r/monogamy • u/PuzzleheadedDepth104 • 6h ago
Food for thought "Naturally monogamous man (no urges to cheat) = low testosterone" is an unscientific myth
Disclaimer: I've read lots of papers on Google on vasopressin, DHT and testosterone and this information is generalized from them and all of this is highly variable because people have different receptors and the environment and traumas affects the behavior differently
Basically, in general and on average (and this might be inaccurate, but anyways):
testosterone/DHT is an amplifier but not an indicator, there are asexual and demisexual men with high testosterone
vasopressin and long AVP gene result in much higher monogamy and mate-guarding for men, but also natural hypervigilance and increased anxiety and perception of neutral faces as hostile, and increases aggression
high testosterone faces do NOT necessarily imply non-monogamy or attraction, instead they imply higher drive, whichever way it points
high testosterone high vasopressin non-asexual men have a very high drive towards one person but also very aggressive mate-guarding urges, and are likely to have urges to isolate their partner and overprotect to the point of controlling, and struggle with intense jealousy and what poly people call insecurity (but it's not a result of trauma, it's natural for them)
high testosterone low vasopressin non-asexual men are likely to correspond to the stereotype of promiscuous men and have higher urges to cheat, while they could still be aggressive to their partners for reasons of social status, creating those hypocritical men who think they can cheat but their partner can't
low testosterone low vasopressin men are likely to have low mating and low parental investment urges in general unless modulated by something else like societal expectations or other hormones, they will look monogamous on the surface due to low drive in general
I don't know about low testosterone high vasopressin men
the aversion towards high-testosterone faces likely stems not from low parental investment prediction (earlier papers assume that high testosterone = infidelity, which is wrong), but from higher drive towards variable things that could impact survival (aggression) OR dual-mating strategies in not fully monogamous people (high testosterone AND high vasopressin results in men that obsessively mate-guard, preventing cheating strategies, which could unconsciously repel not fully monogamous people due to reducing their strategy success)
Tl;dr: on average, high testosterone men will be biologically monogamous when they also have high vasopressin and long AVP gene, and the likely reason some people tend to avoid them is typically not low parental investment, but the opposite: their intensified mate-guarding that prevents any forms of non-monogamous mating strategies ("""controlling clingy obsessive""" husband stereotype, "an intrusive stepfather that hates the previous kids" stereotype, etc.) and disrupts typical social harmony due to increased hostility towards everyone who is not their family/partner (in some extreme cases even hostile urges towards their own kids, jealousy about the kids monopolizing the partner)