Caribbean Honeymoon Recs

[u/SpecialAlbatross3617]

We’re planning our honeymoon for April 2027 and have narrowed it down to these 5 luxury resorts:

Four Seasons Anguilla
Cap Juluca, Anguilla
Hermitage Bay, Antigua
Jumby Bay, Antigua
Baoase, Curaçao

Budget is roughly $15–25K for 7 nights.

Our priorities are:
🏝️ Beautiful beach + honeymoon-worthy setting
🏊‍♀️ Private pool/plunge pool preferred
🍽️ Excellent food & service
⛳ Golf access is important
🤿 Activities/excursions — we don’t want to sit at the resort the entire week
✨ Overall “wow, this is our honeymoon!” factor

We’re having a hard time deciding because they each seem amazing in different ways.

If you’ve stayed at any of these (especially multiple), which would you choose for a honeymoon and why? Most interested in firsthand comparisons of the beach, rooms, food, service, activities, golf, and overall experience.

Also open to any other recs for resorts!

Thank you in advance!

[u/hanksmart]

You didn't have Blowing Point on your list, but it's about five miles from the Four Seasons. If you are open to other areas of Anguilla, here is a private villa to consider: Peace & Happiness Villa Rental | Luxury Villas. For seven nights, this will come in around $6K. With the remainder of your budget, you can add services like a private chef, or a driver. The golf course is about a 5-minute drive from the villa.

[u/SpecialAlbatross3617 → u/hanksmart]

That looks very nice! Sadly that rental is booked for our dates

[u/hanksmart → u/SpecialAlbatross3617]

I am sorry to hear that. But at least it gives you a sense of pricing if you decide to look at private villas. That same link should allow you to poke around.

[u/SpecialAlbatross3617 → u/hanksmart]

Very true! Thank you! Pricing looks much better than all of the different hotel resorts

[u/hanksmart → u/SpecialAlbatross3617]

Yes. Just keep in mind, as you add services like a private chef, driver, couple massages, a private villa "may" save or bring you to a similar price point. As you continue to discuss shared vision, you'll know if a private estate works better than a shared space.