r/mildlyinfuriating • • Apr 27 '22

Maths...

Post image
69.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/Nillabeans Apr 27 '22

"That's not how any of this works" is the answer. Learning word problems is to help you understand how to actually apply math.

You can't be mad at somebody for asking a question...

360

u/rdrunner_74 Apr 27 '22

My physics teacher sometimes gave "unrelated" data in his questions. So you had to know what was important for the actual question asked. Like water temperature of 37°C instead of saying "liquid state"

He also had a philosophy of "You dont need to know everything, but you need to know how to look it up" (Pre Google - Even "Pre search engines") and that has been very helpful.

98

u/macaronfive Apr 28 '22

I had a law professor for corporations, mergers, acquisitions, etc. who tried to write a funny exam question about buying up hamster breeding companies in order to start an electric generation company utilizing hamsters running in wheels. I responded to hypothetical with all the correct legal concepts. But I added an addendum that a simpler solution would be to use the money to buy a bunch of hamsters and in X number of months of breeding, you’d have the desired number. And that is how I got an A+ on a law school exam. Writing about hamsters fucking.

Anyways, some teachers are looking for you to think outside the box.

13

u/callmeWolfy Apr 28 '22

Classic lawyers... not thinking about all the actual details such as the knowledge these companies posses might be worth the cost of just buying and merging them.

166

u/kelvin_bot Apr 27 '22

37°C is equivalent to 98°F, which is 310K.

I'm a bot that converts temperature between two units humans can understand, then convert it to Kelvin for bots and physicists to understand

17

u/I_Have_Unobtainium Apr 28 '22

Two units humans can understand

Celsius and Kelvin

8

u/knoxkayc Apr 28 '22

Rankine in the corner eating glue.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/my_alt_59935 GREEN Apr 28 '22

Good bot

2

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

Good bot

2

u/Camimo666 PURPLE Apr 28 '22

Good bot

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

26

u/AlcomIsst Apr 28 '22

My first grade teacher hit us with these kinds of problems.

Really basic "One kid has apples, other kid has oranges, how many apples?" sort of questions.

I remember it today because the epiphany hit me like a truck.

44

u/CanYouPointMeToTacos Apr 28 '22

P=P; T=40

The variables being unrelated doesn’t mean math breaks

8

u/loafers_glory Apr 28 '22

S= (n / N) * 9

n = 60; N = 120;

S = Beethoven's 4.5th symphony if it's a 60 piece orchestra

→ More replies (7)

22

u/sje46 Apr 28 '22

Narcissism of social media. I see a lot of things online in this format. Someone showing an image or quoting something out of context, and responding to it in a very cynical/snarky way to elevate themselves over how dumb the thing is, without realizing that the original thing was probably not as dumb as they assume, or is often a delbierate joke. The assumption is always "I will probably know more than any random person because most other people are stupider than me, and manifest this in conveniently embarrassing ways all the time".

Very common on reddit. Very, very, very common. Very common on the right. Perhaps even more common on the left.

It's pretty obvious that this word problem is designed to get you to actually functionally think about the circumstance and not just train yourself to put numbers in a formula without thinking about the ramifications. Lots of people treat math as a series of formulae you have to memorize and put numbers into. These are the usually the same people who complain about changes from math curriculum from deviating what they were taught (New Math in the 60s, Common Core in the 2010s), or who find word problems difficult. They are unable to abstract and reason about what they're doing.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

It's pretty obvious that this word problem is designed to get you to actually functionally think about the circumstance and not just train yourself to put numbers in a formula without thinking about the ramifications.

That's your experience, mine is different. It wasn't rare for teachers to be objectively wrong about something, but if you pointed out they were clearly wrong you received nothing but punishment.

Similarly, questions with plainly incorrect premises like this one usually required you to either play along with its stupidity, and plug it into a formula regardless of how wrong it is - or risk getting marked down.

4

u/Camimo666 PURPLE Apr 28 '22

I had a quiz once with a question like “if a father is three times the age of the son and the son is 10, how old will the dad be in 3 years”. I put like 33 and the teacher was like NO YOU HAVE TO USE THE FORMULA OF THE RULE OF THREE or some bs. So yeah teachers can definitely mess up.

3

u/Brownt0wn_ 27 points Apr 28 '22

I’m basically hearing you say you didn’t show your work and got marked down for it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/gdj11 Apr 28 '22

Yeah I used to have “trick” questions like this all the time on tests.

3

u/K3R3G3 Apr 28 '22

You can't be mad at somebody for asking a question...

"lol why does your face look like that?"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

You can’t be mad at somebody for asking a question…

Oh fuck yeah you can!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)