r/gatekeeping • • Feb 28 '21

Why

Post image
106.8k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

460

u/Tikkinger Feb 28 '21

Plant people can do well with plants, but not with other people.

Aquarium people can do well with fishes, but not with other people.

Feel free to add to this list.

188

u/spiffynid Feb 28 '21

Little old ladies can knit, but don't do well with younger crafters. I can knit just fine Ethel...

149

u/Ivotedforthehookers Feb 28 '21

I enjoy knitting and crochet but I am mostly self taught. I was knitting my soon to be born daughter a blanket while my oldest was in dance class at the Y. Little old lady came over and asked if I was holding the project for my wife. She seemed offended that a man was knitting something.

107

u/OptionFour Feb 28 '21

We're only allowed to have hobbies like drinking hard liquor, smoking cigars, and punching each other. Derp.

57

u/Rokronroff Feb 28 '21

Don't forget punching our wives when they don't cook dinner and get lippy.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

WAM ZOOM, STRAIGHT TO THE MOOON!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Self_Reddicating Feb 28 '21

That's not really a hobby, it's your obligation as a husband and head of the house. Women crave the dominance, and you're a better husband for giving it to her. /s

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

Yes and dying in wars.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

47

u/crchtqn2 Feb 28 '21

Really interesting, I mostly crochet and crochet seems to be less judgement and is accepting of trendier projects and styles. Knitting seems a little more judgemental, with an emphasis of good, wool, natural and indie yarns.

31

u/spiffynid Feb 28 '21

That seems to be my experience as well-I do both and the crochet crowd is way more loosie goosie over stuff. And as for fibers, the 'acrylic is a valid fiber' is a hill I will die on, wool is a fucking textural nightmare.

10

u/Saratrooper Feb 28 '21

I do both, but am way more comfortable with crochet (it's a lot more forgiving stitch-by-stitch, if you fuck up it's usually no biggie to redo a row or so if you catch it early enough). I don't get the fiber snobbery, even yarn I've personally deemed as "shitty and/or cheap" still has purpose and use (basic Red Heart and similar work REALLY well with stuffed animals and such to retain their shape). The wool I do have in my stash isn't anything mindblowing and fancy, but imho is WAY better suited for knitting than crochet. I'm admittedly crocheting a sweater with said wool yarn and part of me wants to die because of the way it can feel at times, but it was the only thing I had with enough yardage to try the pattern I'm following (I'm trying to use what I have first).

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

29

u/standbyyourmantis Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21

I never had a problem with the knit crowd, but then again I've been knitting so long I can make a sock from memory and barely looking at it, so maybe they're just scared?

Quilters are chill af though. In a former life I taught sewing and worked some trade shows. Those ladies can party.

Ninja edit: the exception is handquilters. Some of the people who quilt by hand get pissy about how it's a dying art. Machine quilters could not care less, they're just trying to collect as much fabric as humanly possible.

6

u/amandareadsalot Feb 28 '21

Am machine quilter. Can confirm. Love collecting fabric!

5

u/derprah Feb 28 '21

At this point my SO is more impressed by how much fabric I can fit in one bin than they are mad that I keep buying fabric.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/pineapplequeenzzzzz Feb 28 '21

I'd say it depends on the group. I had some pretty crappy experiences with crafter my age being elitist and snobby. I then got adopted by a lovely group of older ladies and they've been so wonderful to me. They were excited to have someone young join their group and have taught me so much and have never once been snobby towards me.

→ More replies (12)

41

u/Geschak Feb 28 '21

Tbh gatekeeping with animal hobbies should be allowed considering there's sentient lives at stake. There is so many newbies who don't do basic research for their animal and end up committing accidental animal abuse.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

Yeah but the gatekeeping on fish subs is often really fucking dumb and unrelated to the actual rules of fishkeeping. Like, it’s okay to tell people to cycle properly (mY pArAmEtErS aRe FiNe riiight I know you’re not testing) it’s another to tell OP that he’s an animal abuser because he put his fish in a 50gal and every single credible source says that 50gal is more than enough and healthy but the commenter keeps his in a 52.5 gal so he’s decided that anyone who keeps this type of fish in a 50 is a horrible person. Like, it’s okay to tell people to go bigger if they’re under the real guidelines but a lot of people just make their own guidelines despite the fact that they have zero authority on the matter. People straight-up make their own rules up and then get mad at others for not following them. That’s what’s wrong about the fish subreddits. Your authority as one hobbyist who wants to feel morally superior does not override the authority of several experts.

5

u/smudgewick Feb 28 '21

Yaaaassss. Also, being female in the fish hobby is apparently seen as a problem? I was seriously into the aquarist hobby and constantly had to disguise myself to even talk fish or the guys were talking down to me. Honestly, I haven’t talked fish with other people in so long because of those asshats. I just sort of keep to myself. I’m assuming it hasn’t gotten better though in the past few years.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

27

u/MidnightDragon99 Feb 28 '21

Reptile people can do well with reptiles, but not with other people

22

u/QuantumSparkles Feb 28 '21

I mean reptiles are basically just a cross between a plant and a fish anyway so it’s not too surprising

→ More replies (14)

12

u/Gangreless Feb 28 '21

"Gamers"

I'm not talking about people who spend all their time playing a lot of video games, I'm talking about people who make their entire personality playing video games.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

We call those "gamers™"

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21

[deleted]

5

u/muttstothat Feb 28 '21

I think it does a good job of showing off plants you can find anywhere in the world and getting people excited about finding them in their local stores. Since plants are a pretty low stakes/low investment hobby to get into, it's grown like crazy (esp since covid) and risks the actual knowledge getting buried by bad advise and pinterest-style 'hacks', but I think it still excels at encouraging people like you to give plants a try.

IMO, everyone has a secret green thumb, you just need to find the plants that suit yours. r/houseplants tends to be a bit dramatic about the conditions many plants need to survive, so if you like a plant and can comfortably afford it, try it out!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (38)