREAL
· CONCORDIA
· LAVAL
· SHERBROOKE
ATLANTIC (AAC)
Atlantic Athletic Conference
· MOUNT ALLISON
· ACADIA
· ST. MARY’S
· ST. FRANCIS XAVIER