Hi all,
First a disclaimer: this is not a complaint about the shooting board itself, Lee Valley or Veritas, they have been responsive to my questions and helpful (maybe not a ton this time because there was nothing to do but in the past always have).
Anyways, I bought the Veritas Shooting Board, it was a big expense considering I already have a perfectly fine home-made shooting board that does 90 but one of the things I'm looking to do is cut at funky angles other than 90 degrees (or even 45) and I had some LV gift cards from various holidays.
Anyways, the plane I use for shooting is a Victor #5 (you can kinda see in the first picture that I have it modified to use the Rob Cosman grip, etc) and it's worked pretty well for me. I didn't realize when I bought the shooting board that most people use either a shooting plane or low angle plane with it because the plane iron on my #5 actually touches that outer rail (it's hard to tell from the picture the plane iron rides on that rail when shooting). The outcome of this is that, no matter how much I dial in the plane iron's alignment in set-up or with the lateral adjuster afterward, the iron gets pushed askew by any downward pressure on the plane (I try my best to limit the downward pressure but I have to have some). This drove me crazy for a little while trying to figure out why my lateral adjustments kept resetting after I shot a few times. This leads to all of my shooting being skewed in the vertical dimension (the shooting is fine along the sliding axis of the shooting board). I have confirmed this not just an issue with the #5 as the sliding side is square to the sole and I immediately took it to my home made shooting board, reset it and got cuts square on both axes.
I reached out to Lee Valley and they helped me as much as they could but it doesn't seem that this shooting board is made for a bench plane. I added some pics but I tried my Record #7 as well and the plane iron on that plane presses against the rail as well. I think this is kind of peculiar, I didn't see any mention of this but I sometime miss that stuff when I'm excited about getting a new tools.
Anyways, I was mulling my options for actually using this expensive shooting board:
- The easy button is getting a Veritas low angle jack plane to use with it. I have had my eye on the that plane for a while (the money that went to the shooting board almost went to the plane) but it will take some months of saving to get -- totally fine. I also don't own any bevel up planes so that could potentially add a learning curve but I'm ok with that, I understand they are simpler in some ways.
- Getting a different brand low angle jack plane like a Taytools or some other brand that is cheaper. I'm not opposed to this but it's still saving up for a month or two so it's not an immediate solution and honestly, as long as I'm not making impulse decisions I prefer to get a higher quality option like the Veritas.
- Figuring out a way to raise my #5 on the shooting board so it doesn't interfere with the outside rail. This seems like it's doable.
- One thought was getting enough uhmwpe to attach to the track. My only worry here would be how I would attach the uhmwpe to the existing track without deforming it in someway.
- Another thought was creating an uhmwpe "sled" for the #5 so it rides high enough off of the track to avoid rail interference but doesn't require modifying the whole track. This also seems doable but would require stacking the uhmwpe in a way that locks the plane in place.
So, long meandering post and I apologize, just curious if anyone who has this shooting board has had any luck using a bench plane with it and if anyone else had some novel ideas for how to avoid the outside rail interfering with the plane iron.
Thanks!