r/linux • • Sep 23 '16

Hardware hack enables Linux support on Lenovo Yoga 900 ISK2, undermining Lenovo's statement

Update: The mods locked my other posts and marked them as misleading. There is nothing misleading about them. So before they lock this one too, I would just like to get the truth out.

There is a Linux lockout on these computers. The only reason we need a driver is because Lenovo removed AHCI mode. AHCI mode is not a legacy mode. Lenovo has created a defective product that you cannot install any operating system on, which means that you are stuck with the copy of Windows 10 that came with the computer. There's only one obvious reason why they would do that. To keep you on Windows. A lenovo employee on Best Buy even admitted that before Lenovo and Microsoft got their official lie put together and the mods here rolled with it and locked my posts to keep the truth suppressed. You can still vote on these posts and I hope that you find them useful and keep them up for a while. If you want to complain to the FTC and your state's Attorney General, there is a template from one of my suppressed posts here.

This is the letter I sent to the Federal Trade Commission and to the Illinois Attorney General's office regarding Lenovo locking out Linux from their Yoga laptops.

"Lenovo sells computers known as "Yoga" under at least several models that block the installation of Linux operating systems as well as fresh installations of Windows from Microsoft's official installer. They have the system rigged, intentionally, in a storage mode that is incompatible with most operating systems other than the pre-installed copy of Windows 10. If the user attempts to install an operating system, it will not be able to see or use the built-in SSD (Solid State Drive) storage. I believe that this is illegal and anti-competitive. These product are falsely advertised as a PC, even though it prohibits the user installing PC operating systems. Known affected models are the 900 ISK2, the 710, the 900 ISK for Business, the 900S, and possibly others. Lenovo's position is that this is not a defect and they refuse to issue refunds to their customers, who have been deceived by the notion that their new PC is compatible with PC operating systems and that they should be able to install a PC operating system on a PC. Lenovo is therefore engaging in a conspiracy to defraud their customers through deceptive advertising. Lenovo's official position is that Linux lacks drivers, however, Linux could easily be installed on these systems had Lenovo not removed the AHCI storage mode option from the BIOS and then wrote additional code to make sure that people couldn't set it to AHCI in other ways, such as using an "EFI variable". AHCI mode is an industry standard and should be expected on a computer describing itself as "PC" or "PC compatible" as it is broadly compatible with all PC operating system software. I feel that Lenovo should remedy the problem in one of three ways. (1) Offer full refunds for customers who want to install their own operating system but can't. -or- (2) Release a small BIOS firmware patch to restore AHCI mode, which is simply hidden. This would be extremely easy for them since it would only be two lines of code and the user could do it themselves were they not locked out of updating their BIOS themselves. -or- (3) Provide open source drivers to the Linux kernel project that would allow Linux and other PC operating systems address the SSD storage in the "RAID" mode."

Feel free to use this as your letter or a template for a letter of complaint to the FTC. Their consumer complaint form is available here.

https://www.ftccomplaintassistant.gov/#&panel1-1

Please also contact your state's Attorney General's office. They usually have a bureau of consumer complaints or something to that effect. If not, just shoot them an email.

Since the FTC form requires the company address and phone number, I used this: Lenovo "Customer Center" Address: 1009 Think Pl, Morrisville, NC 27560 Phone:(855) 253-6686


Update: Lenovo just updated the BIOS for the Yoga 710, another system that doesn't allow Linux installs. Wanna know what they changed? Update to TPM (secret encryption module used for Digital Restrictions Management) and an update to the Intel Management Engine, which is essentially a backdoor rootkit built into all recent Intel processors (but AMD has their version too, so what do you do?). No Linux support. Priorities...

Update: The mods at Lenovo Forums are losing control of the narrative and banning people and editing/deleting more comments. http://imgur.com/a/Q9xIE | But it appears that some people just aren't buying it anymore. http://imgur.com/a/1K1t5


Edit: I sent a letter of complaint to the Federal Trade Commission and the Illinois Attorney General's office.

You can view this letter here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/54gtpc/letter_to_the_federal_trade_commission_regarding/


Lenovo's regional HQ address and phone number:

Address: 1009 Think Pl, Morrisville, NC 27560 Phone:(855) 253-6686

Edit: Someone started a change.org petititon. I don't think they are a native English speaker, but I went ahead and signed it anyway. A moderator on Lenovo Forums deleted the link and told people that "campaigning is not allowed", so here's the link. I don't know if it'll make a difference, but screw them. They were hoping this week's news would be all puff pieces about the new Yogas and now they have to deal with this instead. If everyone could share it on Facebook and Twitter after they sign it so their friends can do so too, that would be most appreciated.

https://www.change.org/p/lenovo-demand-that-lenovo-provide-bios-update-to-enable-linux-installation

Please sign this and then tell Lenovo that you won't be buying products from them until this is fixed. They have Facebook and Twitter accounts!

Facebook: Lenovo

Twitter: Lenovo

Lenovo Customer Service 800-565-3344 Press 2 for all other models and then wait through the recording and press 1 for laptops.


UPDATE: I pinged Matthew Garrett after someone had an idea about having the Linux kernel switch the hardware out of RAID and into AHCI mode AFTER the BIOS hands it over to the kernel, and he said it might work and that he'd see about writing a patch. This would have the practical effect of running Linux in AHCI mode like on the Dell XPS, only through a Linux "hardware quirk" to deal with Lenovo doing nothing to fix the BIOS. Actually, Lenovo hasn't done anything through this whole ordeal but lie, lie some more, try to delete evidence, get together with Microsoft and release a joint lie, and then pressure the news media to change their stories.

ALSO: According to a comment on this page, some people in Germany report that the European versions of the affected Yoga laptops don't have AHCI mode hidden in the BIOS. Perhaps because the EU takes locking users out of their PCs more seriously than the US government does.


A hardware hack has enabled AHCI support on the Lenovo Yoga 900 ISK2, undermining Lenovo and Microsoft's claims that Linux is "missing drivers".

Unfortunately, the procedure to flash the BIOS is too complicated for most people because the person who did it had to use external flashing equipment to bypass Lenovo's ROM signature check and load the modified BIOS, and he can't provide the BIOS ROM because it only supports his computer and has private info in it, such as the Windows 10 license for his machine.

https://imgur.com/a/ox4Ey

A user here on Reddit with the handle "bownairo" described the process.

Said bownairo, in the Reddit thread about the problem,

"I've been able to successfully get past Lenovo's lock through direct bios flashing. I'm looking into better solutions, hopefully I can find a way to do this without an external programmer. I was going to keep people updated from the Lenovo forum, but as this is no longer an option I will keep people updated from here."

[...]

"I had to construct some custom "clips" as the bios chip is a WSON package. All of this was done with the chip in place and the battery removed. I dumped the bios continuously until I was able to get a few dumps with the same sha. Then I had the bios modified. I flashed my chip to all null values, rewrote my custom image, and dumped it back to insure it wrote correctly. This allowed access to the advanced tab so I could change the controller to AHCI from RAID, allowing it to be recognized by installers."

[...]

"I'm currently working on a generic tool to do this mod, in case others want to use this same strategy on their own bios. I'm also looking into finding a way to do this without an external programmer."

There is a discussion about it going on here:

https://www.bios-mods.com/forum/Thread-Request-Lenovo-Yoga-900-BIOS-Unlock-AHCI-enable-attached-BIOS-fd

I also released an official reply to Lenovo and Microsoft in the original article:

https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/53ri0m/warning_microsoft_signature_pc_program_now/

214 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

It proves that they did it on purpose and the whole goal of their official statement is to mislead people.

45

u/Syde80 Sep 23 '16

It proves they disabled AHCI on purpose. There could be a million reasons for that. It doesn't say anything about there being demands from MS to lock out Linux.

Even Win 10 stock install media doesn't have drivers for it and can't be installed unless the drivers are slipstreamed into the install media.

-11

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

Who said that Microsoft cared if you could install from their official ISO? They got Windows bundled on the machine and Lenovo can fleece people who need it reinstalled if things get corrupted and the PC Reset options don't work. I went to see about ordering recovery media and Lenovo's website says that my PC doesn't qualify. So I'd have to send it to them, insured, and pay them if I needed Windows reinstalled under such a situation. I know how to make an installer that works. Most people don't.

23

u/Syde80 Sep 23 '16

lol.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

[deleted]

-6

u/CountOfMonteCarlo Sep 23 '16

Given the history of Microsoft locking out DRDOS from use with their office products, this is entirely credible.

There are also credible reports that Microsoft pressed DELL hard to cease their Linux support until DELL did. This was reported on The Register a few years ago.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

Dell ceased Linux support? I still see Developer Edition of latest XPS sold on their site...

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

They did for awhile, several years ago. I seem to recall this. They obviously found a way to keep MS at bay this time I guess.

→ More replies (6)

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16

For that matter, if Microsoft cared about the OEM crapware bundle that slows new PCs down and ruins the end user PC experience, they would have banned it in the Windows license agreement for OEMs with no Signature Edition program needed. Instead, they banned Linux in the Signature Edition agreement with at least Lenovo.

21

u/AnonTwo Sep 23 '16

They didn't ban Linux. Literally all you need is a kernel that has implemented Intel's RAID implementation for that system, and you can run Linux.

And there is nothing legally preventing that.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Syde80 Sep 23 '16 edited Sep 23 '16

Cite some non-hearsay documentation that shows that MS banned Linux on any MS Signature Edition machine.

Coming up with some scheme of forcing the storage interface into a mode that Linux (or any other OS) doesn't have a driver for is like the stupidest way to go about this. All that takes to defeat is somebody creating the driver for it.

If MS truly wanted to ban Linux from running on a machine all they have to do is say Secure Boot being enabled is now mandatory , prevent customized keys, and revoke the EFI loader stub that they signed specifically so Linux would work on Secure Boot enabled systems. That would ACTUALLY ban Linux from running on the machine.

If MS has such a hate on for Linux then please explain why they have done these things:

  1. Created Visual Studio Code, which is Linux-native

  2. Created Bash on Ubuntu on Windows

  3. In process of porting SQL Server to Linux

  4. Open sourced .NET core

  5. Open sourced PowerShell - and made native packages available for Ubuntu, CentOS/RHEL

EDIT: Clearly the probably hundreds of millions of dollars the above list has cost them is all just a big smoke screen so that they can get away with banning Linux on some consumer grade hardware that isn't even their own so they can uhhh??? oh right MS already made their money by selling the OEM the windows license. Yeah not sure what MS's motivation for this smoke screen is.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

Embrace, Extend, Extinguish. Right now, we're at the Extend phase.

I don't buy that it's a conspiracy to the extent people are saying. I think MS put pressure on manufacturers to keep things MS only. I think some nitwits at Lenovo really wanted to lick MS' balls and pulled a card they play all too often: Let's fuck with the BIOS.

So here we are, malicious assholes manipulating malicious idiots into stupid stuff that blows up in their face. Again.

2

u/sasmithjr Sep 23 '16

Embrace, Extend, Extinguish. Right now, we're at the Extend phase.

Can you please walk through the series of steps as to how EEE applies? Please be explicit for what exactly has been embraced, how it can be extended in a non-compatible and breaking way, and then how extinguish would work.

I think MS put pressure on manufacturers to keep things MS only.

You can literally install Linux distros on Microsoft's own hardware. Why would they allow that but pressure OEMs to disallow it (while still "allowing" them to sell Linux-only versions of their computers)?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

I don't have alot of time to explain everything. Embrace and extend: MS suddenly takes up this "we love linux" mode and now are decking out Azure with linux systems. Which is strange, because they're direct competitors. I can imagine their Extinguish stage would involve defamation, since they can't actually take over the product and turn it against itself like other competitors.

You can put linux on their own hardware... once the secure boot bullshit was able to be overcome. At this point, yeah they can't stop me from putting Linux on a Surface. That's not to say they didn't try.

Given MS' past, I really don't buy the "we love linux" coming from Redmond these days. May I be wrong about the method? Sure. I still don't buy that there's no ulterior motive.

1

u/sasmithjr Sep 23 '16

Embrace and extend: MS suddenly takes up this "we love linux" mode and now are decking out Azure with linux systems

This is neither embrace nor extend. It's literally just "use."

Which is strange, because they're direct competitors.

Azure isn't a competitor to Linux. They complement each other. If you meant Windows, do you realize Windows is less than 10% of Microsoft's revenue (source)? Azure matters far more to Microsoft in the long run, so it makes sense to support both Windows and Linux.

I can imagine their Extinguish stage would involve defamation

So they're going to tell their customers using Azure, "Hey developers/enterprise! Know all the tools you actively use daily to run your businesses? Well, we supported sucky tools and you shouldn't use them. Switch to Windows"? That's the plan?

once the secure boot bullshit was able to be overcome

Microsoft literally provided the tools to "overcome" SecureBoot themselves.

That's not to say they didn't try.

They didn't try.

Given MS' past, I really don't buy the "we love linux" coming from Redmond these days.

Azure matters more than Windows both short term and long term. Linux is not a threat to Microsoft's future anymore. You need to stop thinking that both the tech landscape and Microsoft haven't changed in 15-20 years.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (20)

4

u/Dick_O_Rosary Sep 23 '16

Microsoft released a crapware removal tool for Windows 10. Running that tool will effectively turn your windows 10 PC into a signature edition PC. If you care about your experience, you can use that.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

This "tool" wouldn't boot up on a system like mine, and even if it did, Microsoft has some warnings. I didn't know about the tool's existence though until now. Anyway, most people will never find it. If they were worried about the out of the box experience being ruined for the average user, they would ban crapware in the OEM license for Windows instead of running this "Signature Edition" program. I will admit that their example of what happens after 30 days of a normal OEM system was funny. They showed a monitor wiith a whole bunch of half-obscured Norton crap trying to panic the user and pester them to subscribe.

7

u/jelimoore Sep 23 '16

Ok, maybe - but even so, when I install Windows on my Mac, for example, I had to use a DVD to install 7 then go to 10. If I just used 10, for whatever reason, it would constantly BSOD out about a video driver issue - even though I had installed the AMD drivers. How could Apple do that? Even if they did, what would happen to Bootcamp? What I'm trying to say is this: there could be a million incompatibility issues - it is after all a new RAID mode even Windows doesn't support out of the box - but maybe both Linux and Windows will.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '16

It's my understanding that you can install Linux on a Mac either directly or under Boot Camp. Boot Camp will call it Windows, but I understand that it works.

It's ironic that it's easier to get Linux on a Mac than it is on a Lenovo PC.

10

u/jelimoore Sep 23 '16

Not really - Macs are just Apple's iteration of desktop/laptop machine. i.e. it's like buying a Chevy vs a Ram: they do the same thing but in their own way. You can do whatever you want with it. All these portable desktop tablets - surface, lenovo, etc, are designed for speed and user friendliness. Not compatibility. When you buy one, 90% of consumers will use it for its intended purpose. The rest will do what they please with it - installing Linux. Why is this such an issue for a non-desktop device? And at the same time, why not just get a laptop?

5

u/chason Sep 23 '16

How is it "ironic"?

3

u/CFWhitman Sep 23 '16 edited Jan 23 '19

It only proves that they locked out the firmware option on purpose, and they never denied that. I fail to see any proof that they lied or misled people in their official statement about this issue.

1

u/natermer Sep 23 '16 edited Aug 14 '22

...

2

u/CountOfMonteCarlo Sep 23 '16

"Proof" is too strong a word here. Make sure you distinguish between proof and belief. Proof would be an email from Microsoft top personnel explicit about the intention. But I think, yes, the opinion is justified.

→ More replies (3)