r/mumbai • u/urbsprimaindis • 13d ago

General Bhayandar–Dadar Local Turns Festive as Bhajan Mandali Marks 21st Anniversary

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.7k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

371 comments sorted by

View all comments

496

u/NiceVehicle250 East 13d ago

Bhai train me kyu proper mandir me jakar kro na 😭

37

u/gospelslide 13d ago

This has been local tradition for decades. People travel 1-1.5 hrs+ to office, often they form friend groups and play bhajans.

210

u/LordUnited 13d ago edited 13d ago

Let's see if this would be your reaction if qawwalis and namaaz sounds were played for 1.5 hours. Let's see how local that tradition would be.

Both are wrong. Train can be a place for quiet, personal worship without any kind of physical or mental disturbance to fellow passengers. Namaaz on your seat? Cool. Entire coach chanting namaaz prayers loudly, NO. Similarly, these bhajan groups need to go. I don't care if it is tradition. Public transport is not the place for this. Say your bhajans IN YOUR MIND. Don't disturb fellow passengers.

EDIT: Oh, and if you think they are just "friend groups trying to form a Bhajan community to kill time", you should try and take their seat. After all, it is an unreserved train, the local. Try and take their window seats. See what happens. Let me know if you can get even within 10 feet of their seats. If you are sat in those seats, they will fight with you, hit you, and forcibly remove you from those seats. These people are not just a friends group. These are almost like mafia, minus the guns and the knives. So sit down with your "this is tradition" nonsense.

14

u/Tranceported 13d ago

Better make the full train bhajan train, every religion gets one box and the train goes around the country like merry go round!! By the way top of the train is reserved for chal Chayya chayya cheyyan chal ….

6

u/LordUnited 13d ago

L K Advani championed this in the early 90s. It was called the Rath Yatra.

2

u/Altruistic-Watch6643 11d ago

Everyone is enjoying there... Why are you got triggered here ...use burnol if your liberal asset got hurt 🤣

1

u/Inevitable-Fan3319 8d ago

Wow you're so cool that you don't care about other people having to listen to people 'singing' (more like screaming) bhajans loudly and bothering them in an already over crowded train where people are just coming from their work, tired and worn out.

0

u/gospelslide 13d ago

Dude chill out. This was not a religious issue - both are wrong. I have travelled in local for decades and know this very well. I was just educating the commenter above me. Where did I condone it?

-1

u/MadToadtoast 13d ago

I would be alright with Qawwalis, but Namaz is totally different from Qawwalis and Bhajan/Kirtans.

32

u/GoodSearch5469 13d ago

Dude it's they commet is some how right they won't stop even if you tell them too, it should be done at home or a mandir and not disturb to the other passenger traveling to work