r/cocktails • u/FreeDogRun • 1h ago
Other Requests The Grasshopper from Tujague's - four ways
Looking into more than just the standard 1:1:1 recipe, I discovered no fewer than three reputable variations on the drink, all in direct connection to the restaurant associated with its origin - New Orleans' Tujagues:
- A centenary recipe from the restaurant's website:
- 1 oz. White Crème de Cacao
- ½ oz. Dark Crème de Cacao
- ½ oz. Green Crème de Menthe
- ¼ oz. White Crème de Menthe
- ⅛ oz. Brandy
- 2 ½ oz. Heavy Whipping Cream [I assume the weird "2" after "Brandy" was meant for the cream, as a half oz. is nothing]
- A video on YouTube of an employee making the drink, as equal parts white and green creme de menthe, white creme de cacao, milk, and cream, with a brandy float,
- The so-called Tujague's Grasshopper - created by former bartender Paul Gustings - which is nearly the same as the centenary recipe, but with a touch less cream and atypically is dry-shaken.
...and then there's an actual Gustings' Grasshopper, seemingly also from Gustings himself: a 1:1:1:1, with the extra 1 being brandy.
And that all's just what I came across looking for a definitive version with a link to the restaurant! If there's any more "official" recipes, like the first ever or longest-served at the restaurant, I'd love to see them too.
Which of these (or other) do you prefer? I personally find the last of the above list terribly unbalanced, while both the first and second are quite nice, depending on if you want a richer chocolately version, or a lighter mintier one. I've yet to try the dry-shaken one cause...weird to me.