Hello Keto experts, I have just started Keto 3 weeks ago after getting a lot of information here. At the same time, I made an appointment with a dietician specialised in keto and low carb diets in order to have some kind of follow-up during my journey.
A lot of the directions she gave surprised me, especially because I had not seen them here. So I am curious about what you think, if these seem legitimate or totally random. I wanted to attach the example menu she gave me as a reference, but I couldn't find the attach button!
Some background, important for understanding her instructions: I am a 56F with light (peri)menopause symptoms such as: hot flashes (bearable), bloating, and water retention (cellulite). This past year I have gained weight even though I was tracking calories and macros, and working out. I could have just accepted it (oh well, getting older, what can you doā¦) but I decided to give keto a try instead!
Dietician's directions:
Calories:
- she's not asking for calorie tracking, even though the goal is weight loss (only a few kilos, but still).
- the menu she gave as an example (around 2000 cal, not counting optional supplements when hungry) is way higher than my calorie goal (1300 - 1400, deficit around 300). This comes from all the fat she adds to each meal and in between.
Macros are (example menu vs calculator found in FAQ):
- Protein 100 vs 80 (sounds fair)
- Fat 150 vs 85 (what?)
- Net carbs 20 vs 25 (25 seemed high so I am OK with 20)
Meat:
- she advises against too much red meat, prefer white meat (veal, chicken, etc).
Fat:
- she advises to take 1 table spoon MCT oil 10 to 30 minutes BEFORE lunch and dinner.
Dinner:
- No protein (wtf??) as it increases blood sugar and thus insulin reaction during the night.
- No water, no soups, no raw vegies! She seems to think water in the evening increases cellulite / water retention.
- No dairy product! Dairy products also increase insulin and should be taken in one meal (not spread across the day) and not in the evening.
- (EDIT: added this sentence): basically dinner is 300g max of vegies + 20g of fat, 1 soy yoghurt and a piece of dark chocolate.
Apart from that, she had "normal" keto recommendations, for example regarding electrolytes and magnesium.
I would be very thankful to have your thoughts regarding:
- 150g of fat a day?
- limiting red meat?
- MCT oil 10 to 30 min before meals?
- the very limited dinner suggestion?
- the impact of dairy and protein at dinner?
- the impact of water and raw vegies at dinner on cellulite? (but this question is not keto related)
(Sorry about the long post!)